Haunted hotel guide · Utica, New York
Haunted Hotel Utica, New York: Room 410, the Tuxedo Man and the Forbidden Floors
A grand 1912 hotel where the Roosevelts slept and Judy Garland sang, and where staff say an empty room still rings the front desk.
Hotel Utica rises thirteen stories over Lafayette Street in downtown Utica, a red brick tower that was one of the finest hotels between New York City and Buffalo when it opened in 1912. Today it trades as the DoubleTree by Hilton Utica, but locals still call it the Hotel Utica, and it is one of the best-known haunted hotels in New York State.
Its ghost stories come from the people who work there. Desk staff tell of calls from an empty room, housekeepers of objects moving on the fourth floor, and bartenders of a man in a tuxedo who breaks glasses. The upper floors are closed to guests, which only adds to the legend. The good news for ghost hunters is that the most talked-about room, Room 410, is an ordinary guest room you can ask for.
Hotel Utica at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 102 Lafayette Street, Utica, NY 13502 (315-724-7829)
- Opened March 11, 1912; three floors added in 1926; restored and reopened in 2001
- Most haunted spots Room 410, Rooms 408 and 409, the mezzanine, the old Lamplighter Pub, the closed upper floors
- Best-known ghosts Charlie the Tuxedo Man; the White Lady of the mezzanine; a late-night housekeeper; phantom party guests
- Booking the haunted room Book a standard room, then call the hotel to request Room 410, 408 or 409. Requests are not guaranteed.
- Good to know Now a DoubleTree by Hilton. Pets are not allowed. The restaurant, Iconic by Chesterfield, overlooks Liberty Park.
The ghosts of Hotel Utica (DoubleTree by Hilton Utica)
Room 410, the room that calls the desk
Room 410 is the room staff mention first. In a 2015 report on Utica radio station Lite 98.7, staff said the room was out of use for repairs when its phone kept calling the front desk. When the desk answered, there was no one on the line, and staff later found the phone was not even plugged into the jack. At the same time, the shower in the empty room was found running, the water scalding hot.
A 2023 WIBX report repeated the story, dating the phone calls to renovations in 2012, and added staff accounts of guests waking with a heavy pressure on their chests. Investigators who spent time in the room that year described sudden changes in temperature and a floral smell.
Rooms 408 and 409
The rooms either side of 410 have their own reputation. According to the same staff accounts, some guests have checked out soon after arriving because they felt they were not alone, and housekeepers have reported objects moving while they cleaned. Guests elsewhere on the fourth floor ring the desk to complain about a party upstairs, only to be told no one is there, and some hear knocking at their door and open it to an empty hallway.
Charlie, the Tuxedo Man
The hotel’s best-known ghost is a man in a tuxedo. Older accounts collected by the New York Folklore Society placed him in the Lamplighter Pub, the hotel’s old bar, where staff blamed him for broken bottles and glasses. Staff now call him Charlie and say he steals small things such as jewelry and cutlery.
Hotel staff told WIBX that the story behind him is of a man in a tuxedo who hanged himself from the mezzanine railings in the 1950s. We have found no record of such a death, so treat that part as legend. He is the one spirit at the Utica that guests describe as unfriendly.
The White Lady of the mezzanine
The mezzanine above the lobby, where Judy Garland once sang, is also linked to a woman in a light, 1920s-style gown. Staff say she appears during large events, usually weddings and dinners, and vanishes when anyone tries to follow her.
The housekeeper, the empty ballroom and the closed floors
Guests have described an older woman in a housekeeping uniform walking the halls around 2 a.m., when no housekeepers are on duty. Staff talk of party sounds and conversations coming from an empty ballroom, and of uneasy feelings in the stairwells.
The top floors, gutted and used for storage, are closed to the public. Local podcasters who were allowed up there in 2023 said they heard footsteps and whistling later that night, and a spirit box session in the basement produced names such as Ronald, Nicholas and Cyrus.
The most haunted rooms and places to look
- Room 410 (4th floor): The phone that called the desk while unplugged, a scalding shower running in an empty room, and reports of pressure on sleepers’ chests.
- Rooms 408 and 409 (4th floor): Guests who felt a presence and left early; housekeepers who saw objects move.
- The mezzanine: Charlie the Tuxedo Man and the White Lady, best visited during an evening event.
- The bar (the old Lamplighter Pub): Where staff first blamed the Tuxedo Man for broken glasses. Anyone can stop in for a drink.
- The upper floors: Closed to guests and the public. Ask about them, but do not expect a tour.
History of Hotel Utica (DoubleTree by Hilton Utica)
Hotel Utica opened on March 11, 1912, with more than 1,500 people at the ribbon cutting. The Buffalo firm Esenwein and Johnson designed it for the United Hotels Company of America, with 200 fireproof rooms, four dining rooms, a ballroom and an assembly hall. In 1926 three floors were added on top, taking it to about 250 rooms.
For half a century it was the place to be seen in central New York. Franklin D. Roosevelt stayed often while running for governor, Eleanor Roosevelt came too, Amelia Earhart was honored at a luncheon in 1928, and Judy Garland sang on the mezzanine in 1950. Mae West, Mickey Mantle, Jackie Robinson, Johnny Cash and Robert F. Kennedy are all on the hotel’s guest list. Local tradition says the first legal beer after Prohibition was sold here by the F.X. Matt Brewing Company, makers of Utica Club.
As downtown declined, so did the hotel. It closed in 1972 and the building became an adult care home, first as the Hunter House and later as the Loretto Adult Residence. After a period standing empty, local investors Joseph Carucci and Charles Gaetano bought it and spent about $13 million restoring it, modeling the work on the Willard Hotel in Washington. It reopened in 2001 and joined Historic Hotels of America that year.
Visions Hotels bought the hotel in 2016, and after a renovation it reopened as the DoubleTree by Hilton Utica on October 24, 2017. Much of the original decor survives alongside careful replicas of pieces lost during the care-home years.
Tips for a haunted stay
- Book directly or through our link, then call the hotel and ask for Room 410. If it is taken, ask for 408 or 409. Confirm the request again at check-in.
- Stay over a Saturday when there is a wedding or gala on: the mezzanine stories nearly all happen during big events.
- Pets are not allowed, so leave the dog at home. Parking and current rates are listed on the Hilton site.
- Have a drink in the bar where the Tuxedo Man story began, and be polite: he is the one ghost here said to have a temper.
- Pair your stay with a night at the Historic Four Corners ghost hunt in Herkimer, about 15 miles east.
Want to investigate, not just sleep?
Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.
- Historic Four Corners Ghost Hunt, Herkimer: Investigate the old Herkimer County Jail and Suiter House, about 20 minutes east
- Historic Palmyra Ghost Hunt, Palmyra: A night in Palmyra’s historic museum buildings in the Finger Lakes
- Haunted Fort William Henry Ghost Hunt, Lake George: A night inside the rebuilt 1755 fort
More haunted hotels nearby
- Batcheller Mansion Inn, Saratoga Springs: a Victorian mansion inn about 90 minutes east
- The Sagamore Resort, Bolton Landing: a Lake George grand hotel with a ghost in its elevator
- Belhurst Castle, Geneva: a Seneca Lake castle and its lady in white
- Upstate New York haunted places: more ghost stories across upstate
- Haunted hotels in New York
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is Hotel Utica haunted?
It has one of the strongest ghost reputations of any hotel in upstate New York. Staff and guests report calls from empty rooms, a man in a tuxedo, a woman in a gown on the mezzanine and party sounds from closed floors. The evidence is stories and investigations, not proof.
What is the most haunted room at Hotel Utica?
Room 410. Staff say its phone called the front desk while it was unplugged and the shower ran in the empty room. Rooms 408 and 409 next door are also mentioned.
Can you stay in Room 410 at Hotel Utica?
Yes, it is a regular guest room. Book any room, then call the hotel to request 410. Requests are not guaranteed.
Who is the Tuxedo Man at Hotel Utica?
A ghost staff call Charlie, seen in a tuxedo in the bar and on the mezzanine and blamed for broken glasses and missing small items. Staff say he hanged himself from the mezzanine in the 1950s, but no record of that has been found.
Is Hotel Utica still open?
Yes. It operates as the DoubleTree by Hilton Utica at 102 Lafayette Street.
Who has stayed at Hotel Utica?
Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt, Amelia Earhart, Judy Garland, Mae West, Mickey Mantle, Jackie Robinson, Johnny Cash and Robert F. Kennedy are among the famous guests.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
- Wikipedia: Hotel Utica
- Historic Hotels of America: DoubleTree by Hilton Hotel Utica history
- DoubleTree by Hilton Utica (official site)
- Lite 98.7: Hotel Utica's most haunted rooms (2015)
- Lite 98.7: Does the Tuxedo Man haunt the Hotel Utica's Lamplighter Pub? (2015)
- Lite 98.7: The forbidden floors of haunted Hotel Utica (2015)
- WIBX 950: Is this century-old building Utica's most haunted location? (2023)
Get new haunted hotel guides by email
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page are affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

