Haunted Places in Erie, PA: 10 to Visit and 3 to Leave Alone
A nun in a college tower, a general boiled down to his bones, a little girl on the station stairs and a vault with a V over the door. These are Erie’s best-known ghost stories, with what is true, what is legend and how you can visit.
Erie’s ghost stories cluster in a few square miles of downtown and its two Catholic universities, plus a wooded gorge east of the city and the lighthouse out on Presque Isle. Several of them rest on real history: Anthony Wayne really was boiled down in Erie, Union Station really is a 1927 railroad palace, and Erie Cemetery’s ‘Vampire Crypt’ really has no names on it. We have checked every place below against current sources, corrected the story we had at the wrong church, and moved three places you should not try to visit to a separate list at the end. Haunted Rooms does not run ghost hunts in Erie; our nearest events are listed below.
Where to look The Witches' Circle, the Brown vault ('Vampire Crypt') and the Scott mausoleum
Reported ghosts A vampire legend, a black dog, a coven gone wrong
Visiting Temporarily closed to visitors after the September 2026 storms; normally open in daylight
Tours Volunteer history tours, including Ghosts and Legends walks in October and a Witches’ Circle ‘real story’ tour
Hours and season Normally daylight hours; office Monday to Friday 8 AM to 4 PM
Ghost hunting No ghost hunting; the grounds are open in daylight only
Erie Cemetery is the city’s oldest non-denominational cemetery, run by an association founded in 1850, and it holds Revolutionary War veterans, the composer Harry T. Burleigh and many of Erie’s leading families. Please check before you go: severe storms in early September 2026 brought down well over 100 trees and damaged graves, mausoleums and fencing, and the cemetery closed to visitors while crews made it safe.
Its legends are some of Erie’s best. The ‘Vampire Crypt’ is a nameless vault with a carved V over the door, and the story says a stranger back from Romania was laid there before drained bodies turned up. The records are duller: it is the Brown family vault, no Browns are buried in it, and it holds seven Goodriches, the last interred in 1880. The Witches’ Circle, a ring of headstones some say the devil scorched, now has its own volunteer ‘real story’ tour, and older lists add a black dog after dark.
Haunted Rooms tip: Once it reopens, join one of the volunteer history tours: the October Ghosts and Legends walk covers the Vampire Crypt and the Witches’ Circle with the facts behind them.
Address 12241 Lake Street, Conneaut Lake, PA 16316
Where to look The third floor and Room 323
Reported ghosts Elizabeth, the bride of the 1943 fire
Visiting A working hotel; call to ask for Room 323 or the third floor
Ghost hunting No organised ghost hunts; stay the night instead
If you want to sleep somewhere haunted near Erie, this is the closest choice in our guides, about 35 miles south on the shore of Conneaut Lake. Hotel Conneaut is the last of the grand resort hotels of Conneaut Lake Park, which opened in 1892 as Exposition Park, and a fire in 1943 destroyed much of the building. The rooms you book today are in the part that survived.
That fire is the root of its ghost story. Local legend says a young bride named Elizabeth was on her honeymoon in 1943 and died in the blaze, and that she still walks the third floor. A desk clerk told Erie News Now she saw a figure in the mirror of Room 323. Records do not confirm that anyone died in the fire, but the hotel happily tells Elizabeth’s story.
What investigators report
Reports centre on the third floor, where a desk clerk said he saw Elizabeth’s ghost in a room mirror. Investigators have filmed the third-floor hallway where she has been seen walking.
Where to look The marble stairs, the back stairwell and the tunnels
Reported ghosts Clara, a little girl who fell on the stairs
Visiting Working brewpub and restaurant, open to all
Tours Haunted History Tours in April and October (registration required)
Ghost hunting Paranormal groups have investigated here by arrangement; ask the Brewerie
Erie’s Union Station was dedicated on December 3, 1927: a New York Central Railroad terminal of more than 100,000 square feet across two city blocks, with Art Deco detail in terracotta and metal. FDR and Harry Truman both stopped here. The Brewerie opened inside the station in 2006, and after nearly two decades under founder Chris Sirianni it passed to new owner Jessica Warren in 2025. Trains still rumble past the trackside seating.
Clara is the station’s ghost. Legend says a little girl traveling with her family fell down the marble stairs, in one version after her father’s luggage knocked her. Staff describe a tripping feeling on the stairwell, as if a child had stuck out a foot, and giggling upstairs when nobody else is there, and the founder’s wife said she saw a cracker tin fly down a hallway in the tunnels. The Brewerie named its Apparition Amber Ale after Clara and runs Haunted History Tours each April and October.
What investigators report
Staff and tour guides point to the stairwell, where some report a tripping sensation tied to the legend of a child named Clara, and to the hallway near the tunnels below, where a cracker tin reportedly flew through the air.
Address 109 W 6th St, Erie, PA 16501 (Old Main); Schuster Theatre, 620 Sassafras St
Where to look Old Main's stairs to the third floor and the Schuster Theatre
Reported ghosts George the footman, a man in a black cowboy hat
Visiting Working university; Old Main is offices, the Schuster Theatre opens for performances
Tours Campus ghost tours are held at times; check with the university
Ghost hunting No public ghost hunting
Gannon’s Old Main is the former Scott-Strong mansion on West 6th Street, a 46-room house of stone and brick built in the 1890s for Annie Scott Strong and her husband Charles Strong, paid for by her father, the railroad magnate and congressman William L. Scott. The Buffalo firm Green and Wicks designed it. It was sold to Archbishop John Mark Gannon in 1941, became university property in 1945 and is now Gannon’s administration building.
Its ghost is George, said to be a Strong family footman who was dismissed over a romance with a maid and later took his own life. Students blame him for cigar smoke, flickering lights and slamming doors, and a Gannon staff member told the student paper he watched a figure climb to the third floor and vanish. Students also link George to the Schuster Theatre on Sassafras Street, and an older story tells of a man in a black cowboy hat at a fraternity Halloween party who tipped his hat, disappeared, then came back to warn everyone out.
Haunted Rooms tip: Old Main is an office building, so admire the mansion from West 6th Street. The easy way inside the Schuster Theatre is a ticket to a student production.
Where to look O'Neil Tower, Christ the King Chapel and Egan Hall
Reported ghosts A heartbroken nun in the tower, the 'smoking nun' in the chapel garden
Visiting Working university campus; grounds open, buildings for students and staff
Tours Annual haunted campus tour run by alumni relations in late October
Ghost hunting No ghost hunting: it is a private university
Mercyhurst was founded by the Sisters of Mercy and opened as a women’s college in September 1926, with Old Main at its heart. The square O’Neil Tower over the entrance was finished in 1933 to a design by local architect Walter Monahan, after Ferdinand Durang’s original six-story plan was judged impractical. The estate of oilman James O’Neil paid for the tower, the Christ the King Chapel next to it and the grotto.
The tower holds Erie’s best-known campus legend. A young woman is said to have joined the Sisters after hearing her fiancรฉ had been killed in World War II; he came home alive, she could not break her vows, and she took her own life in the tower. Her ring supposedly sat on a statue in the chapel and brought death within five years to anyone who touched it. No record of the nun or the ring has been published, but students still watch the top window, and a second ‘smoking nun’ is said to appear in the chapel garden.
Haunted Rooms tip: This is a working campus, so visit in daylight and keep to public areas. The best way to hear the stories is the haunted campus tour that Mercyhurst alumni relations runs each October.
Where to look The Wayne kettle, the kitchen and the second floor
Reported ghosts General Anthony Wayne, a little girl upstairs
Visiting Museum campus open to visitors; one ticket covers every building
Hours and season Tuesday to Saturday 10 AM to 5 PM, Sunday noon to 5 PM, closed Monday
Tickets Adults $14, veterans $12, students $8, children 6 and under free
Ghost hunting No public ghost hunts advertised
This 24-room sandstone mansion was built in 1891 and 1892 for paper manufacturer Harrison F. Watson, to designs by the Buffalo firm Green and Wicks. Frederic Curtze bought it in 1923, his family gave it away after his death in 1941, and it has been on the National Register since 1983. It is now part of the Hagen History Center campus on West 6th Street, with a ballroom, a solarium and original stained glass.
Its ghost story grows from a real and grisly object. General Anthony Wayne died at the fort on Erie’s Garrison Hill in December 1796. About 13 years later his son Isaac had Dr. J.G. Wallace boil the body down so the bones could be carried home to Radnor, and the history center holds the iron kettle that was used. Visitors and ghost writers say the kettle rattles at night and Wayne appears near it, and older lists add a little girl on the second floor. The center’s own Wayne article treats the ghost as legend.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask at the front desk whether the Wayne kettle is out on display when you visit, and look for the mansion’s Victorian Halloween program in October.
Visiting a haunted place by day is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through a historic building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and vigils, and gives you time to explore on your own. These are the nearest ones we run.
Where to look The balcony staircase, the main stage and the projection room
Reported ghosts Vinny, a cigar-loving former stagehand; a woman on the balcony stairs
Visiting A working theater; go inside with a ticket to a performance
Ghost hunting No public ghost hunts; one investigation by a local group has been reported
Warner Bros. commissioned the Warner Theatre in 1929 as one of its luxury movie palaces, and it opened on April 10, 1931, to designs by the Chicago firm Rapp and Rapp. It joined the National Register in 1982, and a restoration and expansion that began in 2002 rebuilt its State Street marquee. Owned by the Erie County Convention Center Authority, it seats about 2,250 and is home to the Erie Philharmonic and touring Broadway shows.
Two stories are told about the building: a woman seen walking up the staircase to the balcony, and a former stagehand known as Vinny, fond of cigars, said to cross the main stage. The Erie group Eerie Unknown ran what was reported as the first ghost hunt in the theater’s history. It recorded footsteps, a female voice and a shadow figure, and a REM pod in the projection room, though its founder said he could not tell how active the building really is.
What investigators report
During a public ghost hunt, Eerie Unknown investigators set a REM pod in the projection room and asked the presence to back away; they reported it switching on and off on request. They also worked the balcony staircase and the main stage, where visitors have reported apparitions.
Reported ghosts Katie, a girl from the congregation
Visiting Working church; open for Sunday worship
Hours and season Sunday service 10:30 AM (shared with The Cross)
Ghost hunting No public ghost hunting
This downtown brick church at 10th and Peach is the home of the Katie story, which many lists (ours included, and a 2025 TV station feature) place at the Episcopal Cathedral of St. Paul on West 7th Street. The Erie Reader’s 2011 account, from the church’s own minister, puts it here. Katie was a young member of the congregation who loved helping in the nursery and was known for her laugh. In 1994 she was killed when the van bringing her home from church camp hit a tree.
Members say they still hear her laughter and footsteps near the nursery, and that its door opens and closes by itself. Robin Swope, the church’s minister in 2011 and known locally as the Paranormal Pastor, told the Erie Reader the building had hosted around 50 ghost hunts, and one visiting team said it recorded a hymn on the organ at 1 AM when nobody was at the keys. The church now shares Sunday worship with a congregation called The Cross.
What investigators report
The minister says the church has hosted around 50 investigations, with teams focusing on the nursery, where a door is said to open and close by itself, and the sanctuary organ, which one group reported hearing play a hymn at about 1 a.m. with no one at it.
Address Presque Isle State Park, 301 Peninsula Drive, Erie, PA 16505
Where to look The keeper's house, especially the upstairs main bedroom
Reported ghosts Unexplained activity reported by local investigators
Visiting Closed for the 2026 season, grounds included; see it from Presque Isle State Park during park hours
Ghost hunting No public ghost hunts
The Presque Isle Lighthouse stands behind the beach on the lake side of Presque Isle State Park. Its tower went up in 1872 and was first lit on July 12, 1873, with Charles T. Waldo as the first keeper, and keepers lived in the attached brick house for decades. In 2014 the state leased it for 35 years to a nonprofit, which opened it for tours in 2015 and plans to restore its late 1800s look.
Its ghost story is a modern one. The Erie group Eerie Unknown told the Erie Times-News that after four or five visits it found the most activity in the upstairs main bedroom of the keeper’s house, and the lighthouse has hosted Fright Night evenings that mixed Presque Isle legends with the group’s findings. The lighthouse and its grounds are closed for the 2026 season, so for now you can only see it from the park.
Haunted Rooms tip: Walk the beach at dusk for the classic view of the tower, and check the lighthouse website for the 2027 season.
Address Cooper Road trailhead, Harborcreek Township, PA (Penn State Behrend)
Where to look The main trail and the creek bed
Reported ghosts Tim and his dog Dutch
Visiting Public trails; part of the gorge is Penn State Behrend land
Hours and season Daylight hours
Tickets Free
Ghost hunting No organized investigations; stay on the trails and leave by dusk
Fourmile Creek has cut this gorge, about six miles long and up to 250 feet deep, through glacial debris and Devonian shale over roughly 11,000 years. Part of it lies on Penn State Behrend’s campus, which has rebuilt the trail system with a Cooper Road trailhead (17 parking spaces), an accessible main path and a 165-foot boardwalk. The shale banks erode easily, so stay on the marked trail.
The ghost story here is a gentle one. Local lore says a boy and a big Newfoundland dog are seen on the trails early in the morning or late in the evening. The tale makes them Tim, who explored the gorge with his dog Dutch, outlived him, and died in a car crash as a young man, returning in the form he was happiest in. Witnesses say they did not feel afraid. It rests on a few first-hand accounts posted online and retold by local TV, with no record behind it.
Haunted Rooms tip: Park at the Cooper Road trailhead, walk the main trail in daylight, and leave before dark: the gorge sides are steep and unstable.
These places appear in older lists of haunted spots. We keep them here so you know the facts before you go, but you cannot (or should not) visit them.
The Crowley house, East Lake Road
Older lists call this Erie’s first haunted house, with a murdered husband who smashes the china at midnight. The real Crowley house is the stone Greek Revival home Michael Crowley built in 1832 near Fourmile Creek, at 3506 East Lake Road in Lawrence Park Township, and it is a private residence. The family’s history is genuinely hard: Michael died in 1854, his young daughter Mary was killed in a wagon accident, and in 1893 an 80-year-old Bartholomew Crowley was beaten in a home invasion during which a young woman of the family died jumping from an upstairs window. The story that Michael’s wife hastened his death with salty food has no record behind it. Please do not visit, knock or photograph the house.
Nicky's Pub, 1013 State Street
Our old guide listed a haunted bar here, with a man in a long coat in the east hallway, a smell of sulfur and doors closing by themselves. We could not find any current business by that name, and the 4,240-square-foot building was listed for sale in 2017, 2019 and 2020. With nothing to visit, we have moved it here. If you know what is in the building now, tell us with the form below.
Axe Murder Hollow, off Thomas Road
The legend is set in the woods off Thomas Road in southwest Millcreek Township, along Walnut Creek: a jealous husband kills his family with an axe, and a woman is seen running and screaming through the trees. When the Erie Reader searched the records in 2021, it found no axe murder there. The writer suggests the tale grew from a hermit and a 1920s burglary story, and the real 1963 murder of student Mary Lynn Crotty, whose body was left off Thomas Road, added to the area’s dark name. The woods are private land and much of it is now housing. Do not trespass.
Changed from our older guide: the story of Katie belongs to St. Paul’s United Church of Christ on Peach Street, not the Episcopal Cathedral of St. Paul on West 7th Street, so we have moved it; the Crowley house, Nicky’s Pub and Axe Murder Hollow are now on the off-limits list; Erie Cemetery is temporarily closed after the September 2026 storms; we added Hotel Conneaut as a haunted place you can stay near Erie; and we have now added the Warner Theatre and the Presque Isle Lighthouse, which is closed for the 2026 season.
Visited one of these places? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from visitors and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your visit. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most haunted place in Erie, PA?
Erie Cemetery and the Old Main tower at Mercyhurst University are the two most often named. The cemetery has the Vampire Crypt and the Witches’ Circle; Mercyhurst has the legend of a nun who took her own life in the tower after her fiancรฉ came home from World War II.
Is the Mercyhurst nun story true?
No record of the nun or her cursed ring has been published, and the university’s own archive history of the tower does not mention it. Treat it as a much-loved campus legend; the alumni office tells it on its haunted campus tour each October.
Was Anthony Wayne really boiled in Erie?
Yes. Wayne died at the fort on Garrison Hill in December 1796. Around 1809 his son Isaac had Dr. J.G. Wallace boil the remains so the bones could be taken to Radnor, and the Hagen History Center holds the iron kettle. The ghost that rattles it is legend.
Is Erie Cemetery open?
Not at the moment. Severe storms in early September 2026 brought down more than 100 trees and damaged graves and mausoleums, and the cemetery closed to visitors for safety. Check the Erie Cemetery Association’s website for reopening news; it is normally open in daylight.
Where is Axe Murder Hollow in Erie?
The legend is set in the woods off Thomas Road in Millcreek Township. No axe murder has been found in the records, the land is private, and much of it is now housing, so please do not go looking for it.
Can you go ghost hunting in Erie?
There are no regular public ghost hunts in Erie itself. The Brewerie at Union Station runs Haunted History Tours each spring and fall, and the local group Eerie Unknown has investigated the Warner Theatre and the Presque Isle Lighthouse. Haunted Rooms’ nearest events are listed on this page, and Hill View Manor in New Castle hosts overnight investigations.
Sources and how we research
Every place in this guide is checked against its official website, historic register listings and news coverage, and we confirm whether it is open, closed, private or gone before we list it. Ghost stories are reported as staff, visitors and local historians tell them; we say so where records contradict a story. Each place shows how many independent sources we checked it against; our own Haunted Rooms pages are not counted.
New guides, haunted places to visit and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every place in our guides using official sites, historic registers, local archives and news coverage, and we report ghost stories as the stories they are. We review each guide regularly so you are not sent to a place that has closed, changed hands or banned visitors. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.