Haunted hotel guide · Cape May, New Jersey

The Haunted Angel of the Sea B&B, Cape May, NJ: The Girl Who Fell

A storybook pink Victorian half a block from the beach, sawn in two, dragged across town twice and said to be home to a young woman who never made it back to her room.

By The Haunted Rooms Team · Updated November 2026 · How we rate hotels

2.5/5Haunted Rooms Score
c. 1850Year built
27Guest rooms

Check availabilityMeet the ghosts

With its twin towers, lacy gingerbread trim and two tiers of porches looking toward the Atlantic, Angel of the Sea is one of the most photographed buildings in Cape May. It is a 27-room bed and breakfast on Trenton Avenue at the quiet east end of town, half a block from the beach, where the rate includes a full breakfast, afternoon tea and evening wine and cheese, and the porches come with beach chairs, umbrellas and cruiser bikes.

Behind the pastel paint is one of the strangest building histories on the Jersey Shore, and a ghost story that dates from the house’s years as a college dormitory. Staff have described at least four presences over the years. Here is what is reported, what the history actually says, and what to expect from a stay.

Angel of the Sea at a glance

Haunted reputation3
History4
Ghost hunter access1
Recent activity2
Documentation2
$$ · $150 to $300
  • Address 5 Trenton Avenue, Cape May, NJ 08204. Phone (609) 884-3369
  • Built About 1850, as William Weightman Sr.’s summer cottage; a bed and breakfast since 1989
  • Most haunted spots The second and third floors of the second building, the stairs, Room 17
  • Best-known ghosts A young woman said to have fallen from a window in the 1960s, often called Miss Brown; a girl watching the sea
  • Booking the haunted room The inn does not identify a haunted room. Room 17 and the upper floors of the second house are the ones linked to the stories
  • Good to know 27 rooms with private baths, breakfast, afternoon tea, evening wine and cheese, free parking and beach gear

Check availability

The ghosts of Angel of the Sea

The student who fell

From 1962 until the early 1980s the two houses that make up Angel of the Sea were used as a dormitory for Shelton College and to house workers from nearby inns. The best-known story comes from those years. A young woman, so the story goes, came back late, found she had left her key in her room and decided to climb in through a window rather than go back downstairs. She lost her footing and fell to her death.

She is usually called Miss Brown; some retellings name her Sarah Brown and say she was an Irish exchange student, and her story has inspired a novel by Marlo Berliner. Nobody seems to know which room was hers, only that it was on the second or third floor of the second building. We could not find a contemporary record of the death, so this is best treated as the inn’s legend.

Shaking beds and moving furniture

The activity guests describe matches that part of the house: footsteps on the stairs and in empty halls, lights that flicker, beds that vibrate or shake as people are falling asleep, and furniture that seems to have shifted overnight. Some guests report odd lights in their rooms after dark.

The alarm clock in Room 17

One of the stories staff tell is wonderfully specific. A guest in Room 17 reported that the alarm clock went off at 2:30 in the morning, though nobody had set it, and it stopped only when someone came to check. Staff have treated it as the work of the inn’s prankster, a third presence said to play tricks on them.

The captain's daughter and the cough

Staff have described two more figures. One is a young woman, said to be the daughter of a caretaker and a sea captain, seen looking out toward the ocean. The other is heard rather than seen: a dry cough in empty rooms that some connect to a death from tuberculosis in the house’s earlier life. Neither has a name, and neither is documented, but both stories have been repeated by staff for years.

The most haunted rooms and places to look

  • Room 17: Where a guest’s alarm clock went off by itself at 2:30 a.m.
  • Upper floors of the second building: Where the student’s fall is placed; footsteps, flickering lights and moving objects.
  • The porches: Two levels of rockers facing the sea, where the captain’s daughter is said to keep watch.

History of Angel of the Sea Bed & Breakfast

Angel of the Sea began around 1850 as the summer cottage of William Weightman Sr., a Philadelphia chemist and managing partner of Powers and Weightman, the firm that introduced quinine to the United States. It first stood at Franklin and Washington Streets, where the Cape May post office is today.

In 1881 Weightman wanted an ocean view. Local farmers found the house too big to move in one piece, so they cut it in half and hauled the sections over the winter with mules and horses, rolling them on logs. They could pull the halves but could not push them back together, so the cut sides were simply closed in, and the house has been two buildings ever since. The family kept it until Weightman’s death in 1905, after which it was a hotel, a guest house and for a time a restaurant.

The great nor’easter of March 1962, remembered as the Ash Wednesday Storm, devastated Cape May’s seafront and badly damaged the houses, which were slated to be demolished for a parking lot. Reverend Carl McIntire bought them and moved them on flatbed trucks to Trenton Avenue, where they became a Shelton College dormitory and staff housing. Maintenance was minimal, and in 1981 they were declared uninhabitable and left empty.

In December 1988 builders John and Barbara Girton bought the property. Restoration began in January 1989, the first building opened that July and the work, which cost about $3.5 million and over 103,000 hours of labor, was finished in 1990. It won a preservation award from the National Trust. The Girtons sold the inn in 1995 to their daughter Lorie Whissell, who ran it for about 20 years, and in May 2015 Theresa and Ron Stanton bought it and run it with their sons.

Tips for a haunted stay

  • Ask for a room on the upper floors of the second building if you want to be close to the stories; the inn does not sell a haunted room.
  • Do not miss evening wine and cheese on the porch, the best view in the house.
  • Borrow a cruiser bike and ride to the lighthouse and Sunset Beach.
  • Cape May’s ghost trolley and walking tours run most weekends; book one for the night you arrive.
  • Stay a second night at the Hotel Macomber on Beach Avenue to try Room 10.

Want to investigate, not just sleep?

Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.

See all New Jersey ghost hunts

More haunted hotels nearby

Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened

We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.

Frequently asked questions

Is Angel of the Sea in Cape May haunted?

Staff and guests describe at least four presences, most famously a young woman said to have fallen from a window in the 1960s when the houses were a college dormitory. Reports include shaking beds, footsteps, flickering lights and coughing in empty rooms.

Who is Miss Brown at Angel of the Sea?

She is the name usually given to the student said to have died climbing into her locked room. Some retellings call her Sarah Brown, an Irish exchange student. No record of the death has been found, so treat it as legend.

Why is Angel of the Sea two buildings?

When the house was moved toward the ocean in 1881 it was cut in half. The movers could not push the halves back together, so they closed in the cut sides and left two houses.

How many rooms does Angel of the Sea have?

27 guest rooms, each with a private bath. Breakfast, afternoon tea and evening wine and cheese are included.

Who owns Angel of the Sea?

Theresa and Ron Stanton, who bought the inn in May 2015 and run it with their sons.

Sources

Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.

Get new haunted hotel guides by email

New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

About the authors

The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.

Booking links on this page are affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.