Haunted hotel guide · Dorchester, Canada
The Haunted Dorchester Jail: Sleeping in the Cells Where the Bannister Brothers Waited for the Gallows
The old Dorchester Jail in southeastern New Brunswick held prisoners for well over a century and was the scene of the province's last double hanging in 1936.
The old Dorchester Jail in southeastern New Brunswick held prisoners for well over a century and was the scene of the province's last double hanging in 1936. Today its owners rent out the old cells as a bed and breakfast, and they say knocking and strange sightings are part of daily life. Paranormal TV crews and investigators have spent the night here, and CTV News lists it among Canada's spookiest places.
Dorchester Jail Bed & Breakfast at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 4980 Main Street, Dorchester, NB E4K 2Z1
- Opened Built in 1875 as a jail, used as the provincial jail from 1880 until it closed in 1998, and reopened as a home, bed and breakfast and tour site after Bill Steele and Natasha March bought it around 2017.
- Most haunted spots The upstairs death row cells, the ground-floor cell blocks, and the grounds behind the jail where the 1936 hanging took place.
- Best-known ghosts The Bannister brothers, Arthur and Daniel, hanged at the jail in 1936, along with unexplained knocking and figures that the owners say they sometimes see.
- Booking the haunted room Overnight stays in the six jail cells and the VIP room are booked through Airbnb, linked from the jail's website. Groups can book the whole jail, and late-night tours are arranged by phone (506-213-0112).
- Good to know This is a real former jail, so expect a camping-like stay: cells are basic, and bathrooms are shared, although guests are never locked in. The building is also the owners' home. Tourism New Brunswick lists it as open year round and pet friendly, with breakfast, free parking and Wi-Fi. On arrival you ring the bell at the left inmate door. Dorchester is about 30 minutes from Moncton and close to Sackville.
The ghosts of Dorchester Jail Bed & Breakfast
The Bannister Brothers
The best-known chapter in the jail's history came on September 23, 1936, when brothers Arthur and Daniel Bannister were hanged here in what is reported to be New Brunswick's last double hanging. Arthur was 17 and Daniel 20, and they had been convicted of murder after a botched kidnapping that left three members of one family dead. According to news coverage at the time the jail reopened, the brothers were buried together in an unmarked pine box behind the building. CTV News, in its 2026 roundup of haunted places in Canada, says the jail is said to be haunted by several ghosts, the Bannister brothers among them, and their story is the one most visitors come to hear.
Knocking on the Cell Doors
Owner Bill Steele, who bought the jail around 2017 and turned it into a home and bed and breakfast with his partner Natasha March, has never been shy about its reputation. Speaking to Huddle in 2023, he said the household hears knocking on doors and sometimes sees things, adding that things happen at the jail every day. He has also been careful not to overstate it, saying he did not personally witness anything during a TV shoot. Guests sleep in the original cells behind steel doors and stone block dividers, and many come hoping to hear the knocking for themselves.
Paranormal TV and Investigations
In 2023 the paranormal series Repossessed filmed an episode at the jail, a roadshow-style segment in which people brought supposedly haunted objects from across the Maritimes to a panel of experts. Steele told Huddle that after the episode aired, a group from the United States booked the entire jail. On September 23, 2026, the 90th anniversary of the Bannister hanging, a team of paranormal investigators spent the night inside, and CTV Atlantic reported that they described the experience as pretty intense. The owners welcome such groups, and the jail's website invites anyone fascinated by haunted history to call and arrange a late-night tour.
The most haunted rooms and places to look
No single room is named as the most haunted. The upper floor holds the two death row cells where condemned prisoners spent their last 30 days, which makes that level the focus of interest, and guests can choose between the original cells and the VIP room in the former women's quarters.
History of Dorchester Jail Bed & Breakfast
The Dorchester Jail was built in 1875 in the shire town of Westmorland County and served as a federal prison for its first few years before becoming the provincial jail in 1880, around the time the larger Dorchester Penitentiary opened nearby. The ground floor had a light side with shared cells and a dark side of single cells for serious offenders, while the upper level held the warden's quarters, a men's holding area, a women's room and two death row cells. In 1936 it was the scene of the hanging of Arthur and Daniel Bannister.
The jail closed in 1998 and was sold at auction by the province in 2000. Around 2017 Bill Steele and Natasha March bought it and began renting the cells to overnight guests, keeping the steel doors, stone walls and barred windows. It has since appeared on paranormal television and in Atlantic Canadian news coverage, and it now runs as a home, bed and breakfast and tour site.
Tips for a haunted stay
- Book through the Airbnb link on the jail's website, and call ahead to add a late-night tour.
- Pack as if you were camping; the cells are basic and bathrooms are shared.
- Visit around September 23 if you want to be there on the anniversary of the 1936 hanging.
More haunted hotels nearby
- Marathon Inn: Grand Manan, New Brunswick, about 134 miles away
- The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection: St. Andrews, New Brunswick, about 135 miles away
- The Lucerne Inn: Dedham, Maine, about 215 miles away
- Haunted hotels in Canada
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Dorchester Jail haunted?
It has a strong local reputation. The owners say they hear knocking and sometimes see things, and the jail is said to be haunted by the Bannister brothers, who were hanged there in 1936.
Can you sleep in a jail cell?
Yes. Six original cells and a VIP room are rented to overnight guests through Airbnb, and guests are not locked in.
Does the jail offer ghost tours?
Yes. The jail runs late-night tours daily and welcomes groups; tours are arranged by phone.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
- Dorchester Jail official site
- Atlantic Business Magazine: Now serving guests, not sentences
- Huddle: Former Dorchester Jail featured on paranormal TV show
- CTV News: Paranormal team investigates 90th anniversary of double hanging in N.B.
- CTV News: Spooky Canada, 25 places with a haunted history
- Yahoo News: Sleeping on death row? Dorchester jail-turned-lodgings
- Tourism New Brunswick: Dorchester Jail Bed and Breakfast
Get new haunted hotel guides by email
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page may be affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

