Haunted hotel guide · Cazenovia, New York
The Haunted Brae Loch Inn: The Girl in the Blue Dress and Scotty's Kilted Ghost
A Scottish-themed inn in an 1805 house beside Cazenovia Lake, the Brae Loch Inn is known for a ghostly girl in a long blue dress who offers to show guests to their rooms.
A Scottish-themed inn in an 1805 house beside Cazenovia Lake, the Brae Loch Inn is known for a ghostly girl in a long blue dress who offers to show guests to their rooms. Staff and guests also describe a kilted man thought to be the family's own Scotty Brown, a phantom dinner party and orbs of light drifting through canopy beds. The inn sells a Ghostly Getaway package with a private ghost tour and hosts ghost story dinners each fall.
The Brae Loch Inn at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 5 Albany St, Cazenovia, NY 13035
- Opened Built in 1805 as the William Burr estate, the house was taken over by the Barr family around 1950 after their original Brae Loch restaurant (opened 1946 on Skaneateles Lake) moved to Cazenovia, and it has since operated as a Scottish-themed restaurant and inn.
- Most haunted spots Room 12 (Mary Queen of Scots), Room 13 (Robert The Bruce), the main dining room, the closed-off curved staircase, guest rooms in the original part of the house
- Best-known ghosts The girl in the long blue dress, described as a chambermaid; Adam 'Scotty' Brown in his kilt; a phantom dinner party; a crying child
- Booking the haunted room Call the inn at (315) 655-3431 and ask for the Ghostly Getaway or 'Ghost Tour.' The package, from $225 for two including tax, includes one night in a king canopy deluxe room with a fireplace or jacuzzi, a private ghost tour, a $66.50 dinner and drinks voucher and continental breakfast. It runs Sunday through Thursday from May 1 to October 31 and daily from November 1 to April 30. Ask for Room 12 or Room 13, which the Haunted History Trail lists as the most active.
- Good to know The inn has 12 guest rooms with private bathrooms, individual heat and air conditioning, cable TV and Wi-Fi, priced at about $130 to $170 a night. Its restaurant serves American cuisine with Scottish and French influences in fireplace-lit dining rooms with tartan carpet, and there is a pub with lighter fare. Dinner with the Spirits events have cost $40 per person and include a talk by Soul Searchers Paranormal Research; note that event spaces are reached by stairs and are not accessible. The inn also holds Burns Night every January and scotch tastings. Pet policy was not confirmed in sources read.
The ghosts of The Brae Loch Inn
The Girl in the Long Blue Dress
The Brae Loch Inn's signature ghost is a girl in a long blue dress. According to the Haunted History Trail of New York State, guests have reported her offering to escort them to their rooms. The trail's package listing presents her as the inn's chambermaid, telling her story in her own voice as a spirit who still checks on guests in all 12 rooms, wears a pressed blue dress and occasionally plays pranks, such as tugging a ponytail or tickling a bare foot. That first-person story is marketing copy rather than history, and no source names her or explains who she was in life. The trail lists Room 12, the Mary Queen of Scots room, and Room 13, the Robert The Bruce room, as the most active.
Scotty Brown in His Kilt
Adam 'Scotty' Brown was the stepfather of Grey Barr, one of the brothers who built the business. According to Wandercuse, which interviewed owner Val Barr, Scotty asked for his ashes to be kept in an urn on the cash register so he could keep an eye on the money, and his urn and that of his wife, Eve, were later moved into the inn's safe. Around Christmas one year, someone reported seeing a man in a white shirt, a brown, yellow and green kilt, mismatched socks and penny loafers in the common areas. When the description was passed on, it was said to match the outfit Scotty was cremated in, because the family had not wanted to burn his best clothes.
The Phantom Party in the Dining Room
In 2018, Wandercuse reports, several people saw well-dressed guests partying in the main dining room although staff said no party had been scheduled. Two couples saw the gathering through a doorway at the bottom of the curved staircase, which has been nailed shut since the 1950s, and a second couple saw the same scene at breakfast the following morning. Restaurant guests also report having their chairs bumped and their shoulders touched, and some have heard a child laughing or crying, or saying 'Mama' and 'I'm cold.' The Haunted History Trail adds sightings of a man and a woman walking through closets.
Lights in the Canopy
In the original part of the house, guests describe orbs and flashes of light. Co-owner Valerie Barr, who has owned the inn for more than 30 years, told WAER in October 2025 that light orbs have come out of the fireplace and closet and through the ceiling and canopy, and that one guest described a 'light show' in which the lights seemed to answer questions. Wandercuse tells of a couple who asked the lights to flash once for yes and twice for no and said they responded. Barr also told WAER of a guest who saw a man come out of a closet and stand over the bed.
The most haunted rooms and places to look
The Haunted History Trail names Room 12, the Mary Queen of Scots room, and Room 13, the Robert The Bruce room, as the inn's most active. More generally, guests staying in the original 1805 part of the house report orbs and flashes of light through the canopy beds and figures coming out of closets. Downstairs, the main dining room and the sealed doorway at the foot of the curved staircase are linked to the phantom party.
History of The Brae Loch Inn
The house was built in 1805 as the estate of William Burr in Cazenovia, a village on Cazenovia Lake in Madison County. The Barr family's restaurant began elsewhere: the first Brae Loch opened in 1946 in Borodino on Skaneateles Lake as a summer-only restaurant. A few years later the family moved the business to Cazenovia and took over the Burr house around 1950, a change of just one letter in the family name attached to the property.
Brothers Grey (Henry) Barr and Pete Barr ran the business with the support of their mother Eve and stepfather Scotty Brown, giving it a strong Scottish identity with tartan carpet, Scottish heirlooms and rooms named for figures such as Mary Queen of Scots and Robert The Bruce. Grey's son Jim Barr and his wife Val Barr took over in 1988, and the family expanded the main building over more than 75 years in business. Younger family members run nearby shops.
The inn has become one of Central New York's better-known haunted stays through the Haunted History Trail of New York State, which lists its Ghostly Getaway package and Dinner with the Spirits events, and through local media including a 2025 WAER report on its ghost stories.
Tips for a haunted stay
- Book the Ghostly Getaway by phone and ask for the 'Ghost Tour'; it is not advertised on the inn's own website.
- Request Room 12 or Room 13 for the rooms listed as most active.
- Look out for fall Dinner with the Spirits events, where a paranormal group shares the inn's ghost stories.
- Event spaces are up stairs, so check accessibility needs with the inn in advance.
Want to investigate, not just sleep?
Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.
- The Haunted Shanley Hotel Ghost Hunt: Napanoch, New York, about 112 miles away.
More haunted hotels nearby
- Hotel Utica (DoubleTree by Hilton Utica): Utica, New York, about 34 miles away
- The Otesaga Resort Hotel: Cooperstown, New York, about 50 miles away
- Erie Mansion: Clyde, New York, about 52 miles away
- Haunted hotels in New York
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Brae Loch Inn haunted?
Guests and the owners report a girl in a long blue dress, a kilted man believed to be family member Scotty Brown, a phantom dinner party and orbs of light in the guest rooms.
What are the most haunted rooms at the Brae Loch Inn?
The Haunted History Trail lists Room 12 (Mary Queen of Scots) and Room 13 (Robert The Bruce) as the most active.
Does the Brae Loch Inn offer ghost tours?
Yes. Its Ghostly Getaway package includes a private ghost tour of the inn, and guided tours have been offered after Dinner with the Spirits events.
How much is the Ghostly Getaway package?
It starts at $225 for two, including tax, with one night in a king canopy deluxe room, a private ghost tour, a dinner voucher and breakfast.
How old is the Brae Loch Inn?
The house was built in 1805 as the William Burr estate. The Barr family has run the Brae Loch there since around 1950.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
- Haunted History Trail: Ghostly Getaway at the Brae Loch Inn
- Haunted History Trail: The Brae Loch Inn
- Haunted History Trail: Dinner with the Spirits, The Brae Loch Inn
- WAER: Belief in ghosts declines nationwide, but the spirits still stir at the Brae Loch Inn (2025)
- Wandercuse: Meet the Spirits of the Brae Loch Inn in Cazenovia
- US Census Geocoder (coordinates)
Get new haunted hotel guides by email
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page may be affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

