Haunted hotel guide · Staten Island, New York
The Haunted Old Bermuda Inn, Staten Island: Martha's Candle in the Window
A Staten Island mansion where a Civil War widow is said to still wait for a husband who never came home.
The Historic Old Bermuda Inn sits on three acres in Rossville, on the quiet South Shore of Staten Island, around a mansion that tradition dates to about 1832. Today most people know it as a restaurant, wedding and banquet hall, but it also runs a small bed and breakfast guest house on the grounds, which makes it one of the few places in the city where you can sleep beside a famous ghost story. It belongs on any list of haunted hotels in NYC.
The ghost is Martha Mersereau. Local legend says she lit a candle in her window every night while her husband was away at the Civil War, and that when news came of his death she shut herself in her room and died of a broken heart. Her room is now a dining room, and staff and guests have been telling stories about her for decades.
Old Bermuda Inn at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 301 Veterans Road West, at Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island, NY 10309 (718-948-7600)
- Opened Mansion c. 1832; guest house is a restored 1840s parsonage
- Most haunted spots The dining room that was Martha’s bedroom, the main staircase, the first-floor hallway portrait
- Best-known ghosts Martha Mersereau, the grieving widow
- Booking the haunted room Martha’s room is a dining room, not a guest room; stay in the guest house and dine or attend an event in the mansion
- Good to know Mainly a wedding and event venue; the guest house has four suites, a cottage and a shared Grand Parlor; book by phone or email
The ghosts of Historic Old Bermuda Inn
Martha Mersereau, the widow at the window
The story says a young couple, Martha and David Mersereau, built the house as a summer home in the early 1830s. When the Civil War came, her husband went to fight. Martha kept a candle burning in her bedroom window each evening so he could find his way home.
Months later, the legend goes, word arrived that he had been killed in battle. Martha took to her room, refused to come out and died soon after, of grief as the locals put it. We could not find a record that confirms the husband’s death in the war, so treat the details as the inn’s legend rather than documented history. The house, however, is old enough, and the story has been told about it for generations.
The dining room and the staircase
Martha’s bedroom became a dining room when the house was turned into a restaurant; a 2012 Time Out listing names it as the Somerset Room. Guests describe a young woman walking through the dining room and standing on the stairs, and many say they feel watched. Staff have reported that cameras refuse to work in her old room and that they have heard a woman whisper the word “listen”.
The portrait that caught fire
The inn’s most repeated story concerns a family oil portrait. During renovation work, staff say, it caught fire with nothing nearby that could have lit it. The painting survived and still hangs in the first-floor hallway with its scorch marks, and many visitors believe the sitter is Martha herself.
The light that will not go out
When the dining room chandelier is switched off at night, staff say one bulb keeps burning, as if Martha is still leaving a light on for her husband. Some versions of the story add that it stays lit even when the power is cut. It is the detail that ties the modern haunting straight back to the candle in the window.
More Staten Island ghosts nearby
The South Shore is rich in ghost stories. At Historic Richmond Town, a living history village, staff have reported footsteps and a penny whistle in the children’s room of a house once owned by the Lake family. In Tottenville, legends at the Conference House, built by Captain Christopher Billop around 1680, include a maid he is said to have killed and a fiancee who died of a broken heart. Visitors also tell stories about the abandoned New York City Farm Colony and Sea View Hospital, and about a glowing woman near the Vanderbilt family mausoleum in Moravian Cemetery, which is closed to the public.
The most haunted rooms and places to look
- Martha's room (now a dining room): Where she is said to have died. The center of the haunting, and the place where cameras are said to fail.
- The main staircase: Guests describe a young woman standing on the stairs.
- The first-floor hallway: Home of the scorched family portrait that caught fire during renovations.
- The guest house and Grand Parlor: Where overnight guests actually sleep: four antique-filled suites and a cottage around a parlor with a fireplace and piano.
History of Historic Old Bermuda Inn
The Old Bermuda Inn stands in Rossville, near the Arthur Kill on Staten Island’s South Shore. Venue listings describe the property as the former Mersereau (or Mesereau) and Seguine estate and date the mansion to about 1832. The original part of the mansion is still in use inside the much larger banquet complex that has grown up around it.
It was an era when Staten Island was still a rural retreat for New York families. Aaron Burr, the former vice president who killed Alexander Hamilton in a duel, came to the island at the end of his life and died there in 1836, a few years after the house is said to have been built.
In the 20th century the house became a restaurant and catering hall, and the venue says it has been hosting celebrations for more than 30 years. Weddings now fill its ballrooms, chapel and gardens most weekends.
The overnight side of the business is the Guest House, a Victorian building on the grounds that served as the parsonage of St. Luke’s Church in the 1840s. It has been restored with antiques and modern comforts, with four suites, a separate Cottage for honeymoons and anniversaries, and a Grand Parlor where guests can sit by the fire. Earlier versions of this guide implied guests sleep in Martha’s mansion; in fact the suites are in this separate building.
Tips for a haunted stay
- Contact the inn by phone (718-948-7600) or email to book the Guest House. It is not sold through the big booking sites, and weekends fill with weddings.
- Martha’s stories belong to the main mansion, so plan dinner or an event there and ask staff to show you the scorched portrait in the hallway.
- Ask for the Cottage if you want the most private stay on the grounds.
- Make a Staten Island ghost day of it: Historic Richmond Town and the Conference House in Tottenville are both a short drive away.
- No car? The Staten Island Ferry from Lower Manhattan connects with the Staten Island Railway, but you will need a taxi for the last stretch to Rossville.
Want to investigate, not just sleep?
Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.
- Mid Orange Correctional Facility Ghost Hunt, Warwick: A former state prison about 90 minutes north
- Fort Mifflin Ghost Hunt, Philadelphia: One of America’s most haunted forts
More haunted hotels nearby
- The Bowery Hotel, NYC: a stylish Manhattan stay with ghost stories of its own
- The Algonquin Hotel, NYC: the Round Table hotel in Midtown
- The Haunted Shanley Hotel, Napanoch: a full ghost-hunting hotel two hours north
- Haunted places in NYC: more ghost stories across the five boroughs
- Haunted hotels in New York
- Haunted hotels in NYC
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Old Bermuda Inn haunted?
It is one of Staten Island’s best-known haunted spots. Staff and guests report the ghost of Martha Mersereau in the dining room and on the stairs, a chandelier bulb that will not go out and a portrait that caught fire during renovations. The stories are local legend rather than documented events.
Who is the ghost at the Old Bermuda Inn?
Martha Mersereau, who according to legend kept a candle in her window for her husband during the Civil War and died of grief after hearing he had been killed.
Can you stay overnight at the Old Bermuda Inn?
Yes. The inn has a bed and breakfast guest house on the grounds with four suites and a cottage. It is a separate 1840s building, the former St. Luke’s Church parsonage, and is booked by phone or email.
Which room is haunted at the Old Bermuda Inn?
Martha’s former bedroom, which is now a dining room in the main mansion. It is not a guest room.
Where is the Old Bermuda Inn?
In Rossville on Staten Island’s South Shore, at 301 Veterans Road West by Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island, NY 10309.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
- The Historic Old Bermuda Inn: official site
- The Historic Old Bermuda Inn: The Guest House
- Time Out New York: Old Bermuda Inn (2012)
- Spoon University: 8 scarily good haunted spots to eat and drink in New York
- Roadtrippers: Old Bermuda Inn
- Cvent: The Historic Old Bermuda Inn
- WithJoy: The Old Bermuda Inn
Get new haunted hotel guides by email
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page are affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

