Haunted Hotels in New York State: The Most Haunted Places to Stay
From a Catskills hotel that runs ghost hunts every night to a castle on Seneca Lake and a Manhattan legend, these are the haunted hotels in New York State you can actually book.
New York State packs in Revolutionary War forts, Gilded Age resorts, canal towns and the country’s biggest city, and its hotels have collected ghost stories to match. Every hotel below is open to guests, has a ghost story told by staff, guests or local historians, and has been checked against current sources. We have kept every hotel from our previous list, added the Sagamore on Lake George, the Red Coach Inn at Niagara Falls and three Manhattan hotels from our guide to haunted hotels in NYC, and rated each one for the strength of its ghost stories, its real history and how easy it is to stay in the haunted rooms. Several of these hotels also appear on the state’s Haunted History Trail. For ghost stories beyond hotels, see our guides to haunted places in New York and upstate New York.
$$ · $150 to $300Haunted room bookableGhost tours or eventsHotel embraces its ghostsHaunted Rooms ghost hunts
Address 56 Main Street, Napanoch, NY 12458
Where to look Esther's Room, Rosie's Room and the bordello rooms, the Gentleman's Quarters, the Silent Room
Reported ghosts Beatrice Shanley; little Rosie Greger; Frank the bordello bodyguard; Esther Faughman
Booking the haunted room Every room is a named haunted room (Esther's Room, Rosie's Room, the Gentleman's Quarters and more), booked directly with the hotel as part of an overnight ghost hunt.
The Shanley is a big wooden hotel on Main Street in the Catskills hamlet of Napanoch. A hotel has stood here since 1845; the present building went up after a fire in 1895, and James Shanley bought it in 1906. He and his wife Beatrice lost all three of their babies in infancy, and the barber’s three-year-old daughter Rosie drowned in a well across the road. The hotel later stood empty for years before reopening as a ghost-hunting destination.
Today the Shanley lives entirely for its ghosts. Overnight guests take part in a staff-led ghost hunt and can then investigate on their own, and the owners say they have made contact with more than 30 spirits, from Beatrice and Rosie to a bordello bodyguard called Frank. Rooms are named for the people in its stories, and most share bathrooms. It has appeared on Ghost Hunters and Ghost Lab.
Haunted Rooms tip: Book a room night that includes the public ghost hunt, then ask for Esther’s Room or one of the bordello rooms (Rosie’s, Maddie’s or Anna’s).
Where to look Room 410, Rooms 408 and 409, the mezzanine, the old Lamplighter Pub, the closed upper floors
Reported ghosts Charlie the Tuxedo Man; the White Lady of the mezzanine; phantom party sounds; a housekeeper seen at 2 a.m.
Booking the haunted room Book any standard room, then call the hotel and request Room 410 (or 408 or 409). Requests are not guaranteed.
Hotel Utica opened in 1912 as one of the grandest hotels between New York City and Buffalo. Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt stayed here, Amelia Earhart was honored at a 1928 luncheon and Judy Garland sang on the mezzanine. It closed in 1972 and spent about two decades as an adult care home before a $13 million restoration brought it back in 2001. Since 2017 it has traded as the DoubleTree by Hilton Utica.
Staff stories made it one of upstate New York’s best-known haunted hotels. Room 410 is said to call the front desk while empty, with only static on the line, and the shower has been found running in the same room. A man in a tuxedo, nicknamed Charlie, is linked to the mezzanine and the old pub, and guests on the fourth floor hear party noise from floors that are closed to the public.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for Room 410, or 408 or 409 next door, when you book, then check the request again at the desk on arrival.
Where to look The third-floor corridor, the fifth floor, the Glimmerglass Room, the ballroom
Reported ghosts Giggling girls and running feet on the third floor; shadow figures in old-fashioned clothes on the fifth floor
The Otesaga is the grand lakeside hotel of Cooperstown, built by the brothers Edward Severin Clark and Stephen Carlton Clark and opened on July 12, 1909. Its portico of eight 30-foot columns looks out over Otsego Lake, and Stephen Clark went on to found the National Baseball Hall of Fame a short walk away. From 1920 the hotel also housed the Knox School for Girls in the winter months.
Ghost Hunters filmed here for its sixth season, and staff and guests tell the same stories again and again. Children are heard giggling and running along the third-floor corridor when there are no children staying, which many link to the old girls’ school. On the top floor people hear furniture dragged across the floor above them, and shadowy figures in early 20th-century clothes have been seen walking hand in hand.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for a room on the third or fifth floor of the main hotel, and have a drink in the Glimmerglass Room, where staff say voices call their names.
$$ · $150 to $300Haunted room bookableGhost tours or eventsHotel embraces its ghostsPet friendly
Address 6387 Mill Street, Rhinebeck, NY 12572
Where to look The Tavern and its dining room, the wine cellar and kitchen, the basement, the attic, Rooms 21 and 22
Reported ghosts A dark figure rising from the wine cellar; footsteps, whispers and cold drafts in Rooms 21 and 22
Booking the haunted room Rooms 21 and 22 are the rooms named in the ghost stories. Request one by phone on (845) 876-7077; it is a request, not a guarantee.
The Beekman Arms in Rhinebeck calls itself America’s oldest continuously operating inn. Its roots go back to William Traphagen’s tavern of the early 1700s, and the inn has stood at the crossroads of the old King’s Highway, now Route 9, since 1766. George Washington, Alexander Hamilton and Franklin D. Roosevelt all passed through, and FDR closed his campaigns from its front porch. Today it shares about 80 rooms with the 1844 Delamater Inn down the street.
Historic Hotels of America put the Beekman Arms on its 2025 list of most haunted hotels. Guests and staff report footsteps, cold drafts, odd smells and whispers, above all in Rooms 21 and 22. Employees tell of a dark figure that rises from the wine cellar and crosses the kitchen, and staff call the old basement the most haunted part of the building. The inn has hosted ghost story evenings down there.
Haunted Rooms tip: Call the inn and ask for Room 21 or 22 in the main building, then have dinner in the Tavern, the oldest part of the inn.
$$$ · Over $300Hotel embraces its ghostsPet friendly
Address 110 Sagamore Road, Bolton Landing, NY 12814
Where to look The former Trillium dining room and its elevator, the old Mr. Brown's dining room, the golf course near the Club Grill, second-floor rooms
Reported ghosts A Victorian couple at dinner; a tall woman in white; Walter, the portly man in the elevator; a boy on the golf course
The Sagamore stands on Green Island in Lake George, joined to Bolton Landing by a causeway. The first hotel opened in 1883, burned in 1893 and again in 1914, and the white clapboard hotel you see today opened on July 1, 1930. It closed in 1981, was restored by developer Norman Wolgin in the 1980s and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. It is now part of the Opal Collection.
Historic Hotels of America publishes the Sagamore’s ghost stories itself. A couple from the 1880s is seen coming down from the second floor to the old Trillium restaurant, a woman in a white gown once walked through a prep cook, and staff call a portly man in a brown three-piece suit Walter after he appeared in the Trillium elevator. Golfers tell of a boy from the 1950s who chased lost balls and was killed by a car.
Haunted Rooms tip: Book a room in the historic main hotel rather than the lakeside lodges, and play a round on the Donald Ross course at dusk.
Where to look The third floor, the front dining room, the upstairs front windows, the basement stairs
Reported ghosts Topper; Alice and her two children; a Civil War soldier; a lilac-scented woman
The Naples Hotel stands on Main Street in the Finger Lakes village of Naples. Simeon Lyon opened a stagecoach tavern here in 1818, and the present brick hotel was finished in 1895. It survived a roof fire in 1924 and a Prohibition raid in 1928, and Robert F. Kennedy spoke from its porch in 1964. Owners Tom and Destiny Salviski restored it between 2020 and 2023, and it now has ten suite-style rooms with a seasonal restaurant and bar.
The Naples Hotel is on New York’s Haunted History Trail and appeared on Ghost Hunters. Its best-known spirit is Topper, linked to the third floor, where the owners found a door locked from the inside. Alice is seen in the front dining room while her two children look out of an upstairs window. Guests also report a Civil War soldier on the basement steps, a lilac scent in a front room and TVs that turn themselves on.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for a third-floor suite, and visit in September for the Naples Grape Festival.
Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.
Where to look The front lawn facing Seneca Lake, the bar, the main staircase, the old casino room
Reported ghosts Isabella, the opera singer in white; Dick O'Brien, the prankster caretaker
Belhurst Castle is a red sandstone Romanesque mansion on the west shore of Seneca Lake, built between 1885 and 1889 for Carrie Young Harron, who bought the estate the day she first saw it. Fifty men worked on it for four years. In the 1930s Cornelius “Red” Dwyer ran it as a speakeasy and gambling casino, and today it is a hotel with chambers in the castle, two restaurants, a spa and its own winery.
Its best-known ghost is Isabella, an opera singer in white said to have died when a secret tunnel to the lake collapsed as she fled with her lover. Guests report her on the lawn at night. The other regular is Dick O’Brien, a caretaker who died in 1972 and gets the blame for flying glasses in the bar, showers switching on and off and tablecloths tied to chandeliers.
Haunted Rooms tip: Book one of the Chambers in the Castle rather than the newer Vinifera Inn if you want to sleep in the building the stories come from.
$$ · $150 to $300Haunted room bookableHotel embraces its ghostsNo pets
Address 145 Main Street, Mount Morris, NY 14510
Where to look The Wadsworth, Dansville and Rochester rooms, the main staircase, the library
Reported ghosts Karen on the stairs; Raymond in the library; a teenage girl; a ghost cat and dog
Booking the haunted room Rooms are named (Wadsworth, Dansville, Rochester and others), so you can ask for the Wadsworth Room when you book with the inn.
This white-columned Greek Revival mansion on Main Street in Mount Morris was built by the Wisner family in 1838 and takes its name from Francis Bellamy, the Mount Morris native who wrote the Pledge of Allegiance. It sits a few minutes from Letchworth State Park, and innkeepers Steve and Glenda Luick have run it as a Victorian-style B&B since buying it in 1999.
The Luicks say they did not know the house was haunted until guests started telling them. The regulars are Karen, a gray-haired woman in a long dress seen on the stairs, and Raymond, a chatty man seen in the library. Guests also describe a teenage girl in the Wadsworth Room and a ghost cat or dog curling up on the bed. The inn featured on Paranormal State.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for the Wadsworth Room, where guests report the teenage girl, and ask the innkeepers for their ghost overview at check-in.
Where to look The fifth floor, the hallways and stairwell, the bar
Reported ghosts Mary, the Titanic widow; Nancy Spungen; Dylan Thomas
The Hotel Chelsea was built in 1883 and 1884 as one of New York’s first co-op apartment houses and became a hotel in 1905. Its red brick front with black iron balconies is a New York City landmark, and its guest book reads like a cultural history: Mark Twain, Dylan Thomas, Arthur Miller, Bob Dylan, Janis Joplin, Leonard Cohen and Patti Smith all lived here. After a long renovation that began in 2011, it reopened to overnight guests in 2022.
The Chelsea’s ghost stories follow its residents. Nancy Spungen was found stabbed to death in Room 100 in 1978, and guests say she still lingers. Dylan Thomas, who collapsed at the hotel in 1953 and died days later in hospital, is said to haunt the bar. The most told story is of Mary, said to have hanged herself on the fifth floor after her husband died on the Titanic. Actor Michael Imperioli described seeing a crying woman there on Celebrity Ghost Stories in 2010.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for a room on the fifth floor, Mary’s floor, and walk the famous stairwell late at night.
Address 20 Circular Street, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866
Where to look The Kate, Amelia and Maria Pia rooms, the grand staircase, the basement laundry, the dining room
Reported ghosts George Batcheller; his daughter Kate; voices of a man and woman talking
Booking the haunted room Rooms are named (Kate, Catharine, George, Amelia, Maria Pia and others), so you can request the Kate room when booking with the inn.
Judge George Sherman Batcheller built this fairy-tale mansion facing Congress Park in 1873, with a minaret-style tower, a slate mansard roof and a name, Kaser-el-Nouzha, inspired by his years in Egypt. His daughter Kate sold it in 1916. The house later became a rooming house and a retirement home, stood empty and vandalized from 1966, was condemned in 1973 and was rescued and turned into a nine-room inn.
Staff stories are the heart of its reputation. One worker heard a voice say “Hi, Mike” while sorting laundry in the old boiler room, a new hire overheard a man and woman talking in an empty basement, and an innkeeper watched a cabinet door swing open on its own. Guests report puffs of air, orbs and moving objects, most often in the Kate room, and gardeners say faces look down from the windows.
Haunted Rooms tip: Request the Kate room on the second floor, the one guests most often link to the Batcheller family, and remember the inn is adults only (16 and over).
Where to look The upstairs suites and hallways, the dining room
Reported ghosts A bride and groom said to have died on their wedding day; music and dancing overhead
The Red Coach Inn opened on August 30, 1923, a three-and-a-half-story English Tudor inn modeled on the Bell Inn at Finedon in England. It looks over the Upper Rapids a short walk from the falls, and it still runs as an inn with suites upstairs and a restaurant downstairs. It is named for the red carriage of General Lafayette, who was welcomed at the Eagle Tavern across the street in the early 1800s.
The Red Coach is a stop on New York’s Haunted History Trail. Guests report jewelry moving across dressers, music playing in the middle of the night and footsteps and dancing overhead, and the story told most often is of a bride and groom who died on their wedding day. Staff are happy to share more if you ask.
Haunted Rooms tip: Book a suite with a rapids view and ask the staff for the inn’s ghost stories at dinner.
Where to look The lobby and its Round Table portrait, the Round Table room, the Blue Bar, the ninth floor
Reported ghosts Dorothy Parker and the Algonquin Round Table; footsteps on the ninth floor and stairs
The Algonquin opened on West 44th Street in November 1902 and became the most famous literary hotel in America. From 1919 to 1929 Dorothy Parker, Robert Benchley, George S. Kaufman, Harold Ross and friends met for lunch at a round table in its dining room, and the hotel has kept a resident cat, always named Hamlet or Matilda, since the 1920s. Today it is The Algonquin Hotel Times Square, part of Marriott’s Autograph Collection.
Staff and guests have long said the Round Table never quite left. The best-known story is of Dorothy Parker, the ‘mean woman’ children say told them to be quiet from the lobby portrait. Guests on the ninth floor tell of footsteps on the stairs with no one there and a tapping sound in an empty bathroom. Some say the Parker reports faded after her ashes were finally buried in the Bronx in 2020.
Haunted Rooms tip: Have a drink in the Blue Bar or lobby by the Round Table portrait, then ask for a ninth-floor room when you book.
Where to look The suites and the parlors furnished with coffins
Reported ghosts Former residents, including a spirit investigators call Billy Ely
Erie Mansion is a big red brick house with a white columned portico on Clyde’s main street, close to the Erie Canal. Built around 1858 and home first to a Dr. Smith and then the glassmaking Ely family, it is on the National Register as the Smith-Ely Mansion. Today it is a four-suite bed and breakfast that leans fully into its ghost stories, with coffins used as tables, a suite lined with alligator skins and a roadside sign calling it historically haunted.
The ghost stories center on former residents, and a local rumor says an early resident took their own life here, though no record confirms it. Workers renovating the house reportedly refused to be in it alone, and investigators claim to have spoken with the spirit of Billy Ely. The mansion advertises premium suites and ghost tours under the line ‘Where History Lingers’; check its website for current rooms, tour nights and rates.
Haunted Rooms tip: Book one of the suites on a ghost tour night and check the mansion’s website for the latest schedule.
Address 301 Veterans Road West (Arthur Kill Road), Staten Island, NY 10309
Where to look The dining room that was Martha's bedroom, the staircase, the first-floor hallway portrait
Reported ghosts Martha Mersereau, the Civil War widow
The Old Bermuda Inn stands in Rossville on Staten Island’s South Shore, around a mansion that tradition says the Mersereau family built about 1832. It is best known today as a restaurant, wedding and banquet venue, and it also runs a small bed and breakfast guest house on the grounds, a restored 1840s Victorian that was once the parsonage of St. Luke’s Church.
The inn’s ghost is Martha Mersereau. Local legend says she kept a candle burning in her window while her husband was away at the Civil War, and after word came that he had been killed she shut herself in her room and died of grief. Her room is now a dining room. Staff and guests describe a woman on the stairs, a chandelier light that will not go out and a portrait that once caught fire.
Haunted Rooms tip: Martha’s stories belong to the old mansion, not the guest house, so pair an overnight stay with dinner or an event in the main building and ask staff to show you her portrait.
Where to look Guest room doors and closets, the corridors, the Palm Court
Reported ghosts Voices behind locked doors; shadow figures in guest rooms; Fannie Lowenstein of the Palm Court
The Plaza opened on October 1, 1907, a white-marble French chateau by Henry Janeway Hardenbergh at the corner of Fifth Avenue and Central Park South. It is a National Historic Landmark, and since a 2008 renovation it has about 282 hotel rooms alongside private condominiums. Fairmont has managed it since 2005.
The Plaza’s ghost stories are quieter than its fame. One family told of being locked in their room while a voice outside mocked their calls for help, and of a shadowy figure coming out of the closet; travel writers add disembodied voices and doors that will not open. The hotel’s old guard also blame mishaps on Fannie Lowenstein, one of the ‘Plaza widows’ who lived here for decades.
Haunted Rooms tip: Have tea in the Palm Court, then ask for a room on an upper floor of the original 1907 building.
Where to look The cabin corridors and shared bathrooms
Reported ghosts Titanic crew said to linger; figures in the halls
This red brick building on the Hudson waterfront opened in 1908 as the American Seamen’s Friend Society Sailors’ Home. In April 1912 it housed the 100 surviving crew of the Titanic while the American inquiry went on, and the crew held a memorial service in its hall. Later it became the Jane West hotel, a theater and, after a 2008 sale, the much-loved Jane Hotel with its tiny ship-style cabins. By 2025 it had been renamed the West Village Eurohostel.
The ghost stories here are thin but persistent. Local ghost writers say the Titanic survivors’ sorrow never left, and lists of New York haunted hotels have long included the Jane, with guests looking for figures in the narrow halls and shared bathrooms. There is no documented death of a Titanic survivor here, so treat it as atmosphere, and stay for the history.
Haunted Rooms tip: Book a single cabin for the full sailor experience and read the Titanic plaque on the building before bed.
Where to look The elevators around 1 a.m., guest rooms, the lobby
Reported ghosts An elevator poltergeist; a woman in white; guests who vanish mid-conversation
The Bowery Hotel looks a century old, but it opened in February 2007. Its owners built it to feel like an old-world hideaway, with a wood-paneled lobby, velvet chairs and real metal room keys, on a corner that once held the Gothic Dry Dock Savings Bank and later a gas station. It sits in the East Village, a few minutes from the New York City Marble Cemetery and the Merchant’s House Museum, both with ghost stories of their own.
The hotel’s ghost stories are recent and come from guests rather than history. Travel writers repeat reports that the elevators act up around 1 a.m., that a woman dressed in white has been found sitting in a guest room and that a drink was knocked from a guest’s hand when he was alone. Treat it as a stylish base for a haunted East Village walk rather than a historic haunt.
Haunted Rooms tip: Stay out late on a ghost walk, then ride the elevators around 1 a.m., when guests say they misbehave.
What changed in this guide: We kept all ten hotels from our previous list and added five: the Sagamore Resort on Lake George, which has its own guide, the Red Coach Inn at Niagara Falls, a 1923 Tudor inn on the Haunted History Trail, and the Hotel Chelsea, the Plaza and the former Jane Hotel from our NYC guide. We corrected Hotel Utica’s history (three floors were added in 1926, not ten) and the Old Bermuda Inn’s family name (Mersereau). The Naples Hotel has been restored and reopened with ten suites. The Jane Hotel now trades as the West Village Eurohostel. Details for Erie Mansion in Clyde are hard to confirm, so check its website before you travel. Since then we have added two more: the Beekman Arms in Rhinebeck, on the Historic Hotels of America 2025 most haunted list, and the Otesaga in Cooperstown, investigated by Ghost Hunters in 2010.
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
The Shanley Hotel in Napanoch is the one most often named. It has appeared on Ghost Hunters and Ghost Lab, every overnight stay includes a staff-led ghost hunt, and the owners say they have contacted more than 30 spirits, including Beatrice Shanley and little Rosie Greger.
What is the most haunted hotel in New York City?
The Hotel Chelsea on West 23rd Street, with stories of a Titanic widow on the fifth floor, Nancy Spungen and Dylan Thomas. The Algonquin, with Dorothy Parker and the Round Table, is a close second. See our NYC guide for all six.
Can you book a haunted room in New York?
Yes. At the Shanley Hotel every room is named for one of its ghosts. At Hotel Utica you can request Room 410, and the Batcheller Mansion Inn and Allegiance Bed and Breakfast let you book specific rooms linked to their stories.
Which New York hotels offer ghost hunts?
The Shanley Hotel includes a ghost hunt with every overnight stay, and Erie Mansion in Clyde advertises ghost tours. Haunted Rooms also runs public ghost hunts at Fort William Henry in Lake George, Historic Four Corners in Herkimer, the Mid-Orange Correctional Facility in Warwick, the Hinsdale House and Historic Palmyra.
Is there a haunted castle hotel in New York?
Belhurst Castle on Seneca Lake in Geneva, built between 1885 and 1889, is a hotel and winery whose best-known ghost is Isabella, a woman in white seen walking toward the lake.
What is the Haunted History Trail of New York State?
A state tourism trail of haunted museums, inns and tours. Hotels in this guide on the trail include the Shanley Hotel, Belhurst Castle, the Naples Hotel and the Red Coach Inn.
Sources and how we research
Every hotel in this guide is checked against the hotel’s own website, historic register listings and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as the hotels, guests and local historians tell them; we note where a story can’t be confirmed. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page are affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never affects which hotels we include or how we score them.