Haunted hotel guide · Waterbury, Vermont
The Haunted Old Stagecoach Inn, Waterbury, VT: Nettie and Room 2
An 1826 stagecoach tavern on Waterbury’s Main Street, where the lady of the house, who lived to 99, is still said to check on her guests.
The Old Stagecoach Inn sits on North Main Street in Waterbury, a white Victorian inn with a long porch hung with flower boxes, ten minutes from Ben and Jerry’s and twenty from the slopes at Stowe. It is a small bed and breakfast with eleven rooms, numbered rather than named, and a big hot breakfast in the morning.
It is also one of the most talked-about haunted inns in Vermont. Guests and innkeepers have described an older woman in a long dress with her hair pulled into a tight bun, and most people believe she is Nettie Henry Spencer, the eccentric heiress who made this house her home and lived to 99. Here is her story, what guests report, the building’s long history and which room to ask for.
Old Stagecoach Inn at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 18 North Main Street, Waterbury, VT 05676
- Built 1826; a stagecoach inn and tavern soon after, a bed and breakfast since the late 1980s
- Most haunted spots Room 2, Room 3, the third floor
- Best-known ghost An older woman in a long dress, believed to be Nettie Spencer
- Booking the haunted room Rooms are booked by number; choose Room 2 on the inn’s website or ask when you call
- Good to know Eleven rooms and a suite, full breakfast included, pet-friendly rooms available, walk to downtown Waterbury
The ghosts of the Old Stagecoach Inn
Nettie Henry Spencer
Margaret Annette Henry, known as Nettie, was born in Waterbury in 1848. Her family owned the house by 1890, when it was known as the Henry Farm. She married Albert H. Spencer, an industrialist who had made a fortune in rubber, and it was Nettie who added the porches and trim that give the building its Queen Anne look today.
After her husband died in 1907 she traveled the world, then came home as a widow to live in the house. Locals remembered her as eccentric. She lived to 99 and is buried in a mausoleum beside the Congregational Church cemetery next door. The Rutland Herald, writing about the inn’s ghost stories, put it plainly: if anyone is haunting the place, Nettie is the obvious candidate.
The woman at the foot of the bed
Room 2 is considered the most haunted room in the inn, and guests still request it by number. One man told the Rutland Herald that he and his wife woke to see an older woman in a long dress, hair in a tight bun, standing at the foot of their bed. The description matches what other guests have reported over the years, and it matches Nettie.
The midnight check-in
The inn’s strangest story concerns Room 3. A couple arrived well after midnight, long after their reservation had been canceled for the night. The next morning they thanked the innkeepers for the kind older woman in a long dress, hair in a bun, who had let them in and shown them to their room. No guest matched the description, and nobody in the house admitted to opening the door.
Stripped beds and moving chairs
Other reports are household mischief. Housekeepers have turned away from a freshly made bed and turned back to find it stripped, with the linens folded neatly. Furniture, especially the rocking chairs, has been found moved. Bottles of Scotch once vanished and reappeared the next day, and a fire alarm on the empty third floor was found pulled off the wall.
Longtime innkeeper Jack Barwick said he did not believe in ghosts, but that some events “tested your sense of reality,” and that the activity seemed to fade over the years. That is an honest place to leave it.
The most haunted rooms and places to look
- Room 2: The most requested room, where guests saw a woman standing at the foot of the bed.
- Room 3: The room a mysterious older woman showed late arrivals to after midnight.
- The third floor: Where a fire alarm was found pulled from the wall in an empty building.
History of Old Stagecoach Inn
The house was built in 1826 by a Mr. Allen in the Federal style, with woodwork by the brothers Horace and Henry Atkins. Its first occupant was Dan Carpenter, Waterbury’s first lawyer. Before long it became a stagecoach inn and tavern, a natural stop on the road between Montpelier, Burlington and the mountain village of Stowe.
When the railroad arrived, city families came north to escape summer heat and broke their journey in Waterbury before heading on to the Stowe resorts. By 1890 the house belonged to the Henry family and was known as the Henry Farm. Nettie Henry and her husband, Albert Spencer, remodeled the front with the Victorian additions that survive today.
After Nettie’s time the building passed through several owners. It was a family home and rental units and later a rooming house that took in patients from the Vermont State Hospital in Waterbury. By the 1980s it was run down. In 1985 Kimberlee and James Marcotte, a Boston couple with family ties to Waterbury, began a two-year restoration and opened it as a Victorian country bed and breakfast.
The Marcottes sold to Jack and John Barwick, a father and son from Connecticut, who ran the inn for about 25 years. Jack died in 2017, and in 2022 John Barwick sold the inn to its current owner, Christa Bowdish. The building is part of the Waterbury Village Historic District.
Tips for a haunted stay
- Book Room 2 for the full story, or Room 3 if you would rather meet Nettie at the front door.
- Walk next door to the Congregational Church cemetery, where Nettie’s mausoleum stands.
- Breakfast is generous: skip the early lunch.
- Waterbury is ten minutes from Ben and Jerry’s factory tours and twenty from Stowe.
- Pair the stay with a night at the Green Mountain Inn in Stowe and its tap dancing ghost.
Want to investigate, not just sleep?
Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.
- Fort William Henry Ghost Hunt, Lake George, NY: Investigate the rebuilt 1755 fort on Lake George.
More haunted hotels nearby
- Green Mountain Inn, Stowe: Boots Berry and Room 302
- Haunted hotels in Vermont: Every haunted inn in the state
- Haunted places in Vermont: Beyond the hotels
- Haunted hotels in Vermont
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Old Stagecoach Inn in Waterbury haunted?
Guests and innkeepers have reported an older woman in a long dress with her hair in a bun, beds stripped and linens folded, moving rocking chairs and other odd events. Most believe the ghost is Nettie Henry Spencer.
Who was Nettie at the Old Stagecoach Inn?
Margaret Annette Henry Spencer, born in Waterbury in 1848, whose family owned the house. She married industrialist Albert H. Spencer, lived to 99 and is buried next door.
Which room is haunted at the Old Stagecoach Inn?
Room 2 is considered the most haunted, where guests saw a woman at the foot of the bed. Room 3 has its own story.
When was the Old Stagecoach Inn built?
In 1826, as a Federal style house that soon became a stagecoach inn and tavern.
Who owns the Old Stagecoach Inn?
Christa Bowdish, who bought it from longtime innkeeper John Barwick in 2022.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
- Old Stagecoach Inn: inn history
- Old Stagecoach Inn: official site
- Rutland Herald: Ghost stories brew anew in Vermont
- Haunted Places: The Old Stagecoach Inn
Get new haunted hotel guides by email
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page are affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

