Haunted hotel guide · Annandale, Minnesota

The Haunted Thayer Hotel: Gus and Caroline Thayer, Miss Lily's Room and Al Capone's Third Floor

The Thayer in Annandale opened in 1895 as a railroad hotel built by Gus and Caroline Thayer, and it has survived near demolition, decades as cheap housing and years standing empty.

By The Haunted Rooms Team · Updated November 2026 · How we rate hotels

3.5/5Haunted Rooms Score
1895Year built
Room 305Most haunted spot

Visit the hotel websiteMeet the ghosts

The Thayer in Annandale opened in 1895 as a railroad hotel built by Gus and Caroline Thayer, and it has survived near demolition, decades as cheap housing and years standing empty. Staff and guests say the Thayers still greet visitors and leave pennies behind, alongside a sea captain, ghost cats and the spirits of working girls. The hotel now hosts monthly ghost tours run by the Search4Spirits team.

The Thayer Hotel at a glance

Haunted reputation3
History4
Ghost hunter access5
Recent activity3
Documentation3
$$Ghost tours or eventsHotel embraces its ghostsNo pets
  • Address 60 Elm Street West, Annandale, MN 55302
  • Opened Opened in 1895 by Gus and Caroline Thayer as a Soo Line railroad hotel, renamed the Annandale Hotel after 1920, restored and reopened as the Thayer Hotel in 1985, run as Thayer's Historic Bed n' Breakfast from 1993 to 2011, and reopened as The Thayer hotel and restaurant after a rehabilitation.
  • Most haunted spots Room 305, Room 306 (Miss Lily's Room), the Bridal Suite and the third floor, which Al Capone is rumored to have rented.
  • Best-known ghosts Founders Gus and Caroline Thayer; a sea captain; the spirits of working girls who are said to be nosy about female guests' belongings; ghost cats.
  • Booking the haunted room No haunted room package. Request Room 305 or Room 306 (Miss Lily's Room) when booking through the hotel's online reservation page or by calling (320) 274-2970. For an investigation, join the Search4Spirits haunted tour on the last Wednesday of the month.
  • Good to know Guest rooms are on the second and third floors and there is no elevator. Sources disagree on the room count (between 7 and 12 rooms, depending on the year), so check current room options when booking. The ground floor has a restaurant and bar, and the hotel offers room service. Hotels.com lists pets as not allowed. Guests must be 18 or older unless with a legal guardian, extra adults are $50 a night and children under 12 are $20 a night, and cots and cribs are not available. The old thayers.net website no longer belongs to the hotel, so use its Facebook page or online booking engine.

Visit the hotel website

The ghosts of The Thayer Hotel

Gus and Caroline Thayer, the Guardians

The founders are the hotel's best-known spirits. According to KDHL Radio in 2022, Gus and Caroline Thayer reportedly greet guests and leave pennies behind, and WJON reported the same year that they are said to act as friendly guardians of the building who help the current owner. Gus, born Albert Augustus Thayer, built the hotel with Caroline in 1895 with land and capital from the Soo Line Railroad, and sold it in 1920. Note that the Annandale Advocate reported in 2015 that no hauntings appear in the hotel's recorded history before Sharon Gammell, who owned it from 1993 to 2011, began promoting its paranormal reputation.

Miss Lily and the Working Girls

Staff say Room 306, known as Miss Lily's Room, is the most intimidating room in the building after dark, according to KDHL, and WJON reported in 2023 that staff consider it just as eerie as Room 305 next door. The hotel's lore also includes the spirits of women who entertained travelers in the railroad era. WJON reported that these spirits are said to be nosy about the belongings of female guests. No source names the women or gives dates, so this part of the story is legend rather than documented history.

Capone, the Train Wreck and the Search4Spirits Tours

A long-running rumor says Al Capone rented the entire third floor for his men. Search4Spirits investigators Russ Victorian and Mark Kolle, who began running tours at the owners' request after COVID, told KNSI in 2024 that they have asked for Capone during EVP sessions. Kolle also told KNSI that a train wreck once injured around 40 people and killed about 10, and that hotels of the era served almost as hospitals. The team reports a door slamming shut in the Bridal Suite and briefly locking tour guests inside, and Kolle's rosary beads being cut from an inner pocket of his bag and found on the floor of a top-floor room. Guests also report footsteps, thumping, a sea captain and ghost cats.

The most haunted rooms and places to look

Room 305 is described by KDHL as the room with the most reported activity; one story tells of a couple in the Jacuzzi watching the bathroom glass doors slowly close while they found themselves unable to move. Sources disagree on its name: KDHL calls it Crystal's Room, while WJON in 2023 called it the Gus room after the founder. Room 306, Miss Lily's Room, is said by staff to be the most intimidating after dark. The Bridal Suite, where a door slammed and locked tour guests in, and the third floor linked to the Capone rumor are also popular with investigators.

History of The Thayer Hotel

Gus and Caroline Thayer opened the Thayer Hotel in 1895 after the Soo Line Railroad provided land and operating capital. It had 35 guest rooms according to the Annandale Advocate (WJON says 22), a lobby with a Steinway piano, a salesmen's display room and a dining room, and it was the first building in Annandale with gas lights and electricity. Gus sold the hotel in 1920, and under Samuel Heasely it became the Annandale Hotel and declined into inexpensive housing.

By 1978 the roof leaked badly and the porches sagged. Julia Barkley helped get the building listed on the National Register of Historic Places that year, and preservationists won a legal fight a week before its scheduled demolition. The City of Annandale bought it in 1976, and a group led by Mayor Wally Houle restored it, reopening it as the Thayer Hotel in 1985 after a $550,000 project.

Sharon Gammell bought the hotel in 1993, reportedly spent $3.8 million and ran it as Thayer's Historic Bed n' Breakfast, promoting psychic medium services, ghost adventures and murder mystery dinners; WCCO-TV filmed a night there in 2004. After ownership disputes the building stood empty from 2011, its furnishings were auctioned in 2013 and Renewal Development bought it in 2015. It has since reopened as a hotel and restaurant, Search4Spirits runs monthly tours, and PBS's Hiseerie featured it in 2025.

Tips for a haunted stay

  • Book the Search4Spirits haunted tour on the last Wednesday of the month; earlier tours gave a discount with a same-night dinner receipt.
  • Ask for Room 305 or Room 306 if you want the rooms staff say are most active.
  • Keep an eye out for stray pennies, which the Thayers are said to leave for guests.
  • Pack light: rooms are on the second and third floors and there is no elevator.
  • Watch the Hiseerie episode on PBS before your stay for a look inside.

More haunted hotels nearby

Stayed in one of these hotels? Tell us what happened

We collect first-hand accounts from guests and add the best ones to our guides, with your first name and the date of your stay. We read every story before it’s published.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Thayer Hotel in Annandale haunted?

Staff, guests and the Search4Spirits investigators report footsteps, thumping, slamming doors and spirits including founders Gus and Caroline Thayer. Its hauntings were first widely promoted by owner Sharon Gammell from the 1990s.

Which room is most haunted at the Thayer?

Room 305 has the most reported activity, and staff say Room 306, Miss Lily's Room, is the most intimidating after dark.

Does the Thayer Hotel offer ghost tours?

Yes. Search4Spirits runs haunted tours year-round on the last Wednesday of every month, according to KNSI in 2024.

Did Al Capone stay at the Thayer Hotel?

It is a rumor that Capone rented the entire third floor for his men. No documentary proof is cited by the sources.

Can you stay overnight at the Thayer?

Yes. It operates as a hotel with rooms on the second and third floors and a restaurant downstairs. Hotels.com lists pets as not allowed.

When was the Thayer Hotel built?

It opened in 1895, built by Gus and Caroline Thayer with backing from the Soo Line Railroad, and is on the National Register of Historic Places.

Sources

Facts on this page are checked against the hotel’s own website, historic records and news coverage. Ghost stories are reported as guests, staff and local historians tell them. Read how we rate haunted hotels.

Get new haunted hotel guides by email

New guides, haunted hotel picks and ghost hunt dates near you. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

About the authors

The Haunted Rooms Team runs public ghost hunts and overnight investigations at historic venues across the United States. We research every hotel in our guides using hotel histories, local archives, news coverage and the accounts of guests and staff, and we review each guide regularly so you are not booking a hotel that has closed or changed its name. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.

Booking links on this page may be affiliate links. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.