Haunted hotel guide · Cape May, New Jersey
The Haunted Inn of Cape May: Phantom Children and the Empty Fifth-Floor Room
The Inn of Cape May has stood on the oceanfront at the foot of Ocean Street since it opened as the Colonial Hotel in 1895.
The Inn of Cape May has stood on the oceanfront at the foot of Ocean Street since it opened as the Colonial Hotel in 1895. Guests report children laughing and running in the hallways when no children are staying, and Cape May psychic Craig McManus has described lights and voices in rooms that turned out to be empty. The inn shares these stories on its own Haunted History page.
The Inn of Cape May at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 7 Ocean Street, Cape May, NJ 08204
- Opened Built in 1894 to 1895 by the Church brothers as the Colonial Hotel, expanded by 1905, and now operating as The Inn of Cape May after a renovation completed in 2022.
- Most haunted spots The guest hallways, the fifth floor and the guest rooms.
- Best-known ghosts Unseen children heard laughing and running in the halls; voices recorded in an empty room; an unseen presence that reached across a guest's bed.
- Booking the haunted room No haunted room package. The inn does not name a specific haunted room, so if you want to be close to the reported activity, ask for a room on the upper floors when booking by phone at (609) 884-5555 or online.
- Good to know The inn has 51 guest rooms that vary in shape, size and view, including City King and Ocean King rooms and a two-bedroom suite. Dining is at Ocean 7, a contemporary American restaurant, and The Porch, a coffee and cocktail bar, with a daily happy hour. A third-party booking listing says pets are not allowed, though service animals are welcome, and that a 7% resort fee covers beach towels, an in-room safe and pool access. The front desk is open 8 a.m. to 10 p.m. The building has what Cape May Magazine calls the town's first elevator, still in use, and a pool on the south lawn.
The ghosts of The Inn of Cape May
Children in the Hallways
The most frequently repeated story at the Inn of Cape May involves children who are not there. According to accounts collected by Cape May psychic and author Craig McManus and retold on the inn's own Haunted History page, guests have reported hearing children's laughter, running footsteps and voices in the hallways at times when no children were staying nearby. No source identifies who these children might have been, and there are no documented deaths of children at the hotel in the sources reviewed, so the reports stand as unexplained experiences rather than a story tied to a known event.
The Light Under the Fifth-Floor Door
McManus has his own experience at the inn. As the inn's Haunted History page tells it, he saw light shining beneath a door on the fifth floor and assumed the room was occupied, only to learn that no one was staying in it. On another occasion, according to the same page, he captured what he heard as several people speaking on his recording equipment in a room he had found empty. McManus also hosts channeling dinners at the inn through Cape May MAC, the local arts and culture organization that runs ghost tours in town.
The Arm Across the Bed
The most unsettling account on the inn's page comes from a visiting photographer. He reportedly felt an arm reach across his bedcovers during the night, and he was so shaken that he spent the rest of the night in the lobby. The inn does not give a room number or a date for this experience, and it has not been independently reported elsewhere in the sources reviewed, so treat it as a single guest's account. It remains one of the most vivid experiences linked to the hotel.
The most haunted rooms and places to look
The inn does not single out one haunted room. The accounts it shares point to the guest hallways, where children's laughter and footsteps are reported, and to the fifth floor, where Craig McManus saw light under the door of an unoccupied room. The photographer who felt an arm across his bed did not give a room number. Guests hoping for activity can ask for an upper-floor room.
History of The Inn of Cape May
The Church brothers, William H. and C.S. Church, began building the hotel at the foot of Ocean Street in the fall of 1894, and it opened to guests in 1895 as the Colonial Hotel. It started as a modest cottage-style boarding house with a central hall and rooms on either side, and a porch running along its southern side facing the beach.
By 1905 a wing projecting south had roughly doubled the building's size, and a 1909 Sanborn map shows it at about its present volume, with the mansard roof, towers and sweeping porch that define it today. Cape May Magazine says the hotel installed Cape May's first elevator, which still operates.
The building is listed on the New Jersey and National Registers of Historic Places as a contributing building in the Cape May City Historic District, and the state historic preservation office has identified it as one of the last remaining resort hotels of its kind. A renovation completed in 2022 updated the rooms while keeping their Victorian character.
Tips for a haunted stay
- Read the inn's Haunted History page before you go so you know which experiences guests have reported.
- Look out for Craig McManus channeling dinners at the inn through Cape May MAC; schedules vary, so check current listings.
- Join a Cape May MAC ghost tour to explore the wider town, which has many reportedly haunted inns.
- Ask for an upper-floor room if you want to be near the fifth floor, where McManus saw light under an empty room's door.
- Bring an audio recorder: voices recorded in an empty room are among the reported experiences.
Want to investigate, not just sleep?
Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.
- Belle Grove Plantation Bed & Breakfast Ghost Hunt: King George, Virginia, about 133 miles away.
- The Gettysburg Academy Bed & Breakfast Ghost Hunt: Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, about 138 miles away.
More haunted hotels nearby
- Hotel Macomber: Cape May, New Jersey, in the same town
- The Southern Mansion: Cape May, New Jersey, in the same town
- Congress Hall: Cape May, New Jersey, in the same town
- Haunted hotels in New Jersey
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Inn of Cape May haunted?
Guests report hearing children laughing and running in the halls when no children are staying, and psychic Craig McManus has described lights and voices in empty rooms. The inn shares these reports on its Haunted History page.
Is there a haunted room at the Inn of Cape May?
No single room is named. The reports center on the hallways and the fifth floor.
Does the Inn of Cape May offer ghost events?
Cape May MAC runs ghost tours in town and has held channeling dinners with Craig McManus at the inn. Check current listings, as schedules vary.
When was the Inn of Cape May built?
Construction began in 1894 and it opened in 1895 as the Colonial Hotel. A south wing was added by 1905.
Does the Inn of Cape May allow pets?
A third-party booking listing says pets are not allowed, but service animals are welcome. Confirm with the inn when booking.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
- The Inn of Cape May: Haunted History (official)
- The Inn of Cape May official site
- Cape May Magazine: The Inn of Cape May (architectural observations)
- Matador Network: Haunted Cape May
- HotelPlanner: The Inn of Cape May (policies)
- Kayak: The Inn of Cape May
- Cvent: Inn of Cape May
- Booking.com: The Inn of Cape May
Get new haunted hotel guides by email
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page may be affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

