Haunted hotel guide · St. Augustine, Florida
The Haunted Casa Monica Hotel, St. Augustine
An 1888 Moorish castle in America’s oldest city, where the hotel stays quiet about ghosts and the housekeepers do not.
St. Augustine is often called the most haunted city in Florida, and the Casa Monica sits at its center, across the street from Henry Flagler’s old hotels and a short walk from the Castillo de San Marcos. Its towers and crenellated rooftops look made for ghost stories, and over the years housekeepers, guests and local guides have supplied plenty.
The hotel itself does not promote any of them. The stories come from former staff and guests: children running in corridors on empty floors, a man in 1920s clothes in the lobby, a woman in white in the Ponce de Leon suite and a voice behind the door of the Flagler Suite saying “We’ve been expecting you.” Most of the activity is said to gather on the fourth floor.
Casa Monica at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 95 Cordova Street, St. Augustine, FL 32084, at the corner of King Street
- Opened 1888, built by Franklin W. Smith in poured concrete; bought by Henry Flagler the same year
- Most haunted spots The fourth floor, the Flagler Suite, the Ponce de Leon suite and rooms 411 and 511
- Best-known ghosts Running children, a man in 1920s clothing, a woman in white, a woman in a green dress
- Booking the haunted room The hotel does not sell a haunted room. Ask for a fourth floor room or one of the named suites.
- Good to know Now Casa Monica Resort & Spa, Autograph Collection (Marriott). Pets up to 40 pounds are welcome for $150 a stay.
The ghosts of the Casa Monica
Children in the corridors
The most common report is the sound of children running up and down the hallways and in and out of rooms, even when a floor has been cleared. A local housekeeper who worked at the hotel for about a year has said she experienced many strange things, and that the fourth floor had the most activity. Some staff are said to refuse to clean certain suites alone, and a few refuse to clean them at all.
The Flagler Suite: "We've been expecting you"
The best-known story belongs to the Flagler Suite. A housekeeper knocked to ask whether the room could be cleaned and heard a voice inside say, “We’ve been expecting you.” She opened the door expecting a family getting ready to go out and found the suite empty. Guests have also reported a man in the suite when it was unoccupied, and a small child’s handprint that appears on the first floor bathroom mirror.
The woman in white of the Ponce de Leon suite
Staff working upstairs in the two-level Ponce de Leon suite have heard the radio on the floor below switch itself on. The suite is said to be haunted by a woman in white, and one story claims she was caught in a guest’s photograph, though the picture has never been published.
Rooms 411 and 511
A guest in room 411 is said to have woken to find several figures standing silently around the room. Room 511 carries a darker tale of a man who hanged himself on the upper floor. We have found no record of such a death, and the building spent most of the 20th century as offices and a courthouse rather than a hotel, so treat this one as local legend.
The gentleman in 1920s clothes and the lady in green
Guests and former staff describe a man in 1920s-era clothing who walks through the hotel and vanishes from the lobby when approached. Others report a woman in a green dress, voices when no one is around, footprints appearing on carpet and furniture that has moved overnight.
The most haunted rooms and places to look
- The fourth floor: The floor most often named by staff. Ask for any room here.
- The Flagler Suite: The voice at the door, the man in the empty suite and the child’s handprint on the bathroom mirror.
- The Ponce de Leon suite: Two levels, a radio with a mind of its own and the woman in white.
- Rooms 411 and 511: The silent figures and the hanging legend. Room numbers can change after renovations, so ask at the desk.
- The lobby: Where the man in 1920s clothes is seen and then is gone.
History of Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Boston architect and reformer Franklin W. Smith built the Casa Monica in 1888 in a Moorish Revival style inspired by Spain’s Alhambra, using poured concrete mixed with coquina shell. It was one of the first large buildings of its kind in the country. Smith ran into money trouble almost at once, and within months Henry Flagler, co-founder of Standard Oil and the developer of St. Augustine’s grand hotels, bought it with its furnishings for $325,000 and renamed it the Cordova Hotel.
In 1902 a bridge linked the Cordova to Flagler’s Hotel Alcazar across the street, and the building became the Alcazar Annex. The combined hotels closed in 1932 during the Great Depression and the bridge was later demolished.
St. Johns County bought the empty building in 1962 for $250,000, and it was dedicated as the county courthouse in May 1968. Courtrooms and offices filled the old hotel until the 1990s.
Hotelier Richard Kessler bought the building in February 1997 for $1.2 million and restored it, reopening it as the Casa Monica in December 1999. The King and Queen of Spain visited soon afterward. In 2010 it became the first hotel in Marriott’s Autograph Collection. Today it trades as Casa Monica Resort & Spa, and Marriott’s listing also shows the name Grand Bohemian Casa Monica.
Tips for a haunted stay
- Ask for the fourth floor when you book, and ask whether the Flagler or Ponce de Leon suites are available if your budget stretches.
- Join a ghost walk. St. Augustine’s evening ghost walks wind through the old town around the hotel, and the historic district is compact enough to walk back.
- Visit the Lightner Museum across the street, Flagler’s former Hotel Alcazar, to see the other half of the Cordova and Alcazar story.
- Bringing a pet? Up to two pets under 40 pounds are allowed for a fee, but they cannot be left alone in the room.
- Read our guide to haunted places in St. Augustine and the St. Augustine Lighthouse.
More haunted hotels nearby
- St. Augustine Lighthouse: one of the most investigated haunted lighthouses in America
- Haunted places in Jacksonville: about 45 minutes north
- The Vinoy, St. Petersburg: another 1920s resort with a famous ghost list
- Haunted hotels in Florida
- Haunted places in St. Augustine
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Casa Monica Hotel haunted?
The hotel does not say so, but former housekeepers, guests and local guides describe children running in empty halls, a voice in the Flagler Suite, a woman in white and a man in 1920s clothing. These are stories and personal accounts, not documented fact.
What is the most haunted part of the Casa Monica?
The fourth floor is named most often, along with the Flagler Suite, the Ponce de Leon suite and rooms 411 and 511.
Did someone die in room 511 at the Casa Monica?
Local legend says a man hanged himself on the upper floor, but we have found no record of it. The building was a hotel only from 1888 to 1932 and again since 1999.
Was the Casa Monica a courthouse?
Yes. St. Johns County bought it in 1962 and used it as the county courthouse from 1968 into the 1990s before it was restored as a hotel.
Does the Casa Monica allow pets?
Yes. Up to two pets of 40 pounds or less are welcome for a $150 fee per stay, according to the hotel’s Marriott listing.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
- Marriott: Casa Monica Resort & Spa, Autograph Collection
- Wikipedia: Casa Monica Hotel
- TravelAwaits: 5 of the most haunted hotels in the South
- Haunt World: Casa Monica Hotel
Get new haunted hotel guides by email
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page are affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

