Ten Ohio hotels and inns where guests and staff report something they cannot explain, from a 1931 Art Deco landmark in Cincinnati to stagecoach inns that have taken travelers since the 1800s.
Ohio’s haunted hotels follow the state’s old roads and rivers: stagecoach inns in Granville, Lebanon and Millersburg, riverboat-era hotels where the Muskingum meets the Ohio in Marietta, a Tudor manor on a Geauga County lake and the Art Deco Netherland Plaza in downtown Cincinnati. Every hotel on this list takes overnight guests today. We checked each one’s current name and status, corrected stories older guides got wrong and explain below which places we have taken off the list. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. For abandoned asylums, jails and other spooky sites, see our guide to haunted places in Ohio.
$ · Under $150Haunted room bookableGhost tours or eventsHotel embraces its ghosts
Address 313 East Broadway, Granville, OH 43023
Where to look Room 9, Room 7, the basement tavern and the back service stairs
Reported ghosts Ethel "Bonnie" Bounell as the Lady in Blue, Major Horton Buxton, founder Orrin Granger and a ghostly cat
Booking the haunted room Book through the inn's own website or phone (740) 587-0001 and ask for Room 9 or Room 7 by number.
Orrin Granger opened The Tavern in 1812, and it served as Granville’s first post office and a stagecoach stop on the road between Columbus and Newark. It became the Dilley House in the 1850s and took its current name from Major Horton Buxton, who bought it in 1865. It is on the National Register of Historic Places and is one of the oldest inns in Ohio still taking guests.
Its ghosts are its former keepers. Bonnie Bounell, the opera singer who ran the inn from 1934 until her death in 1960, is the Lady in Blue, often linked to Room 9 and the scent of gardenias. Guests also tell of Major Buxton and his cigar smoke, a little boy in the tavern below the inn and a cat that settles on the bed at night. The inn changed hands in 2026 and is being refreshed.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for Room 9, Bonnie’s old suite, and check what dining is running before you go, as the restaurant is still returning after renovations.
$$ · $150 to $300Haunted room bookableHotel embraces its ghosts
Address 27 South Broadway, Lebanon, OH 45036
Where to look Sarah's Room on the fourth floor, the Vallandigham room, the main staircase
Reported ghosts A little girl often named as Sarah Stubbs, Justice Charles R. Sherman and Clement Vallandigham
Booking the haunted room Rooms are named, so request the Vallandigham room or a fourth-floor room when you book directly with the inn.
Jonas Seaman opened a log tavern here in 1803, and the brick inn grew from Ichabod Corwin’s 1815 rebuild. The Golden Lamb calls itself Ohio’s oldest continuously operating business, and its 17 guest rooms are named for famous visitors, who include Charles Dickens, Harriet Beecher Stowe and a long list of presidents. It is owned by the Portman family and listed on the National Register.
The inn shares its own ghost stories. The best known is a little girl, often said to be Sarah Stubbs, who grew up here, though some say she is Eliza Clay, Henry Clay’s daughter, who died at the inn in 1825. Guests have heard a child laughing in empty halls. Others link a gaunt man and cigar smoke to Justice Charles R. Sherman, who died here in 1829, and the room named for Clement Vallandigham, who died after accidentally shooting himself in 1871.
Haunted Rooms tip: Look into the replica of Sarah’s room on the fourth floor, and book the Vallandigham room if you want the room with the darkest story.
Where to look Macbeth Cottage (Cottage 13), Heyd Cemetery, the Heyd cabin replica, the pool house near the old church site, the tunnel under the castle
Reported ghosts The little girl in blue (possibly Samantha), a woman in white, a gray-haired woman on the Cottage 13 deck, early pioneers of the Heyd settlement
Booking the haunted room Book Cottage 13 directly. The castle lists the same 1890s stone cottage as the Macbeth Cottage for romantic stays and as Haunted Cottage 13 for guests interested in the unexplained. Private investigations can add Macbeth Cottage for an extra fee via ghosthunts@landollsmohicancastle.com.
Landoll's Mohican Castle looks like a European fortress, but its ghost stories come from much older ground: a pioneer cemetery around 230 years old and the site of a church that burned in the 1800s. Guests and staff report a little girl in a blue dress in the graveyard, a woman in white, and voices and knocking in the stone Macbeth Cottage, known to ghost hunters as Cottage 13. The castle was investigated on A&E's Ghost Hunters in 2019 and runs its own ghost walks and overnight investigations.
The castle's best-known ghost is a little girl in a blue dress, most often reported around Heyd Cemetery, the pioneer graveyard at the top of the property. Visitors have described seeing her playing in the graveyard in winter, and guests, often young women, teenage girls and children, report hearing a girl laughing or talking near the pool area, close to the site of the old church. When the Ghost Hunters team investigated in 2019, they identified a girl named Samantha Carnagey among the cemetery's graves as a possible match, and team members said they captured an EVP of a young girl's voice in the cemetery and another at the Heyd cabin.
Haunted Rooms tip: Book Cottage 13 well ahead if you want the castle's most haunted room; it is also sold as a romantic cottage.
Where to look The tower suites, the Windsor Suite and the dining room
Reported ghosts A man said to have been seen hanging in the dining room, plus many unnamed figures
Booking the haunted room Book a tower suite directly with the lodge.
Punderson Manor is an English Tudor mansion begun in the late 1920s as a private home on Punderson Lake in Geauga County. The State of Ohio bought the land in 1948, finished the house and opened it to guests in 1956. Today it offers manor rooms and cabins, with hiking, golf and the lake on the doorstep.
It has a long ghost reputation. Guests have reported at least a dozen different figures over the years. The best-known story is of a man in work clothes seen hanging from the dining room ceiling, and visitors also report laughter, doors and faucets that work by themselves and figures in the tower suites. Others link the haunting to Lemuel Punderson, the early settler the lake is named for.
Haunted Rooms tip: Request one of the tower suites when you book, and walk the lake boardwalk at dusk.
Address 35 West Fifth Street, Cincinnati, OH 45202
Where to look The Hall of Mirrors, the eastern mezzanine, the elevators and the guest corridors
Reported ghosts The Lady in Green, a woman in a green gown who staff say asks for help and then vanishes
The Netherland Plaza opened in January 1931 inside the Carew Tower, John J. Emery’s Art Deco city within a city. It is a National Historic Landmark, famous for its Brazilian rosewood, Egyptian and French Art Deco details, the Rookwood Pottery fountain in the Palm Court and a third-floor ballroom modelled on the Hall of Mirrors at Versailles.
Its ghost is the Lady in Green. Staff told Cincinnati CityBeat about a server who chatted with her in an elevator before she disappeared, an airline pilot who saw her and ran to the front desk, and a guest who was tapped on the shoulder by a woman in a green dress asking for help. Staff tie her to a worker killed during construction, though the hotel’s historian found no record to back the story.
Haunted Rooms tip: Walk up to the Hall of Mirrors and the mezzanine late in the evening when no event is on, and ride the historic elevators.
Where to look The third floor wing named for Durward Hoag, the second floor and the Gun Room restaurant
Reported ghosts Former owner S. Durward Hoag and a maid in a black dress
The Lafayette stands where the Muskingum meets the Ohio River, on the site of the Bellevue Hotel, which was lost in 1916. The new hotel opened in 1918, and the Hoag family ran it for about half a century, adding a wing of rooms during the Depression. It is a member of Historic Hotels of America and still decorated with riverboat-era pieces.
Durward Hoag, who ran the hotel until 1973, is the ghost most guests mention. Stories blame him for bulbs that flicker or burst, elevators opening by themselves and things moved around the rooms, and his old third-floor wing is the place to ask for. The Marietta Times also lists footsteps and voices in empty rooms, misty shapes and a maid in a black dress. The hotel hosts a paranormal convention each year.
Haunted Rooms tip: Ask for a room on the third floor in the wing named for Durward Hoag, and have dinner in the Gun Room.
Where to look The Jefferson Room on the third floor, the upstairs hallways, and the tavern's public rooms.
Reported ghosts Olivina Nicholas (spelled Olevia in some accounts), the daughter of a former owner; an 8-year-old girl said to have died in a fire on the property; and the spirit of a freedom seeker who escaped slavery.
Booking the haunted room The Jefferson Room, which the inn identifies as the ghost's former bedroom, is one of its five guest rooms and is listed at $200 with a full breakfast for two. Reservations are taken by phone at (330) 223-1583, so ask for the Jefferson Room by name.
The Spread Eagle Tavern has stood on Plymouth Street in Hanoverton since 1837, a Federal style canal-era tavern that now offers five guest rooms named for U.S. presidents. The inn itself says it has a resident ghost, Olivina Nicholas, and that the Jefferson Room was her bedroom. Heritage Ohio adds the ghost of an 8-year-old girl and a freedom seeker said to be tied to the building's Underground Railroad past.
The Spread Eagle's best-known ghost is Olivina Nicholas, whose name appears as Olevia in some accounts. The inn's own guest room page says the Jefferson Room, once the meeting place of a Masonic lodge, was the former bedroom of its resident ghost. Local lore, as told to WFMJ, holds that Olivina, whose sister Grace kept a diary, took her own life and still walks the halls.
Haunted Rooms tip: Call (330) 223-1583 to book and ask for the Jefferson Room by name.
Where to look The fourth floor, which staff describe as haunted, and the eleventh floor, where several guest accounts are set.
Reported ghosts No named ghost. The stories describe unexplained activity rather than a specific figure: lights, running water, flushing toilets and a disembodied voice.
Booking the haunted room There is no haunted room package. The hotel is part of Marriott's Autograph Collection, so book through Marriott and ask the front desk about a room on the fourth floor.
The Hotel Cleveland has stood on Public Square since 1918, and for nearly three decades it was better known as the Renaissance Cleveland Hotel. Ohio's official tourism site says staff consider its fourth floor haunted, with flickering lights, faucets that run on their own and toilets that flush by themselves. Guests have also posted accounts of voices in the halls and strange dreams in their rooms.
The hotel's ghost reputation rests mainly on its own staff. In its roundup of haunted getaways, Ohio's official tourism site says the building offers views of downtown Cleveland as well as a haunted fourth floor, according to the staff. The activity they describe is domestic rather than dramatic: lights that flicker, faucets that turn on and off by themselves, and toilets that flush when no one is in the room.
Haunted Rooms tip: Search for "Hotel Cleveland" rather than "Renaissance Cleveland" when booking, since the hotel changed names in 2024.
Address 35 West Jackson Street, Millersburg, OH 44654
Where to look The lobby, the upper hallways and empty guest rooms
Reported ghosts A well-dressed elderly gentleman in a 1920s suit and hat
Hotel Millersburg began as a tavern and stagecoach stop in the 1820s and became the Central Hotel in 1847, making it one of the oldest hotels still operating in Ohio. The brick building stands in the middle of Holmes County’s Amish Country, with a tavern and restaurant on the ground floor and guest rooms upstairs.
Guests and staff describe an elderly man in a 1920s suit and hat who walks the hotel and disappears. Other reports include footsteps in empty halls, knocks on doors with nobody there, lights flashing in unoccupied rooms and belongings moved around. It is a quieter haunting than most on this list, and a good base for exploring the county.
Haunted Rooms tip: Pair a night here with a visit to Holmes County’s Amish villages, and ask the staff about the gentleman in the suit.
Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.
Where to look The Galley restaurant below the hotel and the upstairs guest rooms
Reported ghosts A spirit the staff call Charlotte
Oilman John H. Riley put up this brick block at Second Street and Tiber Way in 1899. It was renovated in the 1980s and the Hackett opened as a small boutique hotel in 2012, with five upstairs rooms named for figures from Marietta’s past. It sits above The Galley restaurant and the Adelphia Music Hall, so expect live music on weekend nights.
The Galley’s staff are the main witnesses here. They describe bottles crashing, glasses flying off shelves and chairs scraping across empty rooms, and the incidents are frequent enough that many believe one ghost is responsible, a woman they call Charlotte. Overnight guests upstairs have reported figures too. The Lafayette is a short walk away, so you can do both in a weekend.
Haunted Rooms tip: Book a room for a weekday if you want quiet, and have a late drink in The Galley, where most of the stories come from.
Joseph Rider’s old stagecoach inn, long known as Rider’s 1812 Inn and famous for Suzanne Rider and Room 11, reopened in 2026 as Joseph’s 1818 Public House and Tavern. We could not confirm overnight rooms, so stop by for dinner and stay at Punderson Manor Lodge, about 30 minutes south.
Removed from this guide: The Lofts Hotel in Columbus. The 1882 warehouse hotel was sold in 2017 and we could not confirm it still operates under that name, and its only story, a Victorian lady on the lobby stairs, has no source we could find. Rider’s Inn in Painesville is listed above under places no longer taking guests.
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
The Hilton Cincinnati Netherland Plaza and the Buxton Inn in Granville have the strongest traditions. Netherland Plaza staff describe the Lady in Green in the elevators and the Hall of Mirrors, while Buxton Inn innkeepers have described the Lady in Blue, gardenia perfume and a ghostly cat.
Which Ohio hotel has a haunted room you can book?
Room 9 at the Buxton Inn, the former apartment of innkeeper Bonnie Bounell, is the best known. At the Golden Lamb you can request the Vallandigham room or a fourth-floor room near Sarah’s room, and the Lafayette’s third-floor wing is named for its ghost, Durward Hoag.
Is the Golden Lamb in Lebanon haunted?
The inn tells its own ghost stories. The best known is a little girl, often said to be Sarah Stubbs, who grew up there. Others are linked to Justice Charles R. Sherman, who died at the inn in 1829, and Clement Vallandigham, who died there in 1871.
Can you go on a ghost hunt in Ohio?
Yes. Haunted Rooms runs public ghost hunts at Mortuary Manor in Toledo, a former funeral home. See all Ohio ghost hunts for current dates.
Are there haunted hotels near Cincinnati?
The Hilton Netherland Plaza is downtown, and the Golden Lamb in Lebanon is about 35 miles north.
Is Rider's Inn in Painesville still a haunted B&B?
Rider’s Inn reopened in 2026 as a pub and tavern, Joseph’s 1818 Public House and Tavern. We could not confirm that guest rooms are offered, so it is no longer on our list of places to stay.
Sources and how we research
Every hotel in this guide is checked against the hotel’s own website, historic register listings and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as the hotels, guests and local historians tell them; we note where a story can’t be confirmed. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page are affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never affects which hotels we include or how we score them.