Haunted hotel guide · Nichols, New York
Fainting Goat Island Inn: Tea-Drinking Ghosts, a Hidden Doll and America's Favorite Haunted Hotel
The Fainting Goat Island Inn is a small former railroad hotel on the Susquehanna River in Nichols, New York, now home to a herd of fainting goats and a lot of ghost stories.
The Fainting Goat Island Inn is a small former railroad hotel on the Susquehanna River in Nichols, New York, now home to a herd of fainting goats and a lot of ghost stories. USA Today readers have voted it into the top three for Best Haunted Hotel every year since 2019, with first place in 2022, 2023, 2025 and 2026. Guests describe footsteps on a staircase that no longer exists, sheets pulled off beds and two women taking tea in the night.
Fainting Goat Island Inn at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 1311 West River Road, Nichols, NY 13812
- Opened Built in the 1800s as a railroad hotel serving travelers on the Erie and Lackawanna lines; restored and reopened as the Fainting Goat Island Inn by owner Marnie Streit in 2017.
- Most haunted spots The Angora Room, the Fainting Room, the Nubian Room, the hallways and the spot where a long-gone staircase once stood.
- Best-known ghosts Two women seen and heard having tea in the Fainting Room, and a little boy that an intuitive guest described as the inn's most active spirit.
- Booking the haunted room Rooms are booked through the inn's website with a two-night minimum. Ask for the Angora Room for the most physical reports, or the Fainting Room for the tea-party ladies. Midweek stays (Monday to Wednesday) need a phone call (607-972-9849).
- Good to know The inn has four themed rooms with private baths and period furnishings, plus a downstairs lounge. It is not a B&B (homemade cinnamon buns are served in the morning) and the lounge is BYOB. The listed rate is $160 per night including taxes and fees, with $75 per extra guest. No pets are allowed, though the farm has fainting goats, potbelly pigs and Pyrenees dogs. The inn is open Thursday to Sunday and closes in March and April. Tioga Downs Casino is about a mile away.
The ghosts of Fainting Goat Island Inn
The Ladies Taking Tea
The best-known story at the inn belongs to the Fainting Room, the purple room with a private balcony over the river. According to the Haunted History Trail of New York State, guests sleeping there have been woken by the voices and visions of two women having tea. No one has put names to them, and the inn does not claim to know who they were. One guest, commenting on a Girl with the Passport review, wrote that his mother was staying in the Fainting Room in August 2022 when she asked whatever was there not to scare her and heard a man's voice reply. The travel writer behind that review stayed two nights in the same room and reported nothing at all, a reminder that activity is never guaranteed.
The Angora Room
The Angora Room opened to overnight guests in the summer of 2019, and the Haunted History Trail says that is when the physical reports began. Guests have described feeling someone sit down on the edge of the bed, having their sheets pulled off during the night, and being held down and unable to sit up. Islands, writing in 2026, repeats the reports of sheets being pulled away. A guest who stayed in the Angora Room on August 15, 2022 wrote that he felt an uneasy presence there. The room itself is painted blue, has a queen bed and an 1830s bedroom set, and looks out over the garden, which makes the stories all the more striking.
The Little Boy, the Doll and the Knife
An intuitive guest told the owners that the most active spirit in the building is a little boy, and the inn's own website mentions a child-sized chair and a little boy spirit. In the Nubian Room, guests say a small chair has moved by itself to sit beside the bed, and Islands notes reports of furniture being shifted overnight. Then there is the discovery the owners like to share on their haunted tour: a doll and a knife that were found hidden in the ceiling. Elsewhere, guests report gumballs spilling across an empty hallway floor, eyes looking back at them from mirrors, and footsteps on a staircase that no longer exists.
The most haunted rooms and places to look
The Angora Room (sheets pulled off, a weight on the bed, guests held down), the Fainting Room (two women having tea, a disembodied male voice) and the Nubian Room (a child-sized chair that moves beside the bed).
History of Fainting Goat Island Inn
The Fainting Goat Island Inn began life in the 1800s as a railroad hotel, one of the places travelers stopped along the Erie and Lackawanna Railroads in the Susquehanna Valley. It overlooks a 17-acre island in the river in the Hoopers Valley area of Nichols, close to the Pennsylvania border. Local lore links the building to the Underground Railroad, a claim owner Marnie Streit disputes, and Islands reports that it has also been described as a former morgue and brothel.
Streit bought and renovated the property and reopened it as an inn in 2017, filling it with antiques, old phonographs and a farm of rescued animals, including the fainting goats that gave it its name. It joined the Haunted History Trail of New York State, has appeared on shows including Paranormal Hotel and Scared and Alone, and has placed in USA Today's 10Best Readers' Choice Awards for Best Haunted Hotel every year since 2019.
Tips for a haunted stay
- Book the Angora Room if you want the room with the most physical reports.
- Plan for a two-night stay, and note the inn is closed Monday to Wednesday and in March and April.
- Ask about the guest-only ghost hunts and haunted tours, which run as events and are limited to 20 people.
Want to investigate, not just sleep?
Sleeping in a haunted hotel is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through the building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and lets you explore on your own during free roam.
- The Haunted Shanley Hotel Ghost Hunt: Napanoch, New York, about 106 miles away.
- Cashtown Inn Ghost Hunt: Cashtown, Pennsylvania, about 156 miles away.
More haunted hotels nearby
- Belhurst Castle: Geneva, New York, about 64 miles away
- The Naples Hotel: Naples, New York, about 66 miles away
- Erie Mansion: Clyde, New York, about 77 miles away
- Haunted hotels in New York
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Fainting Goat Island Inn haunted?
It has a strong reputation. The inn promotes its hauntings, sits on the Haunted History Trail, and guests report voices, footsteps, moving furniture and sheets being pulled off beds.
What is the most haunted room at the Fainting Goat Island Inn?
The Angora Room has the most physical reports, including a weight on the bed and sheets pulled away. The Fainting Room is known for two ghostly women having tea.
Can you go ghost hunting at the Fainting Goat Island Inn?
Yes. The owner allows ghost hunting, and ghost hunts and haunted tours are offered by event for staying guests only, limited to 20 people.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
- Fainting Goat Island Inn official site
- Fainting Goat Island Inn policies
- Fainting Goat Island Inn, Haunted History Trail of New York State
- Stay at New York's Haunted Hotels and Inns, If You Dare, I LOVE NY
- Fainting Goat Island Inn review, Girl with the Passport
- This Is The Best Haunted Hotel In America, Islands
Get new haunted hotel guides by email
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page may be affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

