Haunted places guide · St. Augustine, Florida
St. Augustine Lighthouse: The Pittee Girls and Florida's Most Haunted Tower
A black and white tower on Anastasia Island, a supply cart that ran into the water in 1873, and keepers whose tobacco smoke is still noticed by staff. This is the real history behind Florida’s most famous haunted lighthouse, and how to climb it after dark.
Our nearest ghost hunt: Battleship North CarolinaMeet the ghosts
The St. Augustine Lighthouse stands at the north end of Anastasia Island, across Matanzas Bay from the oldest city in the United States. Its spiral black and white stripes and red lantern room make it one of the most photographed lighthouses in Florida, and it is still an active aid to navigation. The St. Augustine Lighthouse & Maritime Museum, a nonprofit, owns the tower, its original first-order Fresnel lens and the grounds, and it runs the site as a museum you can visit every day.
It is also the haunted place people ask about most in St. Augustine. It has featured on Ghost Hunters, My Ghost Story and the Travel Channel, and the museum itself tells its ghost stories openly on its own night tours. Unlike many haunted places, this one has a documented tragedy at its heart: the deaths of three girls during the tower’s construction in 1873. This guide sets out what the records say, what staff and visitors report, and how to see it for yourself.
St. Augustine Lighthouse at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 100 Red Cox Dr, St. Augustine, FL 32080 (mailing: 81 Lighthouse Ave)
- Built 1871 to 1874; first lit in October 1874
- Earlier light Florida’s first lighthouse, lit in May 1824, lost to erosion
- Run by St. Augustine Lighthouse & Maritime Museum, a nonprofit, since 2002 ownership transfer
- Most haunted spots The tower stairs, the keepers’ house basement and parlor, the grounds near the playground
- Best-known ghosts The Pittee girls, keeper Joseph Andreu, Peter Rasmussen, the Harn family
- Ghost tours Dark of the Moon, run by the museum, the only night tour inside the tower
Our nearest ghost hunt: Battleship North Carolina Visit / tours
History of the St. Augustine Lighthouse
There has been a watch on this shore since the Spanish period, and the museum says the first American light may have stood on the site of an old Spanish watchtower. That light was officially lit by the territorial government in May 1824, making it Florida’s first lighthouse. By the 1860s the sea was eating away the shore beneath it, and after repeated reports to the U.S. Lighthouse Board, Congress paid for a new tower set further back.
At the start of the Civil War, harbor master Paul Arnau and the keeper, Maria Mestre de los Dolores Andreu, took the lens out of the old tower and hid it, to keep Union ships in the dark and help blockade runners. The lens and clockworks were only recovered after Arnau was held on a ship offshore and made to reveal where they were. Maria Andreu is remembered as the first Hispanic American woman to serve in the Coast Guard’s forerunner. She had taken over from her husband, Joseph Andreu, the keeper said to have fallen to his death from the old tower in 1859 while painting it.
Work on the new tower began in 1871 under Hezekiah Pittee, superintendent of lighthouse construction, who had come down from Cape Elizabeth in Maine with his wife Mary and their children. It was finished in 1874 and first lit in October by keeper William Russell, the only keeper to serve in both towers. The brick keepers’ house followed in 1876. One of the longest serving head keepers was William A. Harn, a Union veteran from Philadelphia who had commanded a battery at Gettysburg and lived here with his wife Kate.
The light was automated in 1955, and the last keeper to live on site, James Pippin, reportedly moved out of the house in the early 1950s saying it was haunted. In the 1960s the house was rented out, and in 1970 it burned in a fire nobody explained, leaving little more than the coquina basement. The county planned to knock down the shell. Instead the all-volunteer Junior Service League of St. Augustine raised about 1.2 million dollars over 15 years to restore the house, the tower and the lens. The station went on the National Register in 1981, and in 2002 the Coast Guard handed the tower to the museum, the first such transfer of a lighthouse to a nonprofit in the United States.
The ghosts of the St. Augustine Lighthouse
The Pittee girls
This is the story with records behind it. Building materials came in by ship to Salt Run and were hauled up to the site on a small railway cart, and the Pittee children treated the cart as a ride, rolling down to the water and pushing it back up. A board at the end of the track normally stopped it. On July 10, 1873, it was not in place. The cart carried Mary, 15, Eliza, 13, four-year-old Carrie and a girl of about ten whose father may have worked on the site. It tipped into the water and trapped them. A young worker, Dan Sessions, lifted the cart off them, but only Carrie survived. The museum has never been able to find the name or resting place of the fourth girl, and says names offered by psychics are unconfirmed.
Since then staff, volunteers and visitors have reported girls’ laughter at the top of the tower, a staff member chasing giggles that moved below him as he went down, shoelaces untied on the stairs and a girl in a Victorian dress reading on a bench in the woods who was gone when the visitor looked again. A tour guide told News4JAX in 2022 that she now wears shoes without laces.
Joseph Andreu and the keepers
Joseph Andreu’s fall from the old tower in 1859 gives the lighthouse its other well-known ghost: a man in uniform near the stairs, and footsteps climbing when no one is there. Visitors have also told guides they felt a hand at their back guiding them up the steps, which some credit to Maria Andreu, said to appear in white.
Peter Rasmussen, the longest serving keeper in the early 1900s, was strict and loved his cigars. Staff say the smell of cherry tobacco still turns up in the tower, especially after a visitor says something rude about him.
The Harn family and the keepers' house
Staff who lead tours of the 1876 house describe a rocking chair in the parlor that moves, the sound of a cough in an empty room, dents in the seat cushions and sighs. They link these to William Harn, who died of illness some years after moving in, and his wife Kate, said to appear as a shadow in the halls. Volunteers who rebuilt the burned house reported strange incidents in the basement, and staff say it still feels uneasy.
What a skeptic says
Not everyone is convinced. Investigator Joe Nickell wrote that there is no credible evidence the lighthouse is haunted and suggested that the noises people hear are wind and seagulls. The museum itself says it cannot explain the reports and keeps researching its archives. We think that is the right way to visit: the tragedy is real, the stories are stories, and the tower is worth the climb either way.
Where to look
- The tower stairs: 219 steps up a spiral iron staircase, where footsteps, giggles and untied laces are reported.
- The top of the tower: the gallery around the lantern, where staff have heard laughter.
- The keepers' house basement: the coquina basement that survived the 1970 fire, the part of the house staff find most uneasy.
- The parlor: the Victorian room with the rocking chair linked to the Harn family.
- The grounds and maritime hammock: where a girl in Victorian dress has been seen, and the area near the playground the stories link to the Pittee girls.
Visiting the St. Augustine Lighthouse
The museum is open every day, and a regular ticket lets you climb the tower, tour the keepers’ house and see the maritime archaeology exhibits. Parking is free. The climb is steep and narrow, so wear sensible shoes, and allow a couple of hours for the whole site.
For the ghost stories, book the museum’s Dark of the Moon tour. It is the only paranormal tour that takes guests inside the tower and house at night, and its proceeds support the museum’s maritime archaeology and research. Tours fill up, particularly in October, so book ahead. Several of the city’s commercial ghost tours also pass the lighthouse grounds in the evening, but they do not go inside.
- Visiting Museum and tower climb open daily
- Tours Dark of the Moon paranormal tours inside the tower and keepers’ house
- Hours and season Daily 9 AM to 6 PM (check the site)
- Ghost hunting Ghost tours run by the museum; no independent investigations
Tips for your visit
- Book Dark of the Moon early, especially around Halloween.
- Wear shoes without laces, if you believe the guides.
- Read the museum’s own account of the Pittee girls before you go; it is careful about fact and legend.
- Combine it with the Castillo de San Marcos and the Old Jail across the bay for a full day.
- Stay in town at a haunted inn such as the St. Francis Inn and make a weekend of it.
Go ghost hunting nearby
Visiting a haunted place by day is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through a historic building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and vigils, and gives you time to explore on your own. These are the nearest ones we run.
- USS Battleship North Carolina Ghost Hunt and Tour, Wilmington: investigate below decks on the World War II battleship moored across the river from downtown Wilmington, from 8 PM to 2 AM.
- Old Moore County Jail and Old Lynchburg Funeral Home Ghost Hunt, Tennessee: two haunted buildings in one night: the 1893 county jail and the old funeral home across the street, from 8 PM to 2 AM.
- Roanoke Island Inn Ghost Hunt and Sleepover, Manteo: investigate the Manteo waterfront inn where Roscoe Jones is said to keep his own hours, then sleep in one of its rooms.
More haunted places nearby
- Castillo de San Marcos: the 17th-century Spanish fort across the bay
- Haunted hotels in St. Augustine: stay at the St. Francis Inn, the Casablanca Inn or Casa de Suenos
- The St. Francis Inn: the 1791 inn with Lily’s Room
- Haunted places in Florida
- Haunted places in St. Augustine
Visited one of these places? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from visitors and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your visit. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is the St. Augustine Lighthouse really haunted?
It has one of the strongest reputations in Florida, with reports from staff, volunteers and visitors going back to the 1950s, and it has appeared on Ghost Hunters. The museum says it cannot explain the reports, and skeptic Joe Nickell argues the noises are wind and birds. The tragedy behind the best-known story, the deaths of the Pittee girls in 1873, is documented.
What happened to the Pittee girls?
On July 10, 1873, during construction of the new tower, a supply cart carrying three daughters of superintendent Hezekiah Pittee and another girl rolled into the water of Salt Run and overturned. Mary, 15, Eliza, 13, and the other girl drowned. Four-year-old Carrie survived.
Can you go inside the lighthouse at night?
Yes, on the museum’s Dark of the Moon paranormal tours, the only night tours that go inside the tower and keepers’ house. Book ahead.
How many steps are there to the top?
219. The climb is steep, and the view from the top takes in the old city, Matanzas Bay and the ocean.
Who is the ghost that smells of cigars?
Staff link the smell of cherry tobacco to Peter Rasmussen, a long-serving keeper in the early 1900s who was fond of cigars.
Can you go ghost hunting at the lighthouse?
Not independently. The museum runs its own paranormal tours, and there are no Haunted Rooms events here. Our nearest ghost hunts are listed on this page.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the official website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as staff, visitors and investigators tell them, and we say where records contradict a story.
- St. Augustine Lighthouse: Ghost stories, the Pittee girls
- Wikipedia: St. Augustine Light
- News4JAX: Paranormal activity at the lighthouse keepers' house (2022)
- News4JAX: The most haunted places in St. Augustine (2024)
- Florida Trust: Haunted in St. Augustine
- Visit St. Augustine: St. Augustine haunts
- Old Town Trolley Tours: Haunted places in St. Augustine
Get new haunted places guides by email
New guides, haunted places to visit and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every place in our guides using official sites, historic registers, local archives and news coverage, and we report ghost stories as the stories they are. We review each guide regularly so you are not sent to a place that has closed, changed hands or banned visitors. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.

