Haunted hotel guide · Big Bay, Michigan

The Haunted Big Bay Point Lighthouse: Keeper William Prior and the Red-Haired Figure in the Mirror

Big Bay Point Lighthouse has stood on a bluff above Lake Superior since 1896 and is the only lighthouse bed and breakfast in Michigan.

By The Haunted Rooms Team · Updated November 2026 · How we rate hotels

3.7/5Haunted Rooms Score
1896Year built

Visit the hotel websiteMeet the ghosts

Big Bay Point Lighthouse has stood on a bluff above Lake Superior since 1896 and is the only lighthouse bed and breakfast in Michigan. Its first keeper, William Prior, vanished into the woods in 1901 after the death of his son and was found hanging from a tree more than a year later. Visitors and staff have long reported slamming doors, footsteps and a red-haired man glimpsed in mirrors.

Big Bay Point Lighthouse B&B at a glance

Haunted reputation4
History5
Ghost hunter access3
Recent activity2
Documentation4
Rates not published · check availability through the online booking linkNo pets
  • Address 4674 County Road KCB, Big Bay, MI 49808
  • Opened Light station built in 1896 (the Fresnel lens was first lit on October 20, 1896); the keeper's house opened as a bed and breakfast in 1986.
  • Most haunted spots The kitchen (cupboard doors banging in the early morning), the halls and mirrors of the keeper's house, the grounds, and the second-floor guest rooms.
  • Best-known ghosts Keeper H. William Prior (also spelled Pryor), the station's first keeper, said to appear as a red-haired figure or a man in a keeper's uniform walking the grounds.
  • Booking the haunted room There is no haunted room package and no room is named for Prior. Guest reviews on Michigan Haunted Houses describe a door rattling and slamming in the Assistant Temple room and loud banging in a room the reviewer called the captain's bedroom. Reservations are taken online only, not by phone.
  • Good to know The B&B is seasonal (the 2027 season runs May 15 to November 5) and bookings must be made through the website. Guest rooms are named for former keepers, assistants and helpers, and most include access to the 60-foot tower. Pets are not allowed. Cell service is spotty, so the owners ask guests to email first (bigbaypointlighthouse@gmail.com) and use 906-236-4322 for texts. The light is still an active aid to navigation and the site is on the National Register of Historic Places.

Visit the hotel website

The ghosts of Big Bay Point Lighthouse B&B

The Tragedy of Keeper William Prior

William Prior transferred to Big Bay Point when the station opened in 1896 and, by local accounts, was a strict keeper who fired several assistants he felt were neglecting their duties. He then took on his son, Edward George Prior, as assistant keeper. In April 1901 Edward was badly hurt in a fall on the landing crib steps and was taken to hospital in Marquette, where he died that June. Grief-stricken, William walked into the woods on June 28, 1901, reportedly carrying a gun and strychnine, and could not be found. More than a year later a skeleton in his clothing was discovered hanging from a tree about a mile from the station. Whether it was suicide or something else has never been settled.

Slamming Doors and a Face in the Mirror

The stories told about Prior's ghost are consistent across sources. Visitors and staff describe doors slamming with no cause, footsteps in empty halls and a red-haired figure reflected in mirrors, matching descriptions of the keeper himself. Overnight guests have also reported seeing a man in a keeper's uniform walking the grounds. A writer who has stayed at the lighthouse for more than twenty years says Prior is known for banging cupboard doors in the kitchen in the early hours of the morning. Wikipedia sums up the reputation simply: the lighthouse is reputed to be haunted, with a ghost seen in mirrors and doors banging in the night.

What Guests Have Reported

Guest reviews collected by Michigan Haunted Houses add first-hand detail. One guest, writing about a stay a few years before the current owner, said that in the Assistant Temple room the locked door handle rattled in the middle of the night, then the door opened and slammed shut; the owner at the time put it down to the wind. Another guest, in a review from May 2019, said they were woken by loud banging against the wall in the room they called the captain's bedroom. Not everyone is convinced. Lost in Michigan's author wrote that he was unsure the rumor was true, though he still recommended the lighthouse as a beautiful place to stay.

The most haunted rooms and places to look

No single room is officially linked to the ghost. Guest reports name the Assistant Temple room (a door that rattled, opened and slammed while locked) and a room described as the captain's bedroom (loud banging on the wall). The kitchen is where Prior is said to bang cupboard doors.

History of Big Bay Point Lighthouse B&B

The U.S. Lighthouse Board flagged a dangerous unlit stretch of Lake Superior coast between Granite Island and the Huron Islands in 1882, and the Big Bay Point Light Station was finished in 1896 at a cost of about $25,000. Its third-order Fresnel lens first shone on October 20, 1896, from a tower rising out of a red-brick duplex that housed the head keeper and an assistant. The light was automated in 1941, and in the early 1950s the U.S. Army leased the site for anti-aircraft training; a soldier stationed there was involved in the Big Bay killing that inspired the book and film Anatomy of a Murder.

In 1961 the station was sold to Chicago surgeon Dr. Jon Pick, who spent years restoring it. Dan Hitchens bought the keeper's house in 1979, and Norman and Marilyn Gotschall opened it as a bed and breakfast in 1986. The station was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1988. Nick Korstad, who has also restored Borden Flats Lighthouse and keeps Browns Head Lighthouse in Maine, took over in May 2018 and continues to run the B&B while restoring the property.

Tips for a haunted stay

  • Book early through the website, since the B&B only opens from mid-May to early November and does not take phone reservations.
  • Choose a room with tower access and climb up at sunset for the Lake Superior view.
  • Listen for the kitchen cupboards in the early morning, when Prior is said to be most active.

More haunted hotels nearby

Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened

We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.

Frequently asked questions

Is Big Bay Point Lighthouse haunted?

It has a strong reputation. Visitors and staff report slamming doors, footsteps and a red-haired figure in mirrors, said to be first keeper William Prior, who died in 1901.

Can you stay overnight at Big Bay Point Lighthouse?

Yes. It runs as a seasonal bed and breakfast, with the 2027 season running May 15 to November 5. Reservations are made online only.

Are pets allowed at Big Bay Point Lighthouse B&B?

No. The B&B states that pets are not allowed.

Sources

Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.

Get new haunted hotel guides by email

New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

About the authors

The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.

Booking links on this page may be affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.