Haunted places guide · Monticello, Drew County, Arkansas

The Haunted Allen House, Monticello: Ladell Allen's Story and Tours

On Christmas night in 1948, the builder’s daughter swallowed poison in her upstairs bedroom. Her mother locked the room for decades. Today the Allen House is often called the most haunted house in Arkansas.

By The Haunted Rooms Team · Updated November 2026 · How we rate places

4.0/5Haunted Rooms Score
1906House completed
1949Ladell Allen dies

Our nearest ghost hunt: Hotel Metropolitan, KYMeet the ghosts

The Allen House is a white Queen Anne mansion with two domed turrets on North Main Street in Monticello, a college town in southeast Arkansas. Its reputation rests on one sad, well-documented death and more than seventy years of reports from the people who lived in it afterward: tenants, a doctor, students, and since 2007 the family who own it now.

It is a private home, not a museum, but the owners open it for booked private tours and for special evenings around Halloween. This guide tells the history, the ghost stories as the owners and former residents tell them, where the facts end and the legend begins, and how to arrange a visit.

Allen House at a glance

Haunted reputation5
History3
Ghost hunter access3
Visit on a tourGhost tours
  • Address 705 North Main Street, Monticello, AR 71655
  • Built 1905 to 1906 for Joe Lee Allen, designed by Sylvester Hotchkiss
  • The tragedy Ladell Allen Bonner took mercury cyanide on Christmas night 1948 and died January 2, 1949
  • Owners Mark and Rebecca Spencer, since 2007
  • Most active spots Ladell’s former bedroom, the attic, the dining room, the downstairs bathroom
  • Reported activity A shadow man, footsteps in the attic, a crying baby, voices, moving chairs
  • Visiting Private tours by appointment; October Midnight Hour tours

Our nearest ghost hunt: Hotel Metropolitan, KY Visit / tours

History of the Allen House

Joe Lee Allen was a successful Monticello businessman who commissioned the house from architect Sylvester Hotchkiss in 1905; it was finished about 1906. At roughly 8,000 square feet, with a full attic of about 2,000 square feet, it mixes Queen Anne turrets with Gothic and Neoclassical details, including a tall portico of paired columns. Joe Allen and his wife Caddye raised their daughters here.

Their daughter Ladell married and moved away, then came home in middle age after a divorce to look after her widowed mother. Her son, Allen Bonner, died in 1944, and residents later said they heard her talking to him late at night. In 1948 she reconnected with a former sweetheart, Prentiss Savage, a married oil company executive. They wrote to each other constantly and planned a future together, but he did not leave his wife.

On Christmas night in 1948, during her mother’s holiday party, Ladell went to her upstairs bedroom and swallowed mercury cyanide, a poison then sold for medical use. It did not kill her quickly. She died in the hospital on January 2, 1949. Caddye Allen sealed the room, and it stayed shut for decades; when it was opened in the 1980s, new owners are said to have found the poison bottle still in the closet. Sources differ on the details (one calls the poison potassium cyanide, and the reopening date varies), but the outline is consistent.

After the Allens, the house was divided into apartments, then later returned to a single home. Mark Spencer, a university dean, and his wife Rebecca saw it during a job interview visit, persuaded the owner to sell, and moved in during the summer of 2007. Soon afterward Mark found a bundle of nearly ninety letters under the attic floorboards: the correspondence between Ladell and Savage, signed “Love, P.” He later wrote a book about the house, A Haunted Love Story.

The ghosts of the Allen House

Ladell Allen

Most stories center on Ladell. Tenants in the apartment years reported footsteps and moaning, and one couple said something pushed back against a closet door they were trying to close, with nobody on the other side. A well-known story says a doctor who lived in the house and dismissed the tales found a woman’s face in a mirror when he developed photographs he had taken; we could not find that photograph published. The Spencers say they believe Ladell wanted her letters found.

The shadow man

Rebecca Spencer told KATV in 2019 that she had seen a dark outline of a man, like a cowboy, five times in twelve years, and that investigators believed they had caught him on camera. Investigators have suggested as many as six presences: Joe Lee and Caddye Allen, Ladell, her son Allen, a baby and a man with a gruff voice.

Doubles, voices and a crying baby

The family describe seeing one of their sons in places he could not have been, a doppelganger story the TV show Ghost Hunters explored when it filmed the house for its ninth season. One son avoids the downstairs bathroom after hearing his name called there. Others report rocking chairs moving, footsteps in the attic and a baby crying. Ghost Hunters, notably, debunked the moving rocking chair: loose floorboards made it rock.

On television

The house has been featured on Ghost Hunters, My Ghost Story, A Haunting and Paranormal Witness, among other shows, and Arkansas Tourism says it has appeared on eight paranormal programs and been studied by twelve investigation groups. A Louisiana group reported recording dozens of voices. As always, these are claims; the strongest facts here are the letters and Ladell’s death.

Where to look

  • Ladell's bedroom: the upstairs room where she took the poison, sealed for decades and now the owners’ master bedroom.
  • The attic: where the letters were hidden under the floor, and where footsteps and slamming doors are reported.
  • The dining room: described by the owners as a hot spot during tours and dinners.
  • The downstairs bathroom: where a voice is said to have called a son’s name.

Visiting the Allen House

The Allen House is the Spencers’ home, so you cannot simply turn up. It is open for private tours by appointment: text the number on the official website with your name, preferred date and time and an email address. In 2026 the site listed private tours at $90 for up to six people and $15 for each extra guest. Park on Main Street, come through the front gate and ring the bell.

In October the house runs Midnight Hour tours that focus on the ghost stories and show Allen family artifacts, and it has opened for evening tours on Halloween night. The owners have also hosted dinners, tea parties, weddings and meetings. Paranormal groups visit by arrangement with the owners only.

Monticello is about 90 miles southeast of Little Rock. If you are touring the state’s haunted places, the Crossett Light legend is about 35 miles south, and the Gurdon Light is a couple of hours west.

  • Visiting A private home; book a guided tour by appointment
  • Tours Private tours by appointment, plus an October Midnight Hour tour of the ghost stories
  • Tickets Private tour $90 for up to six people, $15 per extra guest (2026)
  • Ghost hunting Investigations are by the owners’ invitation only

Tips for your visit

  • Book well ahead for October; Midnight Hour tours are the most popular evenings.
  • Read A Haunted Love Story before you go to know the letters’ story.
  • Never photograph or approach the house at night unannounced; a family lives here.
  • Ask to see the attic, where the letters were found.
  • Combine it with a drive to Crossett for the old railroad light legend.

Go ghost hunting nearby

Visiting a haunted place by day is one thing. Investigating one after dark is another. On a Haunted Rooms ghost hunt our team takes you through a historic building with professional ghost hunting equipment, runs EVP sessions and vigils, and gives you time to explore on your own. These are the nearest ones we run.

See all Arkansas ghost hunts

More haunted places nearby

Visited one of these places? Tell us what happened

We collect first-hand accounts from visitors and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your visit. We read every story before it’s published.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Allen House in Monticello haunted?

It is one of the most famous haunted houses in the South. Former tenants and the current owners report footsteps, voices, a shadow man and a crying baby, and Ghost Hunters investigated it. The underlying tragedy, Ladell Allen’s death in 1949, is documented; the hauntings are personal accounts.

Can you tour the Allen House?

Yes, by appointment. It is a private home, and the owners offer private tours (in 2026, $90 for up to six people) plus Midnight Hour ghost story tours in October. Book through allenhousemonticello.com.

How did Ladell Allen die?

On Christmas night in 1948 she swallowed mercury cyanide in her upstairs bedroom after her relationship with a married man, Prentiss Savage, ended. She died in hospital on January 2, 1949.

Who lives in the Allen House now?

Mark and Rebecca Spencer, who bought it and moved in in 2007. Mark found Ladell’s love letters in the attic and wrote the book A Haunted Love Story.

Was the Allen House on Ghost Hunters?

Yes. The TAPS team filmed an episode there for season nine of Ghost Hunters, recapped by SYFY in December 2014. They recorded a voice saying “please stop” and debunked a rocking chair that moved because of loose floorboards.

Sources

Facts on this page are checked against the official website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as staff, visitors and investigators tell them, and we say where records contradict a story.

Get new haunted places guides by email

New guides, haunted places to visit and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

About the authors

The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every place in our guides using official sites, historic registers, local archives and news coverage, and we report ghost stories as the stories they are. We review each guide regularly so you are not sent to a place that has closed, changed hands or banned visitors. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.