Haunted hotel guide · Montauk, New York

Montauk Manor: A Chief in the Hallways and Drumming from Fort Hill

Montauk Manor is the grand resort Carl Fisher opened on a hill above Montauk in 1927, now a condominium hotel next to Fort Hill Cemetery.

By The Haunted Rooms Team · Updated November 2026 · How we rate hotels

3.3/5Haunted Rooms Score
1927Year built
The thirdMost haunted spot

Visit the hotel websiteMeet the ghosts

Montauk Manor is the grand resort Carl Fisher opened on a hill above Montauk in 1927, now a condominium hotel next to Fort Hill Cemetery. Guests and employees have long told of an apparition of a Native American chief on the upper floors, a guest lifted off her bed on the fourth floor, and drumming drifting up from the cemetery. Reader accounts posted on the Montauk Library's blog in 2024 and 2025 suggest the stories are still being added to.

Montauk Manor at a glance

Haunted reputation3
History4
Ghost hunter access2
Recent activity4
Documentation4
$ to $$$ · from about $130 per night in 2022, varies by season and unit
  • Address 236 Edgemere Street, Montauk, NY 11954
  • Opened Opened in 1927 as a luxury resort hotel built by developer Carl Fisher; taken over by the Navy in World War II, closed in 1964 and converted in the mid-1980s into 140 condominium units, many of which are rented to overnight guests.
  • Most haunted spots The third and fourth floors, upper-floor rooms under the roof, the first-floor stairs and the neighboring Fort Hill Cemetery.
  • Best-known ghosts A Native American man in full headdress, sometimes said to be Chief Wyandanch, seen in the hallways, plus unexplained crying, banging doors and hazy white light.
  • Booking the haunted room There is no haunted room package, and the Manor does not promote its ghosts. The upper floors (third and fourth) feature in most of the stories, so ask for a high floor when you book a unit by phone (631-668-4400) or online.
  • Good to know The Manor is made up of 140 condominium apartments, from studios to three-bedroom units, each with a kitchen, and rentals are handled through the Manor's reservation system. Amenities include a wellness center and tennis courts. Rates vary by unit and season, with offers such as a fall four-nights-for-three deal. The pet policy is not published online. Fort Hill Cemetery, linked to many of the stories, is right next door.

Visit the hotel website

The ghosts of Montauk Manor

The Chief on the Upper Floors

The best-known story at Montauk Manor is of a Native American figure in the hallways. Author Kerriann Flanagan Brosky told 27east in 2016 that many people reported an apparition of an Indian chief, particularly on the third and fourth floors, and that surveillance cameras recorded nothing. The Montauk Library says guests and employees have described a man in full headdress, possibly Chief Wyandanch. In a 2001 East Hampton Star article quoted by the library, Wyandanch descendant Harriet Gumbs said disturbing a grave could hold up a spirit. Brosky reported that a group of Montaukett descendants held a ceremony to help the chief's spirit cross over, while noting that some spirits seem to like it better here.

Drums from Fort Hill

The Manor stands beside Fort Hill Cemetery, and Girl with the Passport reports that the area was used as a Native American burial ground and that the hotel's construction disturbed remains. Guests have described loud, rhythmic drumming and chanting, especially from the direction of the graveyard. Brosky said she heard the drumming herself and that it sounded nothing like music from the local clubs. The site has other layers of history too: according to 27east, Teddy Roosevelt's Rough Riders were quarantined with yellow fever in a makeshift hospital where the Manor's parking lot is today. No source ties a particular spirit to that episode.

Guests Still Reporting

The Montauk Library collected several accounts in an October 2025 post. A 2001 East Hampton Star story told of a woman on the fourth floor who said she was lifted about five feet off her bed, and a former employee said she moved to the first floor afterward. Another family described a bathroom door slamming on a guest's foot in an upper-floor room and furniture moved while they were out at dinner. Readers have added their own dated comments: one in September 2024 described a flickering light and moving mist in Room 326, another in June 2025 felt hands on his shoulders while napping in Room 110, and a condo owner in October 2025 saw a reflection at the base of the first-floor stairs with no one there.

The most haunted rooms and places to look

Reader accounts mention Room 326 (flickering light, moving mist), Room 110 (hands on the shoulders) and Room 415 (an unexplained photo). The fourth floor is linked to the guest lifted off her bed, and the third and fourth floor hallways to the chief.

History of Montauk Manor

Developer Carl Fisher opened Montauk Manor in 1927 as a four-story luxury resort hotel for wealthy New Yorkers. The resort struggled after the Great Depression, and during World War II the Navy took it over.

The Manor closed in 1964 and sat in disrepair for almost 20 years before it was listed on the National Register of Historic Places and converted in the mid-1980s into 140 luxury condominiums. Many of the units are rented to overnight guests through the Manor, which still describes itself as Carl Fisher's most splendid resort.

Tips for a haunted stay

  • Ask for a unit on the third or fourth floor, where most of the sightings are reported.
  • Walk over to Fort Hill Cemetery in daylight to see the setting of the drumming stories.
  • Read the Montauk Library's Restless Spirits post before you go for the full collection of guest accounts.

Want to investigate, not just sleep?

Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.

See all ghost hunts

More haunted hotels nearby

Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened

We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.

Frequently asked questions

Is Montauk Manor haunted?

It has a long local reputation. Guests and employees report a Native American chief in the hallways, drumming from Fort Hill Cemetery, and objects and furniture moving in rooms.

What are the most haunted rooms at Montauk Manor?

Recent guest comments mention Rooms 326, 110 and 415, and the third and fourth floors are where the chief is most often reported.

Does Montauk Manor offer ghost tours?

No. The Manor does not promote its ghost stories or run ghost tours.

Sources

Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.

Get new haunted hotel guides by email

New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

About the authors

The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.

Booking links on this page may be affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.