Haunted Hotels in Key West: The 8 Most Haunted Places to Stay
Key West packs more ghost stories into a few blocks of Old Town than most cities fit into a whole county. These are the eight haunted hotels and guest houses you can actually book, and the rooms to ask for.
Key West has been a wrecking port, a cigar town, a navy base and a writers’ hideaway, and many of its old wooden mansions are now guest houses with a story or two. This guide covers every Key West hotel we could verify that is open to guests and has a ghost story told by staff, guests or local historians, from the house where Robert the Doll lived to the 1926 hotel at the top of Duval Street. We have checked each one against current sources and noted where a legend is just that. For the rest of the state, see our guide to haunted hotels in Florida.
$$$ · Over $300Haunted room bookableGhost tours or eventsHotel embraces its ghostsPet friendly
Address 534 Eaton Street, Key West, FL 33040
Where to look The turret suite, the main staircase and the attic
Reported ghosts Anne Otto, a little girl on the stairs, the shadow of Robert the Doll
Booking the haunted room The turret suite, where Gene Otto and Robert the Doll spent much of their time, can be requested when you book.
This Queen Anne house on Eaton Street was the Otto family home, and it is where Robert Eugene Otto kept Robert, the doll that Key West calls the most haunted object in America. Robert now sits in a case at Fort East Martello Museum, but the house he lived in is a small guest house, and the turret room where Gene and the doll spent their days can be booked.
Local lore says Gene’s wife Anne never left: guests describe a woman on the staircase and a presence in the turret. Key West historian David Sloan has written about a crying little girl seen sitting on the stairs, possibly linked to the family’s nanny. The attic, where Anne is said to have locked Robert away, has the heaviest atmosphere.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for the turret suite when you book; it is the room tied most closely to Gene and Robert.
$$ · $150 to $300Haunted room bookableGhost tours or eventsHotel embraces its ghosts
Address 410 Fleming Street, Key West, FL 33040
Where to look Room 7, the upstairs hallways, the chandelier and the gardens
Reported ghosts Enriquetta Marrero, a playful child, an elderly gentleman
Booking the haunted room Rooms are numbered 1 to 12. The inn links Room 7 to Enriquetta's story; request it when you book (305-294-6977).
Cigar maker Francisco Marrero built this Old Town mansion in 1890 for Enriquetta, the woman he called his wife. After he died on a trip to Cuba, his legal wife arrived from Havana, claimed the house and had Enriquetta and the children put out. The story says Enriquetta vowed to stay in the house she loved, even after death.
Guests describe lavender perfume, someone sitting on the end of the bed and a chandelier that sways when she dislikes a visitor. Today it is a 12-room, adults-only guest house with a pool and a page about its haunting on its own website, and Key West ghost tours stop outside.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for Room 7, the room the inn links to Enriquetta, and book direct by phone if you want it.
Where to look The fifth floor, the elevators, the roof and the Hemingway Suite
Reported ghosts A busboy who fell down the elevator shaft, a wine-loving ghost on the roof
La Concha opened on Duval Street in 1926 as Key West’s first luxury hotel. Ernest Hemingway stayed here, Tennessee Williams is said to have finished A Streetcar Named Desire here, and at seven stories it is still the tallest building on Duval. Formerly the Crowne Plaza La Concha, it completed a $35 million restoration in late 2024 and became La Concha Key West, Autograph Collection.
Its ghost stories are darker than most. Tour guides say more than a dozen people have jumped from the roof over the years, and one is said to take glasses of chardonnay out of drinkers’ hands. A young employee is said to have fallen down an open elevator shaft after a New Year’s Eve party in the 1980s, and guests report the elevator stopping on the fifth floor with nobody waiting.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for a fifth-floor room near the elevators; the restored seventh floor is now rooftop villas, including the Hemingway Suite.
Where to look The kitchen hearth, second-floor rooms and the widow's walk
Reported ghosts Sarah "Aunt Sally" Curry, a housekeeper folding sheets
William Curry arrived in Key West as a teenager in 1836 and died in 1896 as Florida’s first self-made millionaire. His son Milton rebuilt the family home on Caroline Street in the early 1900s, keeping the original stone hearth, and Al and Edith Amsterdam rescued it in the 1970s and turned it into an inn. Today the inn has 29 rooms spread across the mansion and two neighboring buildings.
Staff believe the woman seen by the old kitchen hearth is Sarah “Aunt Sally” Curry, said to have made the island’s first Key lime pie in the cookhouse. Guests on the second floor describe waking to a housekeeper folding sheets at the foot of the bed and hearing coins drop, and lights are said to move along the widow’s walk after dark.
Haunted Rooms tip: Book a room in the main mansion rather than the James House across the street if you want the ghost stories.
$$ · $150 to $300Ghost tours or eventsPet friendly
Address 511 Eaton Street, Key West, FL 33040
Where to look The front porch and front rooms, the garden cistern and fish pond
Reported ghosts Dr. William Warren and his wife Genevieve
Formerly the Eaton Lodge, this three-story Victorian on Eaton Street was built in 1886 and bought in 1913 by Dr. William Warren, a Key West surgeon who saw patients on the front porch and operated in the front rooms. His wife Genevieve, known as Miss Gen, planted the garden, and the house stayed in the family until her death in the early 1970s.
Today it is a bed and breakfast and a stop on Key West ghost tours. Guests say they dream of a doctor who matches Dr. Warren’s description, and Genevieve is usually seen near the cistern and fish pond in her garden. Older stories include footsteps, flickering lights and a sleeping guest who kept finding her blankets tucked back over her.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for one of the rooms in the original front of the house, where Dr. Warren saw his patients.
Where to look The Cosgrove House and the garden paths
Reported ghosts Captain Philip Cosgrove, a little girl who takes pillow chocolates
The Banyan Resort joins seven historic homes on Whitehead Street, set around the huge banyan trees that give it its name. One of them is the Cosgrove House, bought in 1871 by Captain Philip Cosgrove, whose wife Myrtle is credited with planting the banyans. Today the Cosgrove House holds five one-bedroom suites with kitchens, and the resort runs as a timeshare that also rents to nightly guests.
Captain Cosgrove is said to still walk the grounds, and visitors report seeing and hearing him near his old house. The resort’s best-loved story is a little girl who takes the chocolates left on pillows, even in locked rooms, and housekeepers have long told guests about her. Other guests describe knocking with no source and the feeling of a tap on the shoulder in the gardens at night.
Haunted Rooms tip: Request a suite in the Cosgrove House; the resort books mainly direct and through timeshare exchanges.
Reported ghosts A man said to have been murdered by his wife
Booking the haunted room Room 018 is the room linked to the ghost story; ask the front desk whether it is still in use when you book.
The Chelsea House stands on Truman Avenue, a few minutes’ walk from Duval Street, in two Queen Anne style houses built in 1891 and 1905. It was long run as a separate inn by Historic Key West Inns and is now part of Winslow’s Bungalows, a larger Old Town property with heated pools and gardens that still lists the Chelsea House name.
Its ghost story is a grim one. Local legend says the man of the house disappeared, his wife claimed he had gone back to Cuba, and on her deathbed she confessed she had killed him and buried him under the porch. No body has ever been found and no record backs the story, but guests report a man’s apparition and pipe or cigar smoke in Room 018.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for Room 018, the room most often linked to the smell of smoke.
Where to look Third-floor suites facing Duval Street
Reported ghosts An unknown, sighing presence
Ocean Key sits at the very end of Duval Street, beside Mallory Square and its sunset crowds. It is not old: it began in 1982 as a time-share high-rise, became a hotel in 1989 and took its current name in 2005 under Noble House. That makes it an unusual entry on any haunted list, and the owners deny any ghost.
Still, guest accounts keep coming. They center on a third-floor suite overlooking Duval Street, with sighs, jingling keys, cold spots, a weight settling on the edge of the bed and items on the bureau moved overnight. Some think the presence belongs to the land rather than the building.
Haunted Rooms tip: Book a third-floor suite facing Duval Street if you want to test the stories.
What changed in this guide: We added the Curry Mansion Inn, which has published ghost stories, and kept every hotel from our previous list. La Concha is no longer a Crowne Plaza; it reopened as La Concha Key West, Autograph Collection in late 2024. Robert the Doll lives at Fort East Martello Museum, not the Artist House. At Marrero’s, the inn links Enriquetta to Room 7 (rooms are numbered 1 to 12), not Rooms 17, 18 and 23. The Chelsea House and Ocean Key stories are folklore with no supporting records, and Ocean Key’s owners deny any ghost, so we rate them lower.
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
The Artist House on Eaton Street and Marrero’s Guest Mansion on Fleming Street are the two named most often. The Artist House was the Otto family home where Robert the Doll lived, and Marrero’s is said to be haunted by Enriquetta Marrero, who was forced out of the house after her partner’s death.
Can you stay in Robert the Doll's house?
Yes. The Artist House at 534 Eaton Street is a guest house, and you can request the turret suite, the room where Gene Otto and Robert are said to have spent much of their time. Robert himself is on display at Fort East Martello Museum.
Is La Concha in Key West haunted?
It has some of the island’s best-known ghost stories, including a young employee said to have fallen down an elevator shaft after a New Year’s Eve party and a ghost on the rooftop bar who takes people’s chardonnay. It reopened in late 2024 as La Concha Key West, Autograph Collection.
Which Key West hotels have haunted rooms you can request?
Ask for Room 7 at Marrero’s Guest Mansion, the turret suite at the Artist House and Room 018 at the Chelsea House. Call after booking, since rooms are rarely guaranteed.
Do Key West ghost tours visit these hotels?
Yes. Most of the walking ghost tours in Old Town pass the Artist House, Marrero’s, La Concha, the Curry Mansion and Old Town Manor, so you can stay in a hotel you have just heard about on the tour.
Every hotel in this guide is checked against the hotel’s own website, historic register listings and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as the hotels, guests and local historians tell them; we note where a story can’t be confirmed. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page are affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never affects which hotels we include or how we score them.