Haunted hotel guide · Milwaukee, Wisconsin

The Haunted Hilton Garden Inn Milwaukee Downtown: The Loyalty Building and the Newhall House Fire

This downtown Hilton Garden Inn lives inside an 1886 Romanesque office building, raised on the site of the Newhall House, where the deadliest fire in Milwaukee’s history killed more than 70 people in 1883.

By The Haunted Rooms Team · Updated November 2026 · How we rate hotels

2.8/5Haunted Rooms Score
1886Loyalty Building completed
Rooms 201 & 326Most mentioned rooms

Check availabilityMeet the ghosts

The Hilton Garden Inn Milwaukee Downtown is at 611 North Broadway, on Broadway at Michigan Street in the historic East Town business district. It occupies the Loyalty Building, a six-story granite office block designed in the Romanesque style and completed in 1886 as the home office of the Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company. Since 2012 it has been a 127-room hotel inside a landmark, a few minutes’ walk from the lakefront and the Third Ward.

It is also one of the most talked-about haunted hotels in Milwaukee, because of what stood here before. On January 10, 1883, the Newhall House hotel on this corner burned in a fire that killed more than 70 people. Local lore links the hotel’s strange sounds, opening doors and hair-pulling presence to them, and Rooms 201 and 326 come up again and again.

Hilton Garden Inn at a glance

2.8/5
Haunted Rooms Score
Haunted reputation3
History4
Ghost hunter access1
$$ · $150 to $300No pets
  • Address 611 North Broadway, Milwaukee, WI 53202
  • Built 1885 to 1886 for Northwestern Mutual; designed by Solon Spencer Beman; a Hilton Garden Inn since November 2012
  • Most haunted spots Rooms 201 and 326, guest bathrooms and the older corridors
  • Best-known ghosts Victims of the 1883 Newhall House fire, according to local lore; an unseen presence that pulls hair
  • Booking the haunted room Rooms 201 and 326 are regular rooms. Book, then call the hotel to request one; it cannot be guaranteed.
  • Good to know 127 rooms in a six-story landmark listed on the National Register in 1973 as the Home Office of the Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company.

Check availability

The ghosts of Hilton Garden Inn Milwaukee Downtown (Loyalty Building)

The Newhall House fire

Every story told about this hotel goes back to one night. The Newhall House was one of the largest hotels in Wisconsin, and firefighters who had dealt with earlier fires there called it a tinderbox. In the early hours of January 10, 1883, fire broke out in its wooden elevator shaft and spread through the building. Many of the people trapped on the upper floors jumped from their windows. Firefighter Herman Strauss raised a ladder across a neighboring building and carried ten servant women to safety.

Accounts usually give 71 deaths. Researcher Carl Baehr, whose work is summarized in the Encyclopedia of Milwaukee, concluded the true number was 72, only 29 of them identified. Of the 177 people in the building that night, 104 were saved. It remains the deadliest fire in Milwaukee’s history.

Sounds, doors and the hand in your hair

Guests at the Hilton Garden Inn describe unexplained clanking noises around the building, and doors that swing open and shut when nobody is on the other side. Writing in the Shepherd Express in 2025, Milwaukee paranormal author Tea Krulos added staff and guest reports of shadowy figures and sudden, intense feelings of fear.

The most specific story, and the one people remember, is about a restless presence said to pull the hair of guests who are relaxing alone in their rooms. Local storytellers and ghost walk guides link all of it to the victims of the fire, although the Loyalty Building is a different, later building on the same corner.

Rooms 201 and 326

A large share of the accounts come from two rooms, 201 and 326. Nobody has explained why those rooms in particular, and the hotel does not discuss them. If you want to try your luck, they are ordinary guest rooms that you can ask for. Most guests, in any room, simply have a good night’s sleep downtown.

The most haunted rooms and places to look

  • Room 201: One of the two rooms named most often in guests’ stories. A regular room: call after booking to request it.
  • Room 326: The other room that comes up again and again, especially for the hair-pulling story.
  • Bathrooms and older corridors: Where guests describe doors opening and closing on their own and sounds with no source.

History of Hilton Garden Inn Milwaukee Downtown (Loyalty Building)

The Newhall House stood on the corner of Michigan Street and Broadway, one of the biggest hotels in the state, until the fire of January 10, 1883. It took more than 26 hours to put out. The disaster led to a song, “The Milwaukee Fire, or the Burning of the Newhall House”, to monuments to the victims at Forest Home and Calvary cemeteries, and to a memorial Mass that was still being held almost fifty years later.

The Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company built its new home office on the site. Designed by the Chicago architect Solon Spencer Beman, the building went up in 1885 and 1886: a six-story granite office in the Romanesque Revival style, with heavy arches rising three floors above a street-level arcade, a glass-roofed atrium and a grand marble staircase. OnMilwaukee notes that it was meant as a statement of strength and reliability after the disaster on the same corner. It was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1973 as the Home Office of the Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company.

Northwestern Mutual moved to a new headquarters in 1914, and the building, by then known as the Loyalty Building, carried on as offices until 2011, latterly with many empty floors. That year First Hospitality Group bought it and began a $19 million conversion using federal historic preservation tax credits, with Kahler Slater as architect. The Hilton Garden Inn opened in November 2012 with 127 rooms, many with 14-foot ceilings and floor-to-ceiling windows. The atrium lobby, the marble staircase and the company’s original bank safes survive.

Tips for a haunted stay

  • Request Room 201 or 326 by calling the hotel after you book. They are regular rooms and cannot be guaranteed.
  • Take a look at the atrium lobby, the grand marble staircase and the old bank safes, survivors from the building’s insurance company days.
  • Look closely at the building’s stone arches and carving from across Broadway; it is one of downtown’s finest nineteenth-century facades.
  • Visit the Newhall House fire monument at Forest Home Cemetery to pay your respects to the victims.
  • The hotel is an easy walk from the lakefront, the Third Ward and the Pfister Hotel, so you can visit Milwaukee’s most famous haunted lobby the same evening.
  • For a full night of investigating, book our ghost hunt at Ringling House in Baraboo, about two hours west.

Want to investigate, not just sleep?

Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.

See all Wisconsin ghost hunts

More haunted hotels nearby

Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened

We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Hilton Garden Inn Milwaukee Downtown haunted?

It has a reputation. Guests describe sounds with no source, bathroom doors that open and close on their own and something that pulls their hair, especially in Rooms 201 and 326. Local lore links it to the victims of the 1883 Newhall House fire on the same site.

What was the Newhall House fire?

A fire at the Newhall House hotel on January 10, 1883, that killed 71 or 72 people, the deadliest fire in Milwaukee’s history. It started in the wooden elevator shaft and took more than 26 hours to put out.

What is the Loyalty Building?

The 1886 Romanesque office building at 611 North Broadway, built as the home office of Northwestern Mutual on the site of the Newhall House. It now houses the Hilton Garden Inn Milwaukee Downtown.

Can you request Room 201 or 326?

Yes, you can ask. They are regular guest rooms, so call the hotel after booking; the request cannot be guaranteed.

Is the Hilton Garden Inn the same as the Newhall House?

No. The Newhall House burned in 1883. The Loyalty Building was built on its site a few years later, so the ghost stories are about the site rather than the building itself.

When did the Hilton Garden Inn Milwaukee Downtown open?

In November 2012, after a $19 million conversion of the Loyalty Building, which had been offices since 1886.

Sources

Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.

Get new haunted hotel guides by email

New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

About the authors

The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.

Booking links on this page are affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.