Haunted Places in Milwaukee, WI: 14 of the City's Most Haunted
A hotel that rattles visiting ballplayers, a beer baron watching over his mansion, a projectionist in the light booth and a museum director in an opera cape. These are Milwaukee’s ghost stories, with the facts behind them.
Milwaukee’s haunted places line up along Wisconsin Avenue: the Pfister downtown, the Riverside by the river, then west past Marquette to the Pabst Mansion, the Rave, the Ambassador and the Brumder Mansion. Walker’s Point adds Shaker’s, and the old Miller caves sit in Miller Valley. Some stories rest on real tragedy, like the 1883 Newhall House fire under today’s Hilton Garden Inn. Others, like the lovers of the Miller caves, have no record at all, and we say so. Several of these places are hotels where you can spend the night.
Address 424 East Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Where to look Guest floors of the original 1893 building, the grand staircase and lobby, the Imperial Ballroom
Reported ghosts Charles Pfister, the founder's son; unseen knockers and footsteps reported by visiting ballplayers
Visiting A working hotel; the public areas are open to visitors
Ghost hunting No public ghost hunts
The Pfister opened in 1893 as the “Grand Hotel of the West,” built by tannery owner Guido Pfister and his son Charles for about $1 million. It still holds what it calls the largest hotel collection of Victorian art in the world, and it has been owned by the Marcus family’s company since Ben Marcus bought it in 1962 and added a 23-story guest tower.
It is also the hotel where most visiting Major League Baseball teams stay when they play the Brewers, which is how its ghost stories went national. Players including Bryce Harper, Pablo Sandoval, Michael Young and C.J. Wilson have described moved clothes, radios and iPods switching on, footsteps and scratching in the walls. Guests also tell of an elderly gentleman on the stairs who looks a lot like Charles Pfister.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for a room in the original 1893 building, then walk the lobby and mezzanine to see the Victorian art collection.
Where to look The main staircase, the chandeliers, the upstairs rooms and the lower level
Reported ghosts Captain Frederick Pabst, a watchful man in the house, cigar smoke and perfume
Visiting House museum open daily; check in at the visitor center next door
Tours Guided 60-minute tours and self-guided visits daily; Behind-the-Scenes tours May to September; candlelit Illuminating the Dark tours in October
Hours and season Sunday to Thursday 10 am to 4 pm, Friday and Saturday 10 am to 5 pm
Ghost hunting No ghost hunting; tours focus on the family and the house
Beer baron Frederick Pabst, founder of the Pabst Brewing Company, built this Flemish Renaissance Revival mansion on Wisconsin Avenue between 1890 and 1892, designed by George Bowman Ferry. The family lived here until 1908, then the Archdiocese of Milwaukee owned it for 67 years and five archbishops lived in it. In the 1970s it was slated to make way for a parking structure, until a preservation group bought it in 1978 and opened it as a museum.
Staff, volunteers and contractors have told local reporters about doors opening and closing, chandeliers swinging or ringing with nobody upstairs, candles popping out of candelabra and the smell of cigars and perfume. The best-known story is a workman who was watched all day by a man he later recognized in a portrait of Captain Pabst. The mansion itself plays the stories down, and one ghost group reportedly found nothing.
Haunted Rooms tip: Book the candlelit Illuminating the Dark tour in October, which opens seldom-seen lower-level spaces after hours.
Where to look The old projection booth and its steep stairs, the upper hallways, the basement
Reported ghosts A projectionist who died in the booth, children laughing upstairs, growling in the basement
Visiting A working concert venue; go to a show
Tours Seasonal ghost tours have run in October
Ghost hunting Occasional ticketed late-night ghost investigations in October
The Riverside opened on April 29, 1928, as a vaudeville palace by architects Charles Kirchhoff and Thomas Rose, and later became a movie house. A 1984 renovation restored its Wurlitzer organ, and since 2005 it has been run by the Pabst Theater Group as one of Milwaukee’s main concert halls, seating about 2,500.
It has a reputation as one of the most haunted theaters in the state. The story told most is of a projectionist who had a heart attack in the booth while changing reels and who now plays with the stage lights. People also describe children laughing in the upper halls and growling in the basement. The theater has run October ghost tours, including late-night investigations with a seance on the stage.
What investigators report
On the theater’s ghost hunts, investigators have placed children’s toys in the dark 4th-floor hallway, where people report hearing children running and laughing. Teams also report capturing EVPs in the basement beneath the stage using voice recorders, EMF meters and a spirit box.
Address 2308 West Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53233
Where to look The fifth floor (the room usually given as 506 or 507), guest room corridors, the Art Deco lobby
Reported ghosts Unnamed presence often linked to Steven Tuomi; beds made and unmade, moved objects
Visiting A working hotel; the public areas are open to visitors
Ghost hunting No public ghost hunts
The Ambassador opened in 1928 as one of Milwaukee’s smart Art Deco hotels, a few blocks west of downtown near Marquette University. It slid into decline in the 1980s and became a low-rent residence hotel, then was rescued and restored by developer Rick Wiegand, who brought back the original lobby sconces, plasterwork and bronze elevator doors.
Its dark footnote is Jeffrey Dahmer. In November 1987 Dahmer took Steven Tuomi to a room he had rented at the Ambassador and woke to find him dead. Retellings put the room on the fifth floor. Guests since have described a heavy feeling up there, beds that are made or unmade before housekeeping arrives, items that vanish and turn up elsewhere, and writing on fogged mirrors.
Haunted Rooms tip: The hotel does not market a Dahmer room, so be respectful. Book a historic room and have a drink in the restored Art Deco lobby.
Where to look The third floor where Dr. Borhegyi's portrait hangs, the Streets of Old Milwaukee, the elevators
Reported ghosts Dr. Stephan de Borhegyi, the museum director who died in 1969
Visiting Public museum; moving to a new building in early 2027
Ghost hunting No ghost hunting
The Milwaukee Public Museum was chartered in 1882 and opened in 1884. Its current building on Wells Street was finished in 1962, and its Streets of Old Milwaukee, the first big exhibit built there, opened in 1965. The museum is building a new home in the Haymarket neighborhood, due to open in early 2027 as the Nature and Culture Museum of Wisconsin.
Staff say the building has been haunted since Dr. Stephan de Borhegyi, the Hungarian-born director who created its walk-through exhibits, died in a car crash on his way to work in 1969. He is said to stay on the third floor, where his portrait hangs. People describe a caped figure, he wore an opera cape, cold rushes of air, pipe smoke, laughter, motion alarms tripping and an elevator that opens by itself.
Haunted Rooms tip: See the Streets of Old Milwaukee and the third floor before the move to the new building in 2027.
Open to the publicGhost toursOvernight investigations
Address 422 S 2nd St, Milwaukee, WI 53204
Where to look The basement and walk-in cooler, the women's restroom, the upstairs penthouse
Reported ghosts O'Connor in the basement, a little girl called Elizabeth, mob-era figures
Visiting A working bar; over 21 unless on a tour with consent
Tours Paranormal tours of the building, plus true crime and Prohibition walking tours
Ghost hunting Bar-run paranormal tours; overnight stays in the penthouse
Shaker’s is in an 1894 building in Walker’s Point that began as a cooperage making barrels for a Schlitz subsidiary and was later a coal and oil depot. During Prohibition it is said to have been a speakeasy with a brothel upstairs, though Milwaukee Magazine noted no records confirm it. Owner Bob Weiss opened the bar in 1986 and has promoted its ghosts and cigars ever since.
Staff tell of O’Connor, a basement spirit blamed for vanishing whiskey, a walk-in cooler that shuts on people, and Elizabeth, a little girl heard giggling in the women’s restroom who has a raspberry martini named after her. Stories of skeletons and murdered politicians in the basement come from psychics and lore. The bar runs paranormal tours of the building and rents the old upstairs as an overnight penthouse.
Haunted Rooms tip: Book one of the bar’s paranormal tours, or the penthouse if you want to spend the night.
Visiting a haunted place by day is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through a historic building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and vigils, and gives you time to explore on your own. These are the nearest ones we run.
Mortuary Manor Ghost Hunt, Toledo: investigate a former north Toledo funeral home with its embalming rooms, basement morgue and viewing parlors still in place.
Where to look The empty basement swimming pool, backstage corridors
Reported ghosts A boy said to have drowned in the pool, children's voices, a cranky former janitor
Visiting A working concert venue; the pool is backstage
Ghost hunting No public ghost hunts
The Eagles Club opened on September 13, 1927, a five-story Mediterranean Revival clubhouse by Russell Barr Williamson for the Fraternal Order of Eagles, with a ballroom, bowling alley and a swimming pool in the basement. It was listed on the National Register in 1986 and reopened in 1991 as the Rave, a complex of six music venues.
The ghost stories gather around the pool, empty for decades. UpNorthNews reports that a 15-year-old boy drowned there in 1927, months after the club opened, and touring bands tell of children’s voices when nobody else is around. Others describe a girl by the pool and a grumpy janitor. Performers sign the pool walls; Mac Miller wrote “My soul remains here.” Our older guide said Buddy Holly played one of his last shows here; we could not confirm that.
What investigators report
On the venue’s behind-the-scenes ghost tours, guides stop at the old underground pool and ask guests to stay silent and listen. People report hearing footsteps, children laughing and a woman singing when no one else is there.
Where to look Rooms 201 and 326, bathrooms, older corridors
Reported ghosts Victims of the 1883 Newhall House fire, according to local lore; a hair-pulling presence
Visiting A working hotel; the public areas are open to visitors
Ghost hunting No public ghost hunts
This Hilton Garden Inn sits inside the Loyalty Building, a six-story Romanesque Revival granite office block completed in 1886 for Northwestern Mutual and converted into a 127-room hotel in 2012. It was built on the site of the Newhall House, a downtown hotel that burned on January 10, 1883, in one of the deadliest hotel fires in American history, with more than 70 people killed.
Local lore ties the hotel’s stories to those victims. Guests describe odd sounds with no source, bathroom doors that open and close on their own, and something that tugs at the hair of people who are alone in their rooms. Rooms 201 and 326 come up again and again in the accounts.
Haunted Rooms tip: Call after booking to request Room 201 or 326. They are ordinary rooms and cannot be guaranteed.
Address 3046 West Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53208
Where to look The suites upstairs, the lobby and stairs, the lower level once used as a speakeasy
Reported ghosts Suzanne, a former housekeeper; a woman from the speakeasy years
Visiting A working hotel; the public areas are open to visitors
Ghost hunting No public ghost hunts
Newspaper publisher George Brumder built this brick mansion in 1910 for his eldest son, in a mix of English Arts and Crafts, Victorian and Gothic styles. Local history says later owners ran it as a club and speakeasy during Prohibition. After decades of other uses it was restored as a bed and breakfast with four suites, the Emma, George, Gyneth and Marion, a short drive west of downtown.
Owners and guests describe a housekeeper’s ghost, usually called Suzanne, who seems unwilling to leave, and a younger woman tied to the speakeasy years. Pictures that were fastened to walls drop without breaking, doors open and slam in the night, and the doorbell has played tunes it was never set to play.
What investigators report
Members of a TV crew who stayed overnight with Paranormal Investigators of Milwaukee singled out the basement and Marion’s Suite, reporting static sensations, a touch near the head and one full-figure sighting in the basement.
Where to look The cold stone in St. Joan of Arc Chapel, Straz Tower, Helfaer Theater, Johnston and Humphrey Halls
Reported ghosts Whispering Willie in Straz Tower, a director at the Helfaer, a priest in Johnston Hall
Visiting Campus; the chapel welcomes visitors, residence halls are private
Ghost hunting No ghost hunting on campus
The little stone St. Joan of Arc Chapel was built in Chasse-sur-Rhone, south of Lyon, probably in the 15th century. It was shipped to a Long Island estate in 1927 and then moved stone by stone to Marquette, where it was dedicated in 1966. Legend says Joan of Arc knelt and prayed on a flat stone now behind the altar, and the stone is said to feel colder than those around it.
The rest of the campus has its own stories, told by students and local guides rather than records: Whispering Willie in Straz Tower, once a YMCA, a long-dead artistic director in the Helfaer Theater, a Jesuit priest in Johnston Hall and child patients in Humphrey Hall, which was Children’s Hospital from 1923 to 1988. The residence halls are for students only; the chapel is the place visitors can go.
What investigators report
Visitors to the St. Joan of Arc Chapel traditionally touch the stone near the altar that Joan is said to have kissed, and many report it feels cooler than the stones around it.
Address 509 West Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53203
Where to look Guest room floors of the 1928 tower, quiet corridors at night
Reported ghosts An unseen presence some link to Walter Schroeder
Visiting A working hotel; the public areas are open to visitors
Ghost hunting No public ghost hunts
The Hilton Milwaukee opened in 1928 as the Schroeder Hotel, the 25-story Art Deco flagship of Walter Schroeder’s Midwest hotel chain, with 811 rooms and the title of Wisconsin’s tallest hotel. It later became the Sheraton-Schroeder, the Marc Plaza and, from 1995, the Hilton Milwaukee City Center. A $42 million renovation finished in January 2026 gave it the shorter name Hilton Milwaukee, and it was listed on the National Register as the Hotel Schroeder in 2024.
The ghost stories here are guest stories rather than legends. One widely shared review describes a daughter and her mother who felt the hotel was haunted from the moment they arrived: a laptop switching songs by itself, drawers opening and closing, a bathroom light flicking on and off, and Siri answering “Well that’s not very nice” when the mother told the presence to leave. Some people say Walter Schroeder still checks on his finest hotel.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for a high floor in the original 1928 tower and take a look at the restored Art Deco lobby.
Where to look The tower stairs and the keeper's quarters
Reported ghosts Children heard screaming, cold pockets of air, a feeling of sadness
Visiting Museum in Lake Park
Hours and season Saturdays and Sundays 1 to 4 pm
Ghost hunting No ghost hunting
Milwaukee’s first lighthouse on this bluff was lit in 1855. Erosion forced a new cast iron tower and Queen Anne keeper’s house farther back in 1888, and in 1912 the tower was set on a steel base to raise it to 74 feet. Georgia Stebbins kept the light from 1874 to 1907, one of the few women to hold the job in her own right. The Coast Guard closed it in 1994, and volunteers reopened it as a museum in Lake Park in 2007.
Ghost lists say some visitors hear children screaming when no children are near, and feel cold pockets of air and a sense of sadness. No names, dates or events are attached to the story, and the museum itself does not talk about ghosts; its focus is the keepers and the light. It is still one of the city’s oldest landmarks and a fine place to stand on the bluff at dusk.
Haunted Rooms tip: Climb the tower on a weekend afternoon, then walk Lake Park’s ravine paths as the light fades.
Where to look The cave entrance and the stairwell inside
Reported ghosts A young brewery worker and his sweetheart, seen together at the cave mouth
Visiting Seen on the Miller brewery tour; the caves are an event space
Ghost hunting No ghost hunting
Charles and Lorenz Best began digging storage caves for their Plank Road Brewery in 1850, and Frederick Miller, who bought the brewery in 1855, kept tunneling: by 1885 about 600 feet of brick and limestone tunnels held 12,000 barrels of lager, kept cold with lake ice. Sealed in 1908 and found again in 1946, the caves became a Cold War shelter and, from 1954, the base of the Miller brewery tour, now run by Molson Coors.
Miller workers have passed down the legend for generations: a brewery worker met his sweetheart at the cave mouth every Saturday night one summer, until he fell on a cave stairway and died. She died months later, of a lung ailment by the doctor’s account and of a broken heart by everyone else’s, and the two are said to appear together, glowing, at the entrance. Staff and guards tell of voices, laughter and footsteps. No record of the couple has been found.
Haunted Rooms tip: Take the Miller brewery tour, which takes in the caves, and ask the guide about the lovers.
Address 100 E Hawthorne Ave, South Milwaukee, WI 53172
Where to look The timber gateway and the footbridges over the ravine
Reported ghosts A woman in white on the bridges, footsteps, screams in the woods
Visiting Public county park trail
Hours and season The park closes at 10 PM and is patrolled
Ghost hunting Park rules and hours apply
The Seven Bridges Trail winds through a wooded ravine in Grant Park in South Milwaukee, crossing more than seven wooden footbridges. Frederick C. Wulff, the county’s first horticulture superintendent, began it in 1914, and Depression-era WPA and CCC crews added stone stairs, walls and the covered entrance bridge. Its words, “Enter this wild wood and view the haunts of nature,” come from a William Cullen Bryant poem and have done a lot for the trail’s reputation.
People describe screams in the dark woods, footsteps and heavy breathing on the bridges, a misty shape at the entrance and a sudden feeling of fear, and some say a woman in white walks the lakeside path looking for children said to have drowned in Lake Michigan. None of it has any record behind it, but it is a lovely, eerie walk at dusk.
Haunted Rooms tip: Walk it at dusk with a flashlight and keep to the trail; the bridges and ravine get slippery.
Changed from our older guide: we now list 14 places instead of 10, adding the Riverside Theater, Shaker’s, the Ambassador and the Hilton Milwaukee. The Rave’s pool story now follows UpNorthNews, which reports a 15-year-old boy drowned there in 1927; we could not confirm that Buddy Holly played one of his last shows here. The North Point Lighthouse story of screaming children has no names or events behind it, and we say so. The Milwaukee Public Museum moves to a new building in 2027.
Visited one of these places? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from visitors and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your visit. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most haunted place in Milwaukee?
The Pfister Hotel, where visiting baseball players have described footsteps, moving clothes and electronics switching on. The Pabst Mansion and the Riverside Theater are close behind.
Is the Pabst Mansion haunted?
Staff, volunteers and contractors have told stories of swinging chandeliers, cigar smoke and a man who looks like Captain Pabst. The mansion itself plays the stories down, and one ghost group reportedly found nothing.
Are there ghost tours in Milwaukee?
Yes. Shaker’s Cigar Bar runs paranormal tours of its building, the Riverside Theater has run October ghost tours, and walking tour companies cover downtown and Walker’s Point.
Can I stay overnight somewhere haunted in Milwaukee?
The Pfister, the Brumder Mansion, the Ambassador, the Hilton Garden Inn in the Loyalty Building and the Hilton Milwaukee all take guests, and Shaker’s rents an upstairs penthouse.
Who haunts the Milwaukee Public Museum?
Staff tell of Dr. Stephan de Borhegyi, the director who died in a car crash in 1969, said to linger on the third floor where his portrait hangs.
Sources and how we research
Every place in this guide is checked against its official website, historic register listings and news coverage, and we confirm whether it is open, closed, private or gone before we list it. Ghost stories are reported as staff, visitors and local historians tell them; we say so where records contradict a story. Each place shows how many independent sources we checked it against; our own Haunted Rooms pages are not counted.
New guides, haunted places to visit and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every place in our guides using official sites, historic registers, local archives and news coverage, and we report ghost stories as the stories they are. We review each guide regularly so you are not sent to a place that has closed, changed hands or banned visitors. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.