Haunted hotel guide · Thunder Bay, Canada
The Haunted Prince Arthur Hotel: Harvey's Cigar Smoke and the Maitre d' in the Basement
The Prince Arthur opened on the Thunder Bay waterfront in 1911 as the grandest hotel between Toronto and Winnipeg, and it has hosted royalty, prime ministers and Johnny Cash.
The Prince Arthur opened on the Thunder Bay waterfront in 1911 as the grandest hotel between Toronto and Winnipeg, and it has hosted royalty, prime ministers and Johnny Cash. Local writers say two of its old regulars never checked out: a long-term resident whose cigar smoke still drifts along the second floor, and a maitre d' in an old-fashioned uniform seen in the basement corridors.
The Prince Arthur Hotel at a glance
Haunted Rooms Score
- Address 17 North Cumberland Street, Thunder Bay, ON
- Opened Opened March 14, 1911, as the Canadian Northern Railway's hotel in Port Arthur; a railway hotel until 1955 and independent since, now the Prince Arthur Hotel (formerly the Prince Arthur Waterfront Hotel and Suites).
- Most haunted spots Room 203 and the second-floor corridor, and the long basement hallways with their old tunnels.
- Best-known ghosts A long-time resident known as Harvey, linked to Room 203 and the smell of cigars, and a former employee in an out-of-date maitre d' uniform.
- Booking the haunted room Room 203 on the second floor is the room tied to the stories. There is no haunted room package, so call 807-345-5411 or email the hotel and ask for Room 203 by number.
- Good to know The hotel offers standard single and double rooms and several suite types, including Jacuzzi, executive and family suites. Original features survive, including the two-story rotunda with its marble staircase and the original dining room, and a plaque in the rotunda marks the 1921 meeting that led to Canada's first Poppy Day. The hotel faces the Thunder Bay waterfront and Marina Park. Pet policy is not stated online.
The ghosts of The Prince Arthur Hotel
Harvey and Room 203
The best-known story concerns a long-term resident who lived in Room 203 on the second floor. In a 2015 roundup of ghost stories for Northern Wilds Magazine, Elle Andra-Warner wrote that people still report smelling cigar smoke on that floor. According to the tale, when hotel staff took the man's photographs down from the walls of his old room, the room flooded, and the flooding only stopped once the pictures were hung back up. Thunder Bay's arts magazine The Walleye names him Harvey, describing him as either a former resident or a former owner who remains in his room and makes his presence known with the scent of cigars.
The Maitre d' in the Basement
Below the hotel run long, dark hallways, along with two old tunnels, one now bricked over, that once led toward the lakeshore and the neighboring Marriaggi Hotel. The Walleye reports sightings down there of a former employee dressed in an old, long out of style maitre d' uniform, as if he were still waiting to seat guests in a dining room that has long since changed. Historians think the tunnels were simply used to move goods from the docks under the railway tracks, though the hotel's own history notes that more romantic notions about them persist.
The most haunted rooms and places to look
Room 203 on the second floor, the former home of the long-term resident known as Harvey, is the only room named in the stories. Guests elsewhere on the second floor have reported the smell of cigar smoke.
History of The Prince Arthur Hotel
The Prince Arthur Hotel was born, the story goes, at a late-night poker game in 1908 aboard the private rail car of Sir William Mackenzie and Sir Donald Mann of the Canadian Northern Railway, when Port Arthur's mayor offered them a waterfront lot. Ratepayers approved the land in 1909, and the six-story brick and stone hotel, designed by J. D. Matheson of the New York firm Warren and Wetmore and built largely of concrete and marble to be fireproof, opened on March 14, 1911. It was named for Prince Arthur, Duke of Connaught, who became Governor General shortly before the opening.
The hotel hosted Prime Minister Robert Borden in 1914, King George VI and Queen Elizabeth in 1939, and performers including Duke Ellington and Johnny Cash. In 1921 a Great War Veterans Association conference held there adopted Madame Guerin's proposal for a Poppy Day, leading to Canada's first poppy campaign. The railway sold the hotel to a private Winnipeg firm in 1955, and it has operated independently ever since.
Tips for a haunted stay
- Ask for Room 203 by number when you call.
- Take a look at the poppy plaque in the rotunda on your way in.
- Walk across to Marina Park and the waterfront after dinner.
More haunted hotels nearby
- The Landmark Inn: Marquette, Michigan, about 156 miles away
- The Nahma Inn: Nahma, Michigan, about 216 miles away
- Chase on the Lake: Walker, Minnesota, about 265 miles away
- Haunted hotels in Canada
Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened
We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Prince Arthur Hotel haunted?
Local writers report cigar smoke on the second floor tied to a long-term resident called Harvey, and sightings of a maitre d' in the basement.
Which room is haunted?
Room 203, the former room of the long-term resident.
How old is the hotel?
It opened on March 14, 1911, as the Canadian Northern Railway's hotel.
Sources
Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.
- The Prince Arthur Hotel official site
- The Walleye: Haunted Thunder Bay
- Northern Wilds Magazine: Ghost Stories
- The Walleye: The Prince Arthur Hotel
- Wikipedia: Prince Arthur Hotel
- Doors Open Ontario: Prince Arthur Waterfront Hotel and Suites
Get new haunted hotel guides by email
New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
About the authors
The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.
Booking links on this page may be affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

