Haunted hotel guide · Hanoverton, Ohio

The Haunted Spread Eagle Tavern & Inn, Hanoverton: Olivina Nicholas and the Jefferson Room

The Spread Eagle Tavern has stood on Plymouth Street in Hanoverton since 1837, a Federal style canal-era tavern that now offers five guest rooms named for U.S.

By The Haunted Rooms Team · Updated November 2026 · How we rate hotels

3.2/5Haunted Rooms Score
1837Year built

Visit the hotel websiteMeet the ghosts

The Spread Eagle Tavern has stood on Plymouth Street in Hanoverton since 1837, a Federal style canal-era tavern that now offers five guest rooms named for U.S. presidents. The inn itself says it has a resident ghost, Olivina Nicholas, and that the Jefferson Room was her bedroom. Heritage Ohio adds the ghost of an 8-year-old girl and a freedom seeker said to be tied to the building's Underground Railroad past.

Spread Eagle Tavern & Inn at a glance

Haunted reputation3
History4
Ghost hunter access4
Recent activity2
Documentation3
$$ · $125 to $250Hotel embraces its ghosts
  • Address 10150 Plymouth Street, Hanoverton, OH 44423
  • Opened Built in 1837 as a tavern during the Sandy and Beaver Canal era; restored and reopened by the Johnson family in 1990.
  • Most haunted spots The Jefferson Room on the third floor, the upstairs hallways, and the tavern's public rooms.
  • Best-known ghosts Olivina Nicholas (spelled Olevia in some accounts), the daughter of a former owner; an 8-year-old girl said to have died in a fire on the property; and the spirit of a freedom seeker who escaped slavery.
  • Booking the haunted room The Jefferson Room, which the inn identifies as the ghost's former bedroom, is one of its five guest rooms and is listed at $200 with a full breakfast for two. Reservations are taken by phone at (330) 223-1583, so ask for the Jefferson Room by name.
  • Good to know All five rooms (Lincoln, Washington, Van Buren, Madison and Jefferson) have private baths and include a full breakfast for two, with listed rates from $125 to $250. Many rooms have fireplaces, but none can be lit during an overnight stay. The tavern serves dinner in period-decorated dining rooms and a basement rathskeller. The website suggests calling to confirm hours.

Visit the hotel website

The ghosts of Spread Eagle Tavern & Inn

Olivina Nicholas and the Jefferson Room

The Spread Eagle's best-known ghost is Olivina Nicholas, whose name appears as Olevia in some accounts. The inn's own guest room page says the Jefferson Room, once the meeting place of a Masonic lodge, was the former bedroom of its resident ghost. Local lore, as told to WFMJ, holds that Olivina, whose sister Grace kept a diary, took her own life and still walks the halls. Heritage Ohio says she was a former owner's daughter, that she has been seen walking the hallways, and that she pulls the covers off guests sleeping in her old bedroom. Owner Dave Johnson says he has never seen her, but that some guests have wanted to leave in the middle of the night.

A Little Girl and a Freedom Seeker

Olivina is not the only spirit said to remain at the tavern. Heritage Ohio describes the ghost of an 8-year-old girl who is said to have died in a fire on the property, and the spirit of a freedom seeker who escaped slavery. The second story is linked to the tavern's reputation as a stop on the Underground Railroad, which is often illustrated with a tunnel in the basement. Neither ghost is named, and no record of either death is given, so both are best treated as stories told about the building. Heritage Ohio says these two spirits are usually seen in the tavern's public areas rather than in the guest rooms.

The most haunted rooms and places to look

The Jefferson Room, which the inn describes as the former bedroom of its resident ghost, Olivina.

History of Spread Eagle Tavern & Inn

The Spread Eagle Tavern was built in 1837, when Hanoverton sat midway along the Sandy and Beaver Canal. Heritage Ohio calls it one of the area's finest examples of Federal Period architecture. The building is tied by local tradition to the Underground Railroad, and a long-told story says Abraham Lincoln visited in 1864, though, as the current owner told WFMJ, no one can prove it either way.

The Johnson family bought the tavern in 1988 and spent about two years on a full renovation, reopening it in 1990 with the basement rathskeller restored to its original look. Today Dave Johnson runs the tavern and inn, which offers five period guest rooms named after presidents, including the Lincoln Room in what was once the tavern's ballroom.

Tips for a haunted stay

  • Call (330) 223-1583 to book and ask for the Jefferson Room by name.
  • Plan dinner in the tavern, since the dining rooms and rathskeller are part of the experience.
  • Do not expect a fire in your room: the fireplaces cannot be lit during overnight stays.

Want to investigate, not just sleep?

Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.

See all ghost hunts

More haunted hotels nearby

Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened

We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.

Frequently asked questions

Who haunts the Spread Eagle Tavern?

The best-known ghost is Olivina Nicholas, a former owner's daughter said to walk the halls and pull covers off guests. Heritage Ohio also mentions an 8-year-old girl and a freedom seeker.

Which room is haunted at the Spread Eagle Tavern & Inn?

The inn says the Jefferson Room on the third floor was the bedroom of its resident ghost.

How do you book a room at the Spread Eagle Tavern?

Reservations are made by phone at (330) 223-1583. Rates listed on the website run from $125 to $250 and include a full breakfast for two.

Sources

Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.

Get new haunted hotel guides by email

New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

About the authors

The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.

Booking links on this page may be affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.