Haunted hotel guide · Milwaukee, Wisconsin
The Haunted Pfister Hotel, Milwaukee: Ghosts, Ballplayers and History
Milwaukee’s 1893 “Grand Hotel of the West” is also the hotel that big league ballplayers talk about in hushed voices. Here is what guests and players report, where it happens, and how to plan your own stay.
The Pfister Hotel sits at 424 East Wisconsin Avenue, a few blocks from the Lake Michigan shore, and it has been downtown Milwaukee’s grandest address since 1893. Inside you will find a Victorian art collection that the hotel describes as the largest of any hotel in the world, a lobby of marble, gilt and painted ceilings, and a guest list that has included entertainers, dignitaries and almost every visiting Major League Baseball team.
That last group is the reason the Pfister is one of the most talked-about haunted hotels in America. Players have described footsteps in locked rooms, electronics switching on by themselves and clothes that moved overnight, and some have refused to stay at all. Guests and staff add a quieter story: an elderly gentleman in the halls who many believe is Charles Pfister, the man who finished building the hotel and ran it for more than three decades. This guide gathers the best-documented accounts, the history behind them and practical tips for booking a stay in one of Wisconsin’s most haunted places.
The Pfister at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 424 East Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53202
- Opened 1893, by Guido Pfister and his son Charles; guest tower added in the 1960s
- Most haunted spots Guest floors of the original 1893 building, the grand staircase, the lobby and the Imperial Ballroom
- Best-known ghosts Charles Pfister; unseen knockers, footsteps and pranksters reported by MLB players
- Booking the haunted room There is no named haunted room. Ask for a room in the historic building rather than the tower
- Good to know Owned by the Marcus Corporation. Up to two dogs or cats per room for a one-time $150 fee. Check-in 3 pm
The ghosts of The Pfister Hotel
Charles Pfister, still checking on his hotel
The most familiar story at the Pfister is about Charles Pfister himself. Guests and staff have described an elderly gentleman walking the halls who is there one moment and gone the next. In most tellings he is seen in the public rooms, on the grand staircase or in the corridors of the original building, looking over the hotel as if it were still his.
Charles Pfister completed the hotel his father Guido had planned and ran it until his death in 1927. Local storytellers like to say he never stopped caring about the details. It is a gentle haunting: nobody reports feeling threatened, only watched.
Michael Young and the footsteps in a locked room
The best-known ballplayer story comes from Michael Young, the longtime Texas Rangers infielder. Speaking to ESPN The Magazine in 2013, he described lying in bed after a night game when he heard footsteps stomping around inside his locked room. He had heard the stories about the hotel and was wide awake by the second set of footsteps.
His solution became part of baseball folklore. “Listen, I’m not someone who spreads ghost stories, so if I’m telling you this, it happened,” he said, before explaining that he told the presence to make itself at home: “Hang out, have a seat, but do not wake me up, OK?” He said he heard nothing else for the rest of the night.
Adrian Beltre's sleepless nights
Adrian Beltre’s account is the one most often retold in Milwaukee. As it has been widely reported, he heard knocking in the hallway and on his door, went to look and found nobody there, and later watched the air conditioning and the television switch on and off by themselves. When he finally fell asleep he was woken by pounding from behind his headboard.
He is said to have taken a baseball bat to bed for protection and managed only about two hours of sleep across a three-night stay.
The iPods that turned themselves on
Two players separately described music players misbehaving. Carlos Gomez, then with the Minnesota Twins, said he heard voices in his room the day before a game and that his iPod switched itself on and began vibrating so hard it nearly fell off the table, then did it again after he put it back. In ESPN’s 2013 roundup, Pablo Sandoval of the San Francisco Giants told a similar story from 2009: he left his iPod by a speaker while he showered and came out to find it playing. He stayed at another hotel the following year.
Brandon Phillips of the Cincinnati Reds told ESPN that a radio in his room switched on, so he turned it off and got in the shower. When he came out, it was playing again.
Bryce Harper, C.J. Wilson and a clubhouse full of nerves
Bryce Harper told ESPN that he left his jeans and shirt on the bench at the foot of his bed and woke to find the clothes on the floor and the bench pushed against the far wall, with the door still latched. He moved to a higher floor. C.J. Wilson described lights that flickered and went out, a TV that went dark and scratching inside the walls, and said a teammate claimed to have been locked in his own bathroom.
Not everyone is a believer. Shane Victorino told ESPN there was “nothing wrong with that hotel,” while Giancarlo Stanton and Justin Upton simply said the place unsettled them, Upton to the point of sleeping with the lights on and the blinds open.
Guests' stories: knocks, scattered bags and a shadow at the bed
Ordinary guests tell their own versions. One widely shared account describes a first night in which the phone crackled with static and kept cutting out, there were knocks at the door with no one outside, a toiletry bag was emptied across the bathroom floor, and clothes laid out for the morning were thrown across the room. The guest said he then saw a shadow figure at the end of the bed that pushed him down and laughed. He asked to move, and his new room was quiet.
Other guests mention the sound of dogs playing in empty corridors, electronics that malfunction, and shadow people seen at the edge of their vision. As with any haunted hotel, many more guests sleep soundly and notice nothing at all.
The most haunted rooms and places to look
- The original 1893 building: Nearly all of the classic stories come from guest rooms in the historic building, not the 1960s tower. Ask for a historic room when you book.
- The grand staircase and mezzanine: The places most often linked in retellings with sightings of Charles Pfister, overlooking the three-story lobby and its painted ceiling.
- The Imperial Ballroom: The ballroom with 32-foot ceilings at the heart of the historic building. It is not tied to a specific ghost story, but it is the best place to feel the 1890s scale of the hotel.
- The upper floors used by visiting teams: Players’ stories come from the floors where teams are usually housed; the hotel does not publish which ones, and room numbers are not part of the legend.
History of The Pfister Hotel
Guido Pfister was a German immigrant who made his fortune in tanning; the Pfister and Vogel Leather Company was one of Milwaukee’s great industries. He dreamed of a “palace for the people” downtown. His son Charles saw the project through, and the hotel opened in 1893 at a cost of about $1 million, an enormous sum at the time. It was designed in the Romanesque Revival style by Milwaukee architect Henry C. Koch and billed as the “Grand Hotel of the West.” (Some older retellings, including an earlier version of our state guide, put the cost at $1.5 million; the hotel and Historic Hotels of America both say about $1 million.)
It was remarkably modern for its day, with fireproof construction, electricity throughout, its own power plant and thermostat controls in every guest room. Charles Pfister filled the public rooms with Victorian paintings he collected, and that collection is still on the walls today. During Prohibition he opened the English Room and created an “Indian Punch” that was later bottled and sold nationally.
After World War II the hotel lost some of its luster. In 1962 Milwaukee movie theater operator Ben Marcus bought it and set out to restore it, adding a 23-story guest room tower behind the original building in the 1960s without altering the historic structure. The lobby was later restored to its 1890s appearance. The Marcus Corporation still owns the hotel.
The Pfister is part of the East Side Commercial Historic District on the National Register of Historic Places, has been a member of Historic Hotels of America since 1994 and has held a AAA Four Diamond rating for decades. It is also a member of Preferred Hotels and Resorts. Its long tradition of hosting dignitaries, performers and touring sports teams is what has kept the ghost stories in circulation for more than a century.
Tips for a haunted stay
- Ask for a room in the original 1893 building when you book; most stories come from there, not the tower.
- Take the self-guided art tour of the lobby and mezzanine after dark, when the public rooms are quiet. Group tours led by the Artist in Residence can be booked in advance.
- Have a drink at Blu on the 23rd floor for the views over the city and Lake Michigan, or dine at the Mason Street Grill at street level.
- If you are visiting during a Brewers homestand, look up which team is in town: you may share the elevator with the people who tell these stories.
- Self-parking in the connected garage and valet are both available for a fee; there is no airport shuttle.
- Pair your stay with a ghost hunt at Ringling House in Baraboo, about two hours west.
Want to investigate, not just sleep?
Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.
- Ringling House Ghost Hunt & Sleepover, Baraboo: Investigate Charles Ringling’s 1901 mansion, then stay the night in one of its six rooms.
More haunted hotels nearby
- The Ambassador Hotel, Milwaukee: 1928 Art Deco hotel with a dark Jeffrey Dahmer connection
- Hotel Retlaw, Fond du Lac: Room 717 and a 1923 hotel an hour north
- Haunted hotels in Chicago: An easy 90-minute drive south
- Haunted hotels in Wisconsin
- Haunted hotels in Milwaukee
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Pfister Hotel really haunted?
Nobody can prove it, but the Pfister has more first-hand accounts from named people than almost any hotel in the country. Major League players including Michael Young, Bryce Harper, Pablo Sandoval and C.J. Wilson have described unexplained footsteps, moved clothes and electronics switching on, and guests report seeing Charles Pfister on the stairs.
Who haunts the Pfister Hotel?
The ghost most often named is Charles Pfister, son of founder Guido Pfister, who completed the hotel and ran it until his death in 1927. Other stories involve unseen knocking, footsteps and a shadow figure rather than a named spirit.
Which room at the Pfister is haunted?
There is no single haunted room. Most stories come from the guest floors of the original 1893 building and from the grand staircase and mezzanine, so ask for a historic room rather than one in the tower.
Why do baseball players stay at the Pfister?
It is Milwaukee’s landmark luxury hotel and the usual base for visiting teams playing the Brewers. That is why so many of its ghost stories come from ballplayers.
Does the Pfister Hotel allow pets?
Yes. The hotel allows up to two dogs or cats per room for a one-time, non-refundable $150 fee. Service animals do not need to pay the fee.
Can I tour the Pfister's art collection?
Yes. The Victorian art collection in the lobby and public rooms can be viewed on a self-guided walk, and guided group tours with breakfast or lunch can be booked in advance through the hotel.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
- The Pfister Hotel: About
- Historic Hotels of America: The Pfister Hotel history
- ESPN The Magazine: The haunting of MLB's A-list (Stacey Pressman, 2013)
- Wikipedia: Pfister Hotel
- The Pfister Hotel: Pet policy
- The Pfister Hotel: Guided art tours
- The Pfister Hotel: Frequent questions
Get new haunted hotel guides by email
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page are affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

