Haunted hotel guide · Bethlehem, Pennsylvania
The Haunted Sayre Mansion: Robert Sayre, a Lady in the Mirror of Room 23 and a Shadow in Room 32
Sayre Mansion is the 1858 Gothic Revival home of Robert Heysham Sayre, the Lehigh Valley Railroad engineer and industrialist, restored as a 23-room boutique inn.
Sayre Mansion is the 1858 Gothic Revival home of Robert Heysham Sayre, the Lehigh Valley Railroad engineer and industrialist, restored as a 23-room boutique inn. Sayre himself is said to linger in the house, a woman's reflection appears in the bathroom mirror of Room 23, and a dark shape is reported emerging from the wall of third-floor Room 32. The owners have leaned into the stories with paranormal nights that pair a stay with a ghost hunt.
Sayre Mansion at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 250 Wyandotte Street, Bethlehem, PA 18015
- Opened Built in 1858 as the Gothic Revival home of Lehigh Valley Railroad engineer Robert Heysham Sayre, whose family lived there until 1916; now a restored boutique inn.
- Most haunted spots Room 23, Room 32 on the third floor, and the first-floor suite associated with Robert Sayre.
- Best-known ghosts Robert Sayre, the original owner; a woman seen in the bathroom mirror of Room 23 (one of the four Mrs. Sayres, perhaps); and a dark shape in Room 32 that some connect to Cecil, the youngest Sayre son, who lived only a year.
- Booking the haunted room Room 23 and Room 32 are both regular bookable rooms, so request them by number. Visit PA notes that guests in the first-floor suite may glimpse Robert Sayre. Ask the inn whether paranormal night packages with Wyoming Valley Ghost Tours are on the calendar.
- Good to know The inn has 23 rooms and suites across the mansion and its carriage house, including the rooftop Conservatory with a 180-degree view over Bethlehem, the two-room Robert Sayre Library suite and the Hayloft suite in the Carriage House. It sits on about two acres. Paranormal nights reported in 2023 included a one-night stay, dinner and breakfast for two, and a ghost hunt.
The ghosts of Sayre Mansion
Robert Sayre Still at Home
Robert Heysham Sayre, chief engineer of the Lehigh Valley Railroad, lived in the house with his family from 1858 to 1916, and he is said never to have left. Visit PA, the state tourism office, says guests staying in the first-floor suite may catch a glimpse of the original owner. Lehigh Valley Public Media, in an October 2023 roundup of local ghosts by Micaela Hood, reported that Sayre is said to haunt the bed and breakfast along with other spirits, and named both his first-floor suite and Room 23 as rooms where guests can stay. The inn itself has embraced the reputation by hosting paranormal nights with a local ghost tour company.
The Lady in the Mirror of Room 23
Room 23 is the inn's most talked-about room. According to Discover Lehigh Valley, the regional tourism bureau, guests may see a ghostly woman in the bathroom mirror, and the room was once Mrs. Sayre's bedchamber. There is a catch: Robert Sayre married four times, so no one can say which Mrs. Sayre she might be. Visit PA describes the reflection as his wife's, and Lehigh Valley Public Media reports that hoteliers themselves have seen a woman's reflection in the Room 23 mirror. Discover Lehigh Valley says the inn's haunted rooms are highly sought after by guests who want to pair a ghost-themed trip with an overnight stay.
The Shadow in Room 32
Up on the third floor, Room 32 was once used by the household staff and the Sayre children. Discover Lehigh Valley reports that visitors have described a dark shape that seems to emerge from the wall. Some believe it may be Cecil, the youngest Sayre son, who lived only one year. As with the woman in Room 23, the identification is speculation built on the family's history rather than anything confirmed, but it makes Room 32 the choice for guests who want a quieter, more mysterious story. Like Room 23, it is a standard guest room that can be booked by number.
The most haunted rooms and places to look
Room 23 (the woman in the bathroom mirror, once Mrs. Sayre's bedchamber), Room 32 on the third floor (a dark shape emerging from the wall), and the first-floor suite where Robert Sayre is said to appear.
History of Sayre Mansion
The mansion was built in 1858 for Robert Heysham Sayre, chief engineer of the Lehigh Valley Railroad, on about two acres in Bethlehem. The Gothic Revival house remained the Sayre family home until 1916. Sayre married four times, a detail that complicates the ghost story of the woman in Room 23.
Today the house and its carriage house have been restored as a 23-room boutique inn, with suites named for the family, such as the Robert Sayre Library and the William Sayre Suite, as well as a rooftop conservatory. Its ghost stories appear in guides from Visit PA and Discover Lehigh Valley, and in 2023 the owners were hosting paranormal nights with Wyoming Valley Ghost Tours.
Tips for a haunted stay
- Book Room 23 and check the bathroom mirror before bed.
- Ask about paranormal night packages that include dinner and a ghost hunt.
- Request Room 32 on the third floor if Room 23 is taken.
Want to investigate, not just sleep?
Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.
- The Haunted Shanley Hotel Ghost Hunt: Napanoch, New York, about 94 miles away.
- The Gettysburg Academy Bed & Breakfast Ghost Hunt: Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, about 112 miles away.
More haunted hotels nearby
- Historic Hotel Bethlehem: Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, in the same town
- Widow McCrea House: Frenchtown, New Jersey, about 18 miles away
- Black Bass Hotel: Lumberville, Pennsylvania, about 23 miles away
- Haunted hotels in Pennsylvania
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is Sayre Mansion haunted?
Tourism guides say Robert Sayre still lingers, a woman's reflection appears in Room 23's mirror and a dark shape emerges from the wall in Room 32.
Which room at Sayre Mansion is haunted?
Room 23 is the best known, with Room 32 and the first-floor suite also linked to the stories.
Does Sayre Mansion host ghost hunts?
In 2023 the owners hosted paranormal nights with a stay, dinner, breakfast and a ghost hunt with Wyoming Valley Ghost Tours. Ask the inn about current dates.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
- Lehigh Valley Public Media: Famous entities, meet some of the Lehigh Valley's ghosts (Oct 2023)
- Discover Lehigh Valley: Lehigh Valley Haunts
- Visit PA: Haunted Hotels in Pennsylvania
- Sayre Mansion: Rooms
- Sayre Mansion: Official site
Get new haunted hotel guides by email
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page may be affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

