Haunted hotel guide · Santa Fe, New Mexico
The Haunted La Fonda Hotel, Santa Fe: Judge Slough, the Well Under La Plazuela and the Bride of Room 510
There has been an inn on this corner of the Santa Fe Plaza for centuries, and one of its ghost stories begins with a documented killing: the chief justice of New Mexico Territory, shot dead in the lobby in 1867.
La Fonda on the Plaza is the adobe landmark at the southeast corner of the Santa Fe Plaza, where the Santa Fe Trail ended. The hotel says city records place the town’s first inn on this site, which is why it calls itself the oldest hotel corner in America. The current Pueblo Revival building opened in 1922, spent decades as a Fred Harvey hotel, and today has 180 rooms and suites, the La Plazuela restaurant and the Bell Tower Bar on its roof. It is one of the best-known haunted hotels in New Mexico.
The hotel does not sell its ghosts, and its own history pages stick to art, architecture and the trail. Its stories come from guests and staff and have been retold by the National Trust for Historic Preservation and others: a judge pacing the halls, a ruined gambler at the old well, a murdered bride and a cowboy in the bar. Here is what is told, what the records say and how to plan a stay.
La Fonda at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 100 E San Francisco St, Santa Fe, NM 87501, on the corner of the Santa Fe Plaza
- Opened 1922 (current building); the site has hosted inns since the town’s early years, including the Exchange Hotel in the 1800s
- Most haunted spots La Plazuela restaurant over the old well, Room 510, the third-floor halls near La Terraza, the Santa Fe Room, the bar
- Best-known ghosts Chief Justice John P. Slough, a salesman who lost everything at cards, a bride murdered on her wedding night, a cowboy
- Booking the haunted room There is no haunted room package. Ask for Room 510, the wedding suite, when you book; it is a request, not a guarantee.
- Good to know 180 rooms and suites with hand-painted furniture and original art, a spa, La Plazuela, the Bell Tower Rooftop Bar and art and history docent tours.
The ghosts of La Fonda
Judge John P. Slough
This is the story with the firmest footing in history. In December 1867, John P. Slough, chief justice of the New Mexico Territorial Supreme Court, argued with William Rynerson, a member of the Territorial Legislature from Doña Ana County, in the lobby of the Exchange Hotel that stood on this corner. Slough called Rynerson a liar and a thief; Rynerson shot him, and Slough died of his wounds. Rynerson was tried and acquitted.
Guests have long reported heavy footsteps pacing the halls late at night. In one well-known account from the 1970s, a guest rang the front desk to complain about someone walking up and down outside his room. The employee sent up saw a tall man in a long black coat, who disappeared into a stairwell. When he followed, there was no one there.
The salesman at the well
The Exchange Hotel had a busy gambling hall. Legend says a traveling salesman lost his company’s money at cards, ran out into the courtyard and threw himself down a deep well. That courtyard is now La Plazuela, the hotel’s restaurant, and the well lies beneath its floor.
Diners and staff describe a figure who walks to the center of the room and seems to drop through the floor where the well once was. There is no record that names the man, so this is a legend, but it is the one staff are most often asked about.
The bride of Room 510
According to the National Trust, a young bride was murdered on her wedding night by a former lover. She is said to appear in Room 510, the wedding suite, and also in the lobby, an elevator and the basement.
Her story is newer and harder to trace than Judge Slough’s, but Room 510 is the room ghost hunters ask for by number.
A cowboy, a lynching and the third floor
Visitors also hear about a cowboy who haunts the bar, an apparition in the Santa Fe Room and a spirit walking the third-floor hallways near La Terraza. Housekeepers have their own stories; one told of seeing the outline of a person under the covers in an empty room, only to find the bed empty when she pulled back the sheets.
Older accounts add that a man was hanged by a lynch mob behind the hotel in 1857, and local belief says the corner was once used for court hearings and public hangings. We could not find records for these, so treat them as part of Santa Fe’s folklore.
The most haunted rooms and places to look
- Room 510: The wedding suite and the room linked to the murdered bride. Request it by number when you book.
- La Plazuela: The skylit restaurant in the hotel’s original 1920s courtyard, built over the old well. Book dinner and watch the middle of the room.
- The third floor near La Terraza: Hallways where a spirit has been reported walking, close to the La Terraza event room.
- The lobby: Where Judge Slough was shot in 1867, in the old Exchange Hotel that stood on this site.
History of La Fonda on the Plaza
Santa Fe was founded around 1607 to 1610, and La Fonda says city records indicate the town’s first inn stood on this corner. In 1821 William Becknell’s party reached the inn on the first trading trip from Missouri, opening the Santa Fe Trail, and for the rest of the century a hotel here, later called the Exchange Hotel or simply the fonda, served trappers, soldiers, gold seekers, gamblers and politicians. The killing of Judge Slough in 1867 happened in that building.
An earlier hotel on the site, the United States Hotel, burned in 1912, and the current La Fonda, designed by Isaac Hamilton Rapp in the Pueblo Revival style, opened on December 30, 1922. In 1925 the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railway bought it and leased it to Fred Harvey, making it one of the famous Harvey Houses. The hotel credits Mary Colter and John Gaw Meem with shaping its design.
Harvey operations ended in 1968, when local businessman Sam Ballen and his wife Ethel bought the hotel. The Ballen family ran it for 46 years before passing ownership in 2014 to a partnership of local families. La Fonda has been a member of Historic Hotels of America since 1991.
Our older version of this page said La Fonda had 14 rooms; it has 180. We have also dropped old room rates and amenity lists that are no longer accurate.
Tips for a haunted stay
- Ask for Room 510 when you book, and repeat the request at check-in.
- Have dinner in La Plazuela, then a drink in the Bell Tower Bar (check its seasonal hours).
- Join one of the hotel’s art and history docent tours to see the building’s art and hand-painted furniture.
- Santa Fe ghost walking tours pass La Fonda; book one for the evening of your stay.
- The Plaza is busiest in summer and at Indian Market in August; winter rates are often lower.
More haunted hotels nearby
- La Posada de Santa Fe: a few blocks east, haunted by Julia Staab
- Drury Plaza Hotel, Santa Fe: the old St. Vincent Hospital, a short walk away
- Plaza Hotel, Las Vegas: an 1882 hotel about an hour east, with a haunted Room 310
- Hotel Parq Central, Albuquerque: a railroad hospital turned hotel, an hour south
- Haunted hotels in New Mexico
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is La Fonda in Santa Fe haunted?
It is one of the most storied hotels in the city. Guests and staff report a man in a long black coat thought to be Judge John P. Slough, a figure vanishing into the floor of La Plazuela, and a bride in Room 510. The hotel does not promote the stories.
Who haunts La Fonda?
The best-known ghosts are Chief Justice John P. Slough, shot in the lobby of the old Exchange Hotel in 1867; a salesman said to have jumped into the well now under La Plazuela; a bride murdered on her wedding night; and a cowboy in the bar.
Which room is haunted at La Fonda?
Room 510, the wedding suite, is linked to the murdered bride. Reports also come from the third-floor halls, the lobby and La Plazuela.
Was Judge Slough really killed at La Fonda?
Yes, on this site. He was shot by legislator William Rynerson in December 1867 in the lobby of the Exchange Hotel, which stood where La Fonda is now. Rynerson was later acquitted.
How old is La Fonda on the Plaza?
The current building opened in 1922, but La Fonda says an inn has stood on the corner since Santa Fe’s founding in the early 1600s.
How many rooms does La Fonda have?
La Fonda has 180 rooms and suites.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
- La Fonda on the Plaza: History
- National Trust for Historic Preservation: Ghostly encounters at La Fonda on the Plaza
- Legends of America: Haunted La Fonda Hotel
- Wikipedia: La Fonda on the Plaza
Get new haunted hotel guides by email
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page are affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

