Haunted places guide · Fort Smith, Arkansas
The Haunted Clayton House, Fort Smith: History, Ghosts and Tours
A Civil War hospital, the home of the prosecutor who sent men to Judge Parker’s gallows, and a boarding house that nearly fell to the wrecking ball. The people who work at the Clayton House say not everyone left.
Our nearest ghost hunt: Hotel Metropolitan, KYMeet the ghosts
The Clayton House stands on North 6th Street in the Belle Grove Historic District, a few blocks from the river and the old federal courthouse where Judge Isaac C. Parker held court. It is one of the best-loved old houses in Fort Smith: two and a half stories of pale Victorian woodwork, coal-burning fireplaces in every main room and a carved black walnut staircase. It is also, according to the people who have worked in it, one of the city’s most haunted buildings.
This guide sets out what is known about the house and its family, the ghost stories staff and visitors tell, and how to visit. The house is a museum and event venue run by the Fort Smith Heritage Foundation, open for guided tours several afternoons a week. It does not run ghost tours of its own, so treat the stories below as accounts from staff, volunteers and local investigators rather than anything the museum promotes.
Clayton House at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 514 North 6th Street, Fort Smith, AR 72901
- Built 1852 as the Sutton home; doubled in size about 1882
- Famous resident W. H. H. Clayton, U.S. Attorney in Judge Parker’s court
- Museum since 1977, after a seven-year restoration
- Most active spots Mr. Clayton’s study, a second-floor bedroom, the upstairs landing
- Reported activity Footsteps, slamming doors, music, a woman in a brown skirt, an angry man in black
- Ghost hunting No public ghost hunts; guided history tours only
Our nearest ghost hunt: Hotel Metropolitan, KY Visit / tours
History of the Clayton House
The oldest part of the house was built in 1852 by a landowner named Sutton. Fort Smith was then a frontier town on the edge of Indian Territory, and when the Civil War came the Suttons left for Texas. The house was used as a hospital during the war; sources differ on which army ran it, which is not surprising in a town held first by the Confederacy and, from September 1863, by the Union.
About 1882 the house was bought by William Henry Harrison Clayton, a Pennsylvania-born Union veteran whose brother Powell Clayton had been governor of Arkansas. President Grant had appointed W. H. H. Clayton U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Arkansas in 1874, and he served as the chief prosecutor in Judge Parker’s court for most of the next two decades. By one count he won around 80 murder convictions, about half of which ended on the gallows a few blocks away. He prosecuted Belle Starr, and he later defended the deputy marshal Bass Reeves, who was acquitted.
Clayton doubled the house in size and gave it its Victorian look. He and his wife Florence raised six daughters and a son here. The family’s grief was public as well as private: in January 1889 his twin brother John was assassinated while contesting a congressional election, and despite Pinkerton detectives paid for by the family, the killer was never found. In 1897 Clayton left Fort Smith to become a federal judge in Indian Territory, based in McAlester. He died in 1920 and is buried in Fort Smith National Cemetery.
After the Claytons left, the house was leased to a social club, then spent roughly six decades as a boarding house; Emma High bought it in 1924 and ran it into the 1960s. It decayed, suffered fire damage, and in 1969 the city scheduled it for demolition. A local woman, Julia Yadon, stopped it and founded the Fort Smith Heritage Foundation. The house was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1970, taken apart and rebuilt over seven years, and opened as a museum in 1977. The kitchen and servants’ quarters were reconstructed in 1982.
The ghosts of the Clayton House
The woman in Mr. Clayton's study
The best-known account comes from Martha Siler, a former director of the house, who told 5NEWS that she saw the apparition of a woman in Mr. Clayton’s study one day. Older versions of the story describe her in a linen blouse and brown skirt. Later staff and visitors speak of a calm figure in brown who sits or stands by a window and then is gone. Nobody knows who she might be: Florence Clayton, a nurse from the hospital years, or Emma High, who ran the boarding house, are all suggested.
The second-floor bedroom
Siler also described one bedroom on the second floor that frightens people, and the reports that cluster there are mostly sounds: doors slamming hard, boots stomping along the hall, and footsteps overhead when the upstairs is empty. Staff and guests have also described music and singing in other parts of the house. One volunteer told a later interviewer that the 1884 Mathushek piano played by itself until she asked it to stop.
The angry man in black
A tall man dressed in black, sometimes in a hat, is said to pace the upstairs landing and walk through the house as if he is furious. Some tie him to the Civil War hospital, others to the Clayton family’s troubles. As with the woman in brown, there is no record that identifies him; he is part of the house’s oral tradition.
What the investigators recorded
A local group, Paranormal Investigation and Research of Western Arkansas, has investigated the house many times. Accounts of their work mention recorded voices, including one that sounded like a cat and one that seemed to call a name, and a visitor who said her hair was tugged. A carpenter who photographed the house during repairs in 2007 or 2008 is said to have found a woman’s figure in one picture. These are claims by investigators and witnesses; none has been published in a form anyone can check.
Where to look
- Mr. Clayton's study: where the former director saw the woman, and where some staff say they smell pipe tobacco.
- The second-floor bedroom: the room most visitors find unsettling, with slamming doors and heavy footsteps.
- The upstairs landing: where the angry man in black is said to pace.
- The parlor piano: an 1884 Mathushek piano said to have played on its own.
Visiting the Clayton House
The house is open for guided tours Tuesday to Saturday from noon to 4 PM and on Sunday from 1 to 4 PM, and closed on Mondays. You can book a tour through the museum’s website or call ahead at 479-783-3000. Tours take in the parlor, sitting and dining rooms, bedrooms and staircase, with Clayton family belongings such as the judge’s walking stick, Florence Clayton’s writing desk and the family Bible.
The museum also hosts events through the year, including its Gaslight Gala in December, and the house is rented for weddings and parties. It does not run ghost tours, but local Halloween trolley tours have long included the Belle Grove district, and the house appears on many Fort Smith ghost walk itineraries. If you have an experience, the staff are used to hearing about them.
Plan an afternoon around it. The Fort Smith National Historic Site, with Parker’s courtroom, the old jail and the gallows where Clayton’s convicts were hanged, is about a mile away, and Miss Laura’s, the city’s famous former bordello, is a short drive toward the river.
- Visiting Guided tours of the house museum
- Hours and season Tuesday to Saturday noon to 4 PM, Sunday 1 to 4 PM; closed Mondays
- Ghost hunting No public ghost hunts; the house is a museum and event venue
Tips for your visit
- Ask your guide which second-floor room unsettles people, and listen on the stairs.
- Visit the national historic site the same day to see the court Clayton worked for.
- Check the museum’s events page in December for the Gaslight Gala.
- Photograph the study from the doorway; that is where the woman was seen.
- Respect the house: it is a museum and event venue, not a place for ghost hunting gear.
Go ghost hunting nearby
Visiting a haunted place by day is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through a historic building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and vigils, and gives you time to explore on your own. These are the nearest ones we run.
- Hotel Metropolitan Ghost Hunt and Sleepover, Paducah, Kentucky: investigate the historic Black-owned hotel where jazz legends stayed, with an overnight VIP option.
- Ashmore Estates Ghost Hunt, Ashmore, Illinois: six hours after dark, 8 PM to 2 AM, inside a former county almshouse and psychiatric hospital in east central Illinois.
- Old Moore County Jail and Old Lynchburg Funeral Home Ghost Hunt, Tennessee: two haunted buildings in one night: the 1893 county jail and the old funeral home across the street, from 8 PM to 2 AM.
More haunted places nearby
- Haunted places in Fort Smith: the courthouse and gallows, Miss Laura’s, the Museum of History and Fort Chaffee
- Fort Smith National Historic Site: Judge Parker’s courtroom, the Hell on the Border jail and the gallows
- King Opera House ghost hunt: our Haunted Rooms event in Van Buren, five miles away
- Haunted hotels in Arkansas: where to sleep somewhere haunted
- Haunted places in Arkansas
- Haunted places in Fort Smith
Visited one of these places? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from visitors and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your visit. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Clayton House in Fort Smith haunted?
Former director Martha Siler said she saw a woman’s apparition in Mr. Clayton’s study, and staff and visitors report footsteps, slamming doors and music in empty rooms. Those are personal accounts rather than proof, but the house has a long reputation.
Can you tour the Clayton House?
Yes. The museum offers guided tours Tuesday to Saturday from noon to 4 PM and Sunday from 1 to 4 PM. Book through claytonhouse.org or call 479-783-3000.
Who was W. H. H. Clayton?
William Henry Harrison Clayton was the U.S. Attorney in Judge Isaac Parker’s federal court at Fort Smith from 1874, with a break in the 1880s, until 1893. He later became a federal judge in Indian Territory and died in 1920.
Was the Clayton House a Civil War hospital?
Yes. The Sutton family left for Texas during the war and the house was used as a hospital. Sources disagree on whether Confederate or Union troops ran it; Fort Smith was held by both at different times.
Are there ghost hunts at the Clayton House?
No. The museum runs history tours and events only. For a public ghost hunt nearby, Haunted Rooms runs events at the King Opera House in Van Buren.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the official website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as staff, visitors and investigators tell them, and we say where records contradict a story.
- Clayton House museum: official site
- CALS Encyclopedia of Arkansas: Clayton House
- Wikipedia: W.H.H. Clayton House
- Wikipedia: W. H. H. Clayton
- 5NEWS: Haunted Arkansas, the Clayton House
- Atlas Obscura: Clayton House Museum
- History Goes Bump: Haunted Fort Smith, Arkansas (2026)
- Only In Your State: The Clayton House
Get new haunted places guides by email
New guides, haunted places to visit and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every place in our guides using official sites, historic registers, local archives and news coverage, and we report ghost stories as the stories they are. We review each guide regularly so you are not sent to a place that has closed, changed hands or banned visitors. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.

